Best Infamous Indy Podcasts (2025)

1
30: The Jail 36:42

2M ago36:42

36:42

Join us on Episode 29 of Digging Up Dillinger as we explore the infamous Crown Point Jail and John Dillinger's daring escape. See the history come alive!In this episode, we uncover the fascinating story of John Dillinger's escape from the Crown Point Jail. Watch as we delve into the history of this infamous criminal and his daring prison break!In t…

1
29: The Letters 51:06

3M ago51:06

51:06

Melvin Purvis was a ladies man, Who knew?! This episode we go over some letters Todd discovered in the Dillinger files. If you love history this is the episode for you!By Infamous Indy

1
28: The Grave 43:46

3M ago43:46

43:46

A new found article showcases what Dillinger's grave looks like underground! What a huge find for the team and as the weather warms a trip to the gravesite is in order!By Infamous Indy

1
27: The Indiana State Museum SUCKS! 45:37

4M ago45:37

45:37

The Indiana State Museum is the WORST! I can't believe this is an episode we have to cover but this organization sucks. After contacting Travis to inquire about the alleged Dillinger baseball glove, the Museum gives us the run around,making us jump through hoops for nothing. Money, not History, seems to be the motivation, you be the judge.…

1
26: The Pendulum 43:11

4M ago43:11

43:11

The gang brings in a "Pendulum Dousing" experts to see if we could get a lead from the "otherside"! An interesting tactic used by law enforcment and FBI investigators for decades. The team asks a few serious questions at the end to see if we could get a lead on John Dillinger's death.By Infamous Indy

1
25: The Truth Seekers 46:01

5M ago46:01

46:01

The gang is back after a long holiday break. This episode we give the updates we've been working on as a crew and new insight into the crazy 16 hour TikTok Ban of 2025.By Infamous Indy

1
24: The Fix 43:29

6M ago43:29

43:29

Crime historian Paul Maccabee spent 12 years researching his book, “John Dillinger Slept Here: A Crooks Tour of Crime and Corruption in St. Paul” – based on tens of thousands of FBI files released to him under the Freedom of Information Act and interviews with more than 200 police officers, gun molls, retired FBI agents and family members of Public…

1
23: The Derringer 23:45

6M ago23:45

23:45

Mike puts on a 'Show and Tell' with some real-life Dillinger artifacts. This episode is best enjoyed on our YouTube channel.By Infamous Indy

1
22: The Pants 42:47

7M ago42:47

42:47

The gang hangs out again after a short break, this time going over the details of the recent DNA results. The DNA comes from the pants John Dillinger was wearing the night he was allegedly shot at the Biograph Theater.By Infamous Indy

1
21: The K9 Search Part 2 48:30

7M ago48:30

48:30

The gang talks to the Director and Founding Director of Indiana K9 Search and Recovery, the team that helped us search the Dillinger family property.By Infamous Indy

1
20: The K9 Search 46:13

8M ago46:13

46:13

This week's episode, Sherry McCollum joins the gang to talk about the resent K9 search on the old family farm property in Moorsville Indiana.By Infamous Indy

1
19: The Johnny Depp Story 42:10

8M ago42:10

42:10

The gang starts the episode discussing the famous Johnny Depp and his involvment with the Thompsons. Could getting a hold of the actor pay off in the end for the new age Dillinger Crew?By Infamous Indy

1
18: The Map Part 2 50:02

8M ago50:02

50:02

The Gang revists the Mapp discussion after Joe pulls it out the safety deposit box. Specifically we examine the timeline and cities associated with the Dillinger gang to see if there are any connections to the information left behind.By Infamous Indy

1
17: The Mike Thompson Interview Part 2 42:41

9M ago42:41

42:41

Nephew of John Dillinger joins us on the podcast for another round. We hit him with some viewer questions and discuss some of the artifacts hidden in Mike's garage.By Infamous Indy

1
16: The Mike Thompson Interview 50:39

9M ago50:39

50:39

The closest living relative of John Dillinger, Mike Thompson sits down with the gang to talk about the podcaat! A huge wealth of knowledge, Mike brings us stories and facts we have been dying for!By Infamous Indy

1
14: The University Chicago Library 40:12

9M ago40:12

40:12

Auther Ron Offen, co-author of the book 'Dillinger: Dead or Alive' had some serious writer credits. Much of his research and papers are stored in one place, The University of Chicago Library. Joe takes a trip to the college to dive into what they have in the special research section. The Gang dicusses the findings and if it means anything to the in…

1
14: The Melvin Pervis Article 39:22

9M ago39:22

39:22

The Gang takes on some new research. Our own Todd Hiles found a news article buried in the FBI files showcasing what Melivn Pervis says happend to Dillinger. The interesting part is, all of it is on the record, but does that make it true? We dive deep on this episode of Digging Up Dillinger.By Infamous Indy

1
13: The Map 46:56

10M ago46:56

46:56

Imagine one day your digging on the family farm, with a film crew filming, and all of a sudden you put your shovel in the ground and 'Crack'! A ball jar is under the ground and a piece of american history is sitting right at your feet. That is exactly what happened at the Dillinger family farm and to our own Stewart Fillmore. This episode we talk a…

1
12: A Hollywood Persepctive with Paul Lima 51:13

10M ago51:13

51:13

Throughout this case, Hollywood has tried to help tell the story of these two mysteries. Paul Lima was the producer at the forefront of the first real attempt at this case being on TV. He joins the gang for an interview to talk about the project he was a part of.By Infamous Indy

1
11: The Fillmore Report Part 8: The Al Feeney Letter 35:34

10M ago35:34

35:34

On December 3, 1949, the Mayor of Indianapolis, Indiana, Al Feeney, wrote a letter to Terre Haute, Indiana Mayor Ralph Tucker. The letter was relatively short> Was it a hoax, a joke? Was it a secret? The gang covers the letter in the best way they how!By Infamous Indy

1
10: The Fillmore Report Part 7: The Imposter Selfie 54:09

10M ago54:09

54:09

In July 1959 and July 1963, two handwritten letters were received by the Indianapolis Star newspaper and Emil Wanatka Jr., respectively, by someone claiming to be Dillinger. Both letters were signed “John H. Dillinger.” Although I am not a handwriting expert, my analysis and observation of certain specific characteristics of the handwriting in the …

1
9: The Mystery Turns 90 Years Old 41:04

11M ago41:04

41:04

The team gets together on John DIllinger's Death anniversary to answer viewer questions and remember the gangster as this mystery turns 90 years old.By Infamous Indy

1
8: The Fillmore Report Part 6: The Fingerprints 33:39

11M ago33:39

33:39

The FBI's use of John Dillinger's fingerprints marked a significant milestone in law enforcement history, highlighting the effectiveness of fingerprint identification in solving crimes. Dillinger, a notorious American gangster during the 1930s, was known for his string of bank robberies and escapes from custody, making him a high-profile target for…

1
7: The Fillmore Report Part 5: The Missing Tooth 52:28

11M ago52:28

52:28

John Dillinger's missing tooth became an intriguing aspect of his legend. During his criminal career in the early 1930s, Dillinger's missing front tooth became a distinctive feature that often helped authorities and the public identify him. According to reports, he lost this tooth during a confrontation with police or during a scuffle in prison, de…

1
6: The Fillmore Report Part 4: The Heart 39:55

11M ago39:55

39:55

The next part of the Fillmore Report focuses on the heart condition reported by the autopsy physician. The discrepancies continue, and the new-age Dillinger gang is working through the case.By Infamous Indy

1
5: The Fillmore Report Part 3: The Eyes 37:11

11M ago37:11

37:11

The eyes are the windows to the soul and that saying is true in this case. The person shot on July 22nd was reported to have brown eyes, which difers from everything known about John DIllinger. We go over more of the report put together by reired FBI agent Stewart Fillmore.By Infamous Indy

1
4: The Fillmore Report: Part 2 The Ears Part 2 52:54

12M ago52:54

52:54

Another deep dice into the Fillmore Report. The ears are so different but is it the smoking gun for our case? Follow along as we dive deep into the details surrounding the imposter theory.By Infamous Indy

1
3: The Fillmore Report Part 1: The Ears 43:06

12M ago43:06

43:06

The Fillmore Report as we call it was put together and written by our own Stewart Fillmore. It is the basis of our arguments about if John Dillinger was shot at the Biograph Theater on July 22, 1934. Stewart will explain why he wrote the report and go over the first of the major arguments.By Infamous Indy

1
2: Dillinger History 101 51:37

12M ago51:37

51:37

This episode we focus on the basics of the John Dillinger Story. We want everyone to be caught up so they can listen to the rest of the show with this basic knowledge. From his birth, to his jail time, to his bank robbing, to his death, we cover it all this episode. This is the perfect place to start if you are just jumping in!…

1
1: The Two Mysteries 27:01

12M ago27:01

27:01

Welcome to the Digging Up Dillinger Podcast, presented by Infamous Indy. Host Joe Melillo introduces the new Dillinger Gang of 2024, Travis Thompson, the Great-Nephew of 1930's gangster John Dillinger, Retired FBI agent Stewart Fillmore and Retired Secret Service Agent Todd Hiles. We will start this journey with a quick introduction to the team and…

1
Digging Up Dillinger Coming soon June 22nd 2024! 0:52

12M ago0:52

0:52

Welcome to the Digging Up Dillinger Podcast, presented by Infamous Indy. Host Joe Melillo introduces the new Dillinger Gang of 2024, Travis Thompson, the Great-Nephew of 1930's gangster John Dillinger, Retired FBI agent Stewart Fillmore and Retired Secret Service Agent Todd Hiles. We will start this journey with a quick introduction to the team and…

1
34: Wanted in Indiana Infamous Hoosier Fugitives with Author Andrew Stoner 42:24

4+ y ago42:24

42:24

For the second time Author Andrew Stoner joins Joe and the Infamous Indy Podcast to talk about his new book being released on March 15th, 2021 "Wanted in Indiana; Infamous Hoosier Fugitives". Hear about a jail break where the prisoner couldn't escape because he was too fat. Andrew reveals why he does so much research, it comes down to his love of I…

1
33: Digging Up Dillinger - Part 3 1:10:25

4+ y ago1:10:25

1:10:25

Part 3 of the Digging Up Dillinger series continues the conversation as Mike Thomason and Travis Thompson discuss with Former FBI agent Stewart Fillmore and Local Documentary film Maker Scott Umsteadt the details of digging up the Infamous John Dillinger. An incredible story told in their own words. Brought to you exclusively from Infamous Indy Hos…

1
32: Digging Up Dillinger - Part 2 1:19:02

4+ y ago1:19:02

1:19:02

Why did Mike and Travis Thompson, Nephew and Great-Nephew of Infamous Bank Robber John Dillinger, want to dig up their relative? Hear the answer in their own words. Many believed it was for money, fame and notoriety, the real reason will surprise you. Is John Dillinger buried at Crown Hill Cemetery? Find out what the family thinks in this exclusive…

1
31: Digging Up Dillinger - Part 1 1:44:10

4+ y ago1:44:10

1:44:10

After a 12 Month hiatus Host of the Infamous Indy Podcast, Joe Melillo is back with an exclusive never heard perspective from some of the most famous Hoosiers around. The nephew of John Dillinger Infamous Hoosier bank robber is speaking to Joe in his own words about why they wanted to dig up John Dillinger's body out of Crown Hill Cemetery. Joining…

1
30: Notorious 92 Author Andrew E. Stoner 1:02:17

5y ago1:02:17

1:02:17

Notorious 92, is a book written by Author Andrew E. Stoner. Andrew E. Stoner is an Indiana native well-versed in the true crime history of the state, both as a former reporter for The South Bend Tribune, and as the former civilian Public Information Officer for the Indianapolis Police Department. He is the author of nearly a dozen non-fiction works…

1
29: An Interview with an Italian in Quarantine 36:53

5y ago36:53

36:53

Covid-19 is sweeping across the world and this week Infamous Indy reaches across the world to bring you the latest from Italy. Joe talks to his Friend Luca who is quarantined in his apartment in Rome. Also your chance to get involved on the Infamous Indy podcast. Call Joe and leave a message about whats happening in your part of the world. Weather …

1
28: Understanding Suicide with Kennedy Harris 39:19

5+ y ago39:19

39:19

If you or someone you know is struggling with their mental health and need help please contact the National Suicide Prevention Hotline @1- 800-273-8255. Indiana’s suicide rate has been higher than the national average since 1999. According to the 2009 “Indiana Youth Risk Behavior Survey,” 22% of girls and 12% of boys surveyed in grades 9-12 serious…

1
27: The Burger Chef Murders with Circle City Crime 55:27

5+ y ago55:27

55:27

This episode Joe talks to the host and researcher behind the Circle City Crime Podcast. His podcast focuses on the 1879 murders of four fast-food restaurant workers who were abducted in Marion County but murdered in Johnson County. We go over some of the main details but suggest you listen to the 3C podcast to get the full details. Both Infamous In…

1
26: Running back to Life with Wes Doty 1:10:07

5+ y ago1:10:07

1:10:07

An amazing story of strength and recovery with someone who knows it first hand. He was once stealing from others to feed his addiction but now he uses running to heal. He is Running in the 2020 Boston Marathon and Wes Doty needs your help. I hope this episode moves you like it has moved me.By Joe Melillo

1
25: Tony Kiritsis with News Photographer Jack Parker 1:15:10

5+ y ago1:15:10

1:15:10

On a very cold day in February 1977 Tony Kiritsis paraded Dick Hall down the streets of Indianapolis with a shotgun aimed at the back of his skull. And the man who captured the truly first of its kind moment, was Jack Parker, News photographer for Channel 4.By Joe Melillo

1
24: The Story of Jill Coy 26 years later 1:15:45

5+ y ago1:15:45

1:15:45

A terrible story of obsession that turned to murder. Signs of something more sinister and a 14-year-old boy caught in the middle. This week we talk about the tragic end of Jill Coy because of domestic violence. Jill’s Son Jason Cottingim talks to me 26 years after the murder. He tells me he has never spoken out about this publicly since the day his…

1
23: A Very Hoosier Crime Podcast 55:05

5+ y ago55:05

55:05

What is it that makes me do what I do? It is kind of weird how many other True Crime Podcasts about Indiana there are. That’s because there is a lot to talk about in the Hoosier State. This episode four different true crime podcasts get together to talk and give our listeners insight on why we do what we do. Cold Case Chronicles, 3C Podcast and Hoo…

1
22: Chrystal O'keefe and "The Murderer Across the Hall" 45:54

5+ y ago45:54

45:54

Remembering Heather Norris, who was murdered by her abuser and boyfriend in his home in Irvington Indiana. Chrystal talks about her experience living with the murderer just a short time after he committed the crime in the basement of the home. Chilling story from someone who lived it.By Joe Melillo

1
21: Doug Kouns on the Katy Collman Murder 52:54

5+ y ago52:54

52:54

Retired FBI Agent and now Private Investigator talks with Joe about a case from 2005. Katlyn Collman went missing after walking to the store in Southern Indiana, she was abducted raped and murdered. Police got a confession from a man named Charles Hickman, but in a twist, he was NOT the murderer. Kouns talks about his time with Hickman and why some…

1
19: Bonus: Joker (2019) Movie Review 32:36

5+ y ago32:36

32:36

Hiow does this fictional movie look and feel like the real life monsters we talk baout on infamous Indy? Find out in this bonus episodeBy Joe Melillo

1
18: The Case of Shannon Hall with Colleen Stine 49:11

5+ y ago49:11

49:11

On July 27th, 2014 David Hall And his two sons Ten-year-old Connor and wight-year-old Danny, were out for some farther son time. This happened more often because David and his Ex-wife Shannon a second-grade teacher in Fishers Indiana had just finalized their divorce. That night as David was dropping his sons off at the home on Somerset way in Carme…

1
17: Richard Essex on Marcus Schrenker 47:42

5+ y ago47:42

47:42

Wealthy Indianapolis businessman Marcus Schrenker's life was imploding around him. So, he hatched a plan to get away from all his troubles. Faking his own death. The problem was he didn’t do it very well. Joe Interview's current WISH-TV reporter Richard Essex about his time covering the case for WTHR, the NBC affiliate in Indianapolis. We also talk…

1
16: Eat Right Now Podcast 1:00:18

6y ago1:00:18

1:00:18

Joe sits down with the members of the "Live Right now" Podcast Wendell Fowler and Alan Haw. On their show they talk about Food, Faith and everything in between. It is a much different kind of episode than other Infamous Indy Episode. Keeping the the True Crime genre, Joe focuses on how we can use food and the positive healthy living the LRN podcast…

1
15: Human Trafficking with Body Language Expert Lisa Mitchell 56:54

6y ago56:54

56:54

This week Joe is joined by his wife, Carrie Melillo and Lisa Mitchell, Body Language Expert. She describes a time when her work became more than just theory, Lisa used her training in a real world setting and recognized something was wrong with a couple who walked into the same store as her. Lisa teaches us how to stay vigilant and know the signs w…

Podcasts Worth a Listen

Infamous Indy Podcasts

Podcasts Worth a Listen

Quick Reference Guide