Best Dissapearances Podcasts (2025)

1
After the Show: Episode 148 - Where is Amy Bradley? Plus, other Cruise Ship Dissapearances 12:34

8d ago12:34

12:34

Join Daniel and Melissa for the unfiltered, unedited, and unhinged discussion on this case. These are the conversations we used to have after we hit stop. Only now we keep recording. On this episode Melissa shows Daniel the infamous photos sent to the Bradley family back in 2005. The photos they believe are Amy. In an advertisement for a Caribbean …

1
Just Melissa- Murder at Devil's Den: The Brink Family Tragedy 10:19

4h ago10:19

10:19

When Clinton and Cristen Brink set out for a day of hiking at Devil's Den State Park, they were expecting nature, peace, and time together as a family. what happened instead was a brutal double homicide that would shake the Ozarks - and the nation.By Daniel and Melissa MacArthur

1
The MacArthur's Talk Cryptids... New Jersey 27:33

21h ago27:33

27:33

Top Ten New Jersey Cryptids Strap in and hold onto your pork roll - this week we are heading deep into the Pine Barrens, across haunted highways, and straight through New Jersey's weirdest legends and Cryptids.By Daniel and Melissa MacArthur

1
True Crime Tonight | Episode 4 | 7-31-25 13:43

3d ago13:43

13:43

Send us a text This is episode 4 of True Crime Tonight. On True Crime tonight I cover recent and past true crime stories, Horrible Fates, and so much more. Today’s video we will dive into the mysterious disappearance of Jimmy Hoffa, the 1997 NYC bombing threat, the disturbing dentist of death James Craig, and the husband killer Kathryn Restelli. We…

1
True Crime Tonight | Episode 3 | 7-29-25 10:41

5d ago10:41

10:41

Send us a text This is episode 3 of True Crime Tonight. On true crime tonight I cover recent and past true crime stories, Horrible Fates, and so much more. Today’s video we will dive into David Richard Berkowitz, otherwise known as the son of sam. We will also explore the horrifying murder of Megan Kanka, the horrible fate of Sunjay Kapur, and the …

1
True Crime Tonight | Episode 2 | 7-24-25 12:00

7d ago12:00

12:00

Send us a text This is episode 2 of True Crime Tonight. On true crime tonight I cover recent true crime stories as well as the past. Today’s video I will touch on the deaths of Ozzy Osbourne, hulk hogan, and Malcom Jamal Warner. I will also dive into the Idaho murders case and subsequent trial sentencing as well as a horrible fate and more. Welcome…

1
Episode 148- Where is Amy Bradley? Plus, other Cruise Ship Disappearances. 1:31:07

8d ago1:31:07

1:31:07

*Not your average Till Death Do Us Part episode. Think of this bad boy as a "Bonus Episode". Not as structured and full of opinions and personal antidotes. Listen at your own risk. LOL Doing something a bit different in this week's episode. Since an overwhelming number of you have messaged me about this case I decided it was time to tell Daniel and…

1
Just Melissa- The Case Against Douglas Scot Naeher 8:04

11d ago8:04

8:04

On the morning of Sunday July 20th, 2025, a fishing trip off the coast of Anna Maria Island turned into a nightmare. Douglas Scot Naeher, 60, allegedly attempted to murder his wife during an escalating boat confrontation roughly 33 miles offshore from Bean Point. With no one close enough to hear her scream, she fought back. This case is an incredib…

1
True Crime Tonight | Episode One | 7-23-25 9:34

13d ago9:34

9:34

Send us a text Welcome to The Cellar True Crime. This is episode 1 of true crime tonight. On true crime tonight I am looking to cover recent true crime stories as well as dive into the past and talk about true crime related stories that took place on this day in time. In today's video we will be discussing the infamous Cheshire murders which took p…

1
Brian Shaffer | Uncovering The Truth 43:55

13d ago43:55

43:55

Send us a text The disappearance of Brian Shaffer. He vanished without a trace, leaving behind a mystery that has baffled investigators for years. Join us as we delve into the chilling details of this perplexing case, exploring the theories and unanswered questions that continue to surround his disappearance. This is The Cellar True crime and today…

1
After the Show: Episode 147- Bryan and Jennifer Ruff with Dale and Christy Bradley 14:00

15d ago14:00

14:00

Join the MacArthur's for the unfiltered, unedited, and unhinged discussion on this case. These are the conversations we used to have after we hit stop. Only now we keep recording. The banter is about to get a little more interesting and even more dysfunctional. Listen at your own risk.By Daniel and Melissa MacArthur

1
Episode 147- Bryan and Jennifer Ruff with Dale and Christi Bradley 1:08:41

15d ago1:08:41

1:08:41

*Skip the foreplay- around the 11:00 marker. This is a guesstimation due to ad placement. Gotta make that coin! In 1991, 22-year-old security guard Bryan Ruff vanished from his post at a Utah mine called The Kennecott Copper Mine. Eighteen months later his body was found- shot and buried in the desert. It would take over a decade, a second murder, …

1
Bonus Episode- True Crime University with your host Debby: Lesson- Gender and Crime 34:34

18d ago34:34

34:34

Meet our podcast friend Debby, who weekly takes us into the classroom as she discusses a true crime case or topic. True Crime University concentrates on the psychology of criminal behavior and offender profiling. Warning: Adult language and content; listener discretion is advised. Season 3, Episode 10: Lesson- Gender and Crime In this short lesson …

1
The Unsolved Disappearance Of Suzanne lyall 20:07

19d ago20:07

20:07

Send us a text Here at The Cellar I investigate and provide strong narrative storytelling as I dive into cold cases, horrible fates, bizarre deaths, unsolved cases, and so much more. In this video I will be diving into the story of Suzanne Lyall and her true crime case that left little evidence for the police investigation. This case is as intrigui…

1
The MacArthur's Talk Haunted Locations... Arizona! 29:25

22d ago29:25

29:25

From haunted hospitals and outlaw theatres to growling desert domes, Arizona is crawling with ghosts who never got the memo to move on. In this episode Melissa dives into the top 10 most haunted locations across the desert state. You'll laugh, you'll scream, and you definitely won't be checking into room 242.…

1
Bonus Episode- It’s Always the Husband with Sarah and Megan: There's more water in the coffin than the bath 37:36

24d ago37:36

37:36

Meet our friends Sarah and Megan. The amazing and hilarious hosts of It's Always the Husband. This episode is one of Sarah's favorite Forensic Files ever, called Slippery Motives. when an "elite runner" takes his wife on a business vacation, all hell breaks loose. Towel racks, inappropriate sexual advances at funerals, piss-poor burials, The Book o…

1
Just Melissa: The murder of Katlyn Harp with an update on the case of Erin Patterson 10:55

25d ago10:55

10:55

When 33-year-old Katlyn Harp vanished after a final phone call with her sister, her disappearance raised more questions than answers. days later, her body was found sealed inside a green metal box- hidden in the woods. Her husband, Vincent Harp is now charged with her murder. In this episode Melissa unpacks the chilling investigation, digital clues…

1
After The Show: Episode 146 - Jospeh and Emily Ferlazzo with Gabby Petito and Brian Laundrie 17:32

29d ago17:32

17:32

*Remember, opinions are like buttholes; everybody has one and they all stink! Join us for the unfiltered and unedited discussion on the case. These are the conversations we used to have after we hit stop. Only now we keep recording. The banter is about to get a little more interesting and even more dysfunctional. Listen at your own risk.…

1
Episode 146- Joseph and Emily Ferlazzo with Gabby Petito and Brian Laundrie 1:21:20

29d ago1:21:20

1:21:20

**Skip the foreplay around the 10:00 mark. This is a rough guesstimation due to ad placement. Two women. Two vans. Two violent endings. In this episode, Melissa tells Daniel the haunting similarities between the chilling case of Emily Ferlazzo and the high-profile murder of Gabby Petito. Young women who set out on road trips with the men they loved…

1
Bonus Episode- Mortal Musings with Neil and Megan: Omaima Nelson and the Murder of Bill Nelson 46:30

1M ago46:30

46:30

Meet our friends Neil and Megan from Mortal Musings. Coming all the way at you from across the pond. Another true crime couple for you to adore. In today's episode we are discussing Omaima Nelson and the extremely brutal murder of Bill Nelson. This is a case that involves compassion for the difficulties that Omaima faced in her life, without attemp…

1
After the Show: Episode 145- Derrick "Ricky" and Pamela Ballin 14:25

1M ago14:25

14:25

Join us for the unfiltered and unedited discussion on the case. These are the conversations we used to have after we hit stop. Only now we keep recording. The banter is bound to get a little more interesting and even more dysfunctional. Listen at your own risk.By Daniel and Melissa MacArthur

1
Derrick "Ricky" and Pamela Ballin 1:10:38

1M ago1:10:38

1:10:38

Case begins around the 12:00 mark. This is a rough guesstimation due to ad placement. When Ricky Ballin was found bludgeoned to death in the foyer of his upscale home that he shared with his wife Pamela in Lithonia Georgia, the story just didn't add up. Especially when Pamela told police she had hidden in the upstairs closet during the entire attac…

1
Just Melissa- The Horrific Murder of Julian Story 6:20

1M ago6:20

6:20

When former Beauty and the Geek Australia contestant Tamika Chesser moved back in with her ex-boyfriend Julian Story, no one expected it to end in horror. But in June 2025, police discovered Julian’s dismembered and burned body in the bathroom of his South Australia apartment—and his head was missing. Now, Tamika stands charged with murder and dese…

1
The MacArthur's Talk Cryptids... Arizona! 24:50

1M ago24:50

24:50

From haunted camels to horned rabbits with a vendetta, Melissa is diving deep into the dusty weirdness of Arizona's wildest legends. Join us as we count down the Top 10 Cryptids lurking in the Grand Canyon State - including ghost dogs, desert bigfoot, La Llorona, and the ever sassy jackalope. It's spooky, it's funny, a bit dysfunctional, and it wil…

1
Just Melissa- The Poop Cruise 10:41

1M ago10:41

10:41

In this episode Melissa talks about the true tale of the Carnival Triumph disaster, aka the "Poop Cruise". An engine fire, no working toilets, and the phrase "biohazard bag" used unironically- let's dive into what went wrong, what passengers endured, and the lawsuits that followed.By Daniel and Melissa MacArthur

1
Bonus Episode- Mama Mystery with Kelly Evans: The Suspicious Disappearance of Kyron Horman 54:54

1M ago54:54

54:54

*Bonus Episode- meet Mama Mystery with Kelly Evans In this episode, we're diving deep into the haunting disappearance of Kyron Horman, the 7-year-old boy who vanished from Skyline Elementary School in Portland Oregon, on June 4th, 2010. After posing proudly in front of his science fair project, Kyron seemingly vanished into thin air sparking Oregon…

1
Horrible Fates | The Boston Molasses Disaster Of 1919 9:51

1M ago9:51

9:51

Send us a text Welcome to The Cellar True Crime. In today's episode of Horrible Fates, I am focusing in on a singular story that dives into The Great Molasses Flood, otherwise known as The Boston Molasses Disaster of 1919. I hope you all enjoy the story! The great Molasses Flood. The Boston Molasses Disaster. A collection of horrible fates. A colle…

1
Horrible Fates 7 | Trapped and Alone 17:06

1M ago17:06

17:06

Send us a text Welcome to The Cellar True Crime. In today's video I will be discussing 4 different stories that all share a common thread of being trapped and alone. A collection of horrible fates. Bizarre Deaths. Horrifying ways people have died. #horriblefates #acollectionofhorriblefates #collectionofhorriblefates #markwells #ashersullivan #willi…

1
Just Melissa- The arrest of Barry Morphew for the murder of his wife Suzanne Morphew 10:33

1M ago10:33

10:33

Suzanne Morphew vanished on Mother's Day 2020. Her husband Barry said she went for a bike ride and never returned. Now, five years later-with the discovery of her body and tranquilizers found in her system-he's charged with murder... again. Was this a deadly coverup or a wrongful accusation? Listen as Melissa breaks down the evidence, timeline, and…

1
5 True Crime Documentaries You Must Watch 9:47

1M ago9:47

9:47

Send us a text I will be discussing 5 True Crime Documentaries that I highly recommend you take the time to watch. In sharing some of my favorites right now, I hope to hear from you all in the comments section. Let me know what your favorites are! Have you enjoyed any of the ones I shared in today's video!? #truecrimedocumentaries #truecrimepodcast…

1
Horrible Fates 6 16:15

1M ago16:15

16:15

Send us a text A collection of horrible fates. Bizarre Deaths. Horrifying ways people have died. In today's video I will be discussing 4 different stories. From dangerous lawn mowers, to a mysterious bridge, each story in today's video ultimately ends in a Horrible Fate. #horriblefates #acollectionofhorriblefates #collectionofhorriblefates #scaryst…

1
Just Melissa: With Special Guest Daniel- Update on the case of Aaron and Victoria Goodwin 13:08

2M ago13:08

13:08

Melissa gives Daniel an update on this shocking case. Listen as Melissa takes Daniel inside the emotional courtroom showdown where Aaron confronts the woman who plotted his murder face-to-face. Hear powerful statements from both sides and the final sentence. Get the full case: Episode 140- Aaron and Victoria Goodwin…

1
Horrible Fates 4 18:34

2M ago18:34

18:34

Send us a text A Collection Of Horrible Fates. Welcome back to The Cellar True Crime. Today we will be diving into a collection of horrifying real life stories. Each story in today's podcast ultimately ended in a horrible fate. We will discuss three stories resulting in absolutely horrific and bizarre deaths. Worst ways to die. Horrible fates. #hor…

1
The MacArthur's Talk Haunted Locations... Tennessee 41:00

2M ago41:00

41:00

Join your favorite dysfunctional couple, the MacArthur's, as they take a haunted road trip through the spookiest back roads and hot spots of beautiful Tennessee. The "Volunteer" state has a Bell Witch. Ghosts on the Chattanooga Choo Choo. A haunted bathtub. Civil War soldiers who are still living the same day over and over again. And we end with a …

1
Just Melissa: The Strange Case Surrounding the Death of Mica Miller 13:20

2M ago13:20

13:20

A lot of you have been asking and due to some strange and interesting news I decided to look into the case a bit. Wow! So many red flags. *Always remember, opinions are like buttholes. Everybody has one and they all stink.By Daniel and Melissa MacArthur

1
After the Show: Episode 144- Ryan Jenkins and Jasmine Fiore 14:15

2M ago14:15

14:15

Join us for the unfiltered and unedited discussion on the case. These are the conversations we have after we press stop. Only now we keep recording. The banter is bound to get a little interesting and even more dysfunctional. Listen at your own risk.By Daniel and Melissa MacArthur

1
Ryan Jenkins and Jasmine Fiore 1:11:18

2M ago1:11:18

1:11:18

Case begins around 11:00 **this is subject to change due to ad length, but this is a good guesstimation. On this episode of Till Death Do Us Part Melissa tells Daniel the case that rocked the reality television world. When a young woman is found stuffed in a suitcase at the bottom of a Los Angeles dumpster, investigators get to work trying to figur…

1
The MacArthur's Talk Cryptids... Tennessee 27:57

2M ago27:57

27:57

Tennessee are you ready? We have 6 of your most famous cryptids. Plus, lots of dysfunctional banter. You're welcome!By Daniel and Melissa MacArthur

1
The Unsolved Disappearance Of Ben McDaniel | Cave Diving Nightmare 24:31

2M ago24:31

24:31

Send us a text Welcome back to The Cellar True Crime. In this video we will be diving into one of the most mysterious cave diving stories of all time. This is the story of Ben McDaniel and his final dive in the Vortex Spring cave. Bizarre unsolved mysteries. Vanished. Mysteries. Worst ways to die. Horrible fates. #benmcdaniel #vortexcave #cavedivin…

1
Bonus Episode- Crime and Coffee Couple: The Murder of April Milsap 46:16

2M ago46:16

46:16

*Episode Swap with our friends Mike and Allison from Crime and Coffee Couple. Listen as Allison takes Mike through the ends and outs of the horrific murder of 14-year-old April Milsap. And how a fitness tracking app on April's phone led to the conviction of her killer. Mike and Allison have become really great podcasting friends of ours, and we dec…

1
Just Melissa- The Official Pardon of Todd and Julie Chrisley 7:32

2M ago7:32

7:32

Obviously, there is way more to this case than just 7 minutes but here's what we know now about the presidential pardon of the Chrisley's. I'll have more on this story as soon as they are released.By Daniel and Melissa MacArthur

1
After The Show: Episode 143- David and Penelope Jackson 19:08

2M ago19:08

19:08

Join us for an unfiltered and unedited discussion on the case. These are the conversations we have after we hit stop. Only now we keep recording. Bound to get a little interesting and even more dysfunctional. Listen at your own risk. *I did find the points read by the judge during Penelope's sentencing hearing. Very interesting.…

1
David and Penelope Jackson 1:26:02

2M ago1:26:02

1:26:02

Case begins around 15:00 ** this can change due to ads, but this is a good guesstimation. On this episode Melissa tells Daniel the ends and outs of the case that had the people of Great Britain on the edge of their seats. The case officially known as The Bubble and Squeak Murder. On a cold winter's night in February of 2021, a call came into the lo…

1
Just Melissa: The Murder of Valeria Marquez 15:15

3M ago15:15

15:15

Thanks to armchair investigators on social media this case is gaining much needed traction. Is beauty and style influencer Valeria Marquez's murder a cartel hit or possibly a case of jealousy and envy? Perpetrated by the people who she trusted the most? I have a feeling we will know very soon.By Daniel and Melissa MacArthur

1
The MacArthur's Talk Haunted Locations... Kentucky 37:32

3M ago37:32

37:32

Haunted Locations begin around the 6:00 mark. **This can change due to ads, but this is a good guesstimation. Kentucky!!! You sly minx. You have some amazing haunts. This was fun! Once again, the MacArthur's are ridiculous and go off the rails. Enjoy the dysfunction.By Daniel and Melissa MacArthur

1
Creepy Unsolved Disappearances | Thomas Messick 20:42

3M ago20:42

20:42

Send us a text Today we are diving into the absolutely puzzling case of Thomas Messick. Thomas Messick was an 82 year old army vet who disappeared while on a hunting trip with 6 of his closest friends and family. He vanished with no trace of him ever being found. If you enjoy the video please like, subscribe and let me know what you think in the co…

1
Just Melissa- The resentencing of Lyle and Erik Menendez 7:56

3M ago7:56

7:56

I had to do it! A little background on the case and the update many of us have been waiting for. Good or bad.By Daniel and Melissa MacArthur

1
After the Show- James and Beverly Jean Long 18:55

3M ago18:55

18:55

Join us for an unfiltered and unedited discussion on the case. Hear the conversation after we really should have hit stop. Disclaimer: Opinions are like buttholes; everybody has one and most of them stink.By Daniel and Melissa MacArthur

1
James and Beverly Jean Long 1:07:56

3M ago1:07:56

1:07:56

Case begins around the 13:00 marker. Factoids- On this episode Daniel talks about lawn mowers. I know!! In January of 2003, a call came into the Butts County 911 call center. A structure was on fire and someone was trapped inside. Firefighters and medical personnel were immediately on the scene. Found inside the shop was the charred remains of a bo…

1
Just Melissa- The Case Against Joshua Lee Hunsucker and an update on the Erin Patterson case in Australia 10:46

3M ago10:46

10:46

A husband and father, in North Carolina, has been accused of the first-degree murder of his wife and the attempted murder of his daughter. His 32-year-old Wife Stacy, died suddenly at home. Her death was initially attributed to a heart attack. But Stacy's mother was suspicious and reported her daughter's death to the authorities. Plus, an update on…

Podcasts Worth a Listen

Dissapearances Podcasts

Podcasts Worth a Listen

Quick Reference Guide