Best Cracking Cryptids Podcasts (2025)

1
528 // Zodiac Killer Unmasked?! 1:19:13

22h ago1:19:13

1:19:13

Welcome to Crawlspace. In this new episode, Tim Pilleri & Lance Reenstierna speak with old friend Mike Morford about his investigation into the identity of the Zodiac killer. Morf has an extensive history of covering the Zodiac case, including having written a book on it: https://www.amazon.com/Case-Zodiac-Killer-Photographs-Criminology/dp/19472905…

1
Ghost Hands 31:00

22h ago31:00

31:00

Story One – What Killed Olivia Mabel? One afternoon in 1994, a series of silent 911 calls from a remote Texas property would result in several police officers descending upon the scene. What they found after breaking in through the front entrance, would shock them to their core and leave them questioning what killed Olivia Mabel. Story Two – The St…

1
SPECIAL ANNOUNCEMENT! 2:46

1d ago2:46

2:46

Welcome to this SPECIAL ANNOUNCEMENT! On Wednesday, June 11th @ 8pmEST, we are hosting a virtual fundraising event for the non-profit organization, Private Investigations for the Missing. We will be joined by... Julie Murray https://www.mediapressure.com/ Bobby Taghavi https://sweetjames.com/attorney/bobby-taghavi/ Dr. Trace Sargent https://publica…

1
527 // Elizabeth Short, The Black Dahlia 1:01:32

4d ago1:01:32

1:01:32

Welcome to Crawlspace. In this new episode, Tim Pilleri & Lance Reenstierna speak with playwright and actress Marissa Alaniz about Elizabeth Short (also known as The Black Dahlia), her murder, and Marissa's play called "Elizabeth". Check out Marissa's work at marissaalaniz.com. Follow Marissa on Instagram: https://www.instagram.com/malanizofficial.…

1
273: Wolf Out! 30:51

4d ago30:51

30:51

The episode where Sarah brings us a story we’ve never done before…a werewolf. Meet William Ramsey, your typical English gentleman who just so happens to be a wolf. Listen, this is one of those episodes you need to watch on Spotify so you can fully appreciate our howling and wolf impersonations. There’s so many jokes, and we get to talk about the Wa…

1
526 // The Man Who Outgrew Robbing Banks w/ Joe Loya 1:07:56

8d ago1:07:56

1:07:56

Welcome to Crawlspace. In this new episode, Tim Pilleri & Lance Reenstierna are joined by new friend, Joe Loya. Mr. Loya is an author (The Man Who Outgrew His Prison Cell), Hollywood consultant (Baby Driver), prolific bank robber and ex-convict. He is the subject of Orbit Media's podcast series, The Burden - Get The Money and Run. Joe recalls his c…

1
The McGuire Air Force Base Encounter 33:45

8d ago33:45

33:45

There have been multiple alleged interactions which are reported to have taken place between the US military and extraterrestrial visitors. These include the supposed crash of a UFO near to Roswell in New Mexico, and the craft that was encountered by US servicemen in Rendlesham Forest near RAF Woodbridge. In this episode we examine yet another such…

1
525 // America's First Serial Killer w/ Christopher Daley 1:00:54

11d ago1:00:54

1:00:54

Welcome to Crawlspace. In this new episode, Tim Pilleri and Lance Reenstierna are joined by a new friend of the show, Mr. Christopher Daley. Christopher is a historian, public speaker, author and educator. The conversation is about America's first serial killer, not HH Holmes as most people believe. This individual's name is Franklin Evans. Evans c…

1
272: Horridge House Part 2 On Location 27:16

11d ago27:16

27:16

The episode where we return to the Horridge House in Vinton, Iowa. We haven’t been to Horridge House since 2021 so it was time for a return visit. Check out episode 95 for all the history behind this place and how our first investigation went. This time we had two changes: 1. We brought our new friend: Lauren! She’s our (lightly) haunted doll and w…

1
English Civil War - Part 1 (ship money) 1:01:01

13d ago1:01:01

1:01:01

This week, we start a series on the English Civil War and focus on the fighting between King Charles I and the Parliamentarians.By HOOT Studios

1
524 // The Prison Break of Leroy Chasson w/ Daniel Zimmerman 1:02:24

15d ago1:02:24

1:02:24

Welcome to Crawlspace. In this new episode, Tim Pilleri & Lance Reenstierna are joined by new friend of the show, Mr. Daniel Zimmerman. On Sept. 6th, 1982, Leroy Chasson escaped from Walpole Prison in Massachusetts, one the most violent and notorious prisons in the country. With his wife masquerading as a nurse and brandishing a .45 automatic pisto…

1
A Crack in the Slab 34:30

15d ago34:30

34:30

Time, for most of us, feels like the one true constant - a steady progression from past to future. Yet throughout history, people have reported moments where time - and perhaps even reality - seems to falter. Some claim to have been pulled into the past or thrust briefly into the future. Others describe slipping into worlds that look almost like ou…

1
523 // NESK - Brainscratch Collab - Is There a New England Serial Killer? 1:48:23

17d ago1:48:23

1:48:23

In this new episode Tim Pilleri, Lance Reenstierna, and Mike Morford speak on John Lordan's Brainscratch Youtube show about the possibilities of a new and active serial killer in New England. Check out this episode on John Lordan's LordanArts channel: ⁠https://youtu.be/YyXvnuLC7Po⁠. Follow John Lordan's work: ⁠https://linktr.ee/lordanarts⁠. Follow …

1
522 // The 10ish Podcast - 10 Weirdest Town Names in America 1:09:52

18d ago1:09:52

1:09:52

Welcome to Crawlspace...and the 10ish Podcast! Back in July of 2023, the creator of the 10ish Podcast invited Tim Pilleri & Lance Reenstierna onto his show and they brought with them their top ten list of the weirdest town names in America. This is that episode. The three hosts discuss how each town got its name, fun facts about each town, key peop…

1
271: Hot Smelly Boyz Summer 21:46

18d ago21:46

21:46

The episode where Linda brings us some true crime in the form of an unsolved mystery. This is the story of the Lead Mask case in Brazil. We may have other names for the case, so media, consult us next time you need naming help. Really, if you don’t know by now, naming things is kinda our calling. This story has everything: aliens, conspiracy, and g…

1
521 // NESK - Reviewing Expert Insight in New England Serial Killer Case 1:09:43

19d ago1:09:43

1:09:43

In this new episode Tim Pilleri and Lance Reenstierna speak about the possibilities of a new and active serial killer in New England. We also play clips from Lance's conversation with expert Dr. Michael Arntfield that aired on ⁠Crawlspace⁠ on May 18th, 2025. Mike brings his unique and specialized insight into not only the dynamics of how the discov…

1
Ballen Studios Presents: A Twist of History 5:21

21d ago5:21

5:21

The course of history never follows a straight line. These are the epic stories that have shaped the world we now live in. From Ballen Studios, join us - for the most heart pounding podcast in history. New episodes every Wednesday. Listen now: ⁠https://ballen.lnk.to/atwistofhistory Learn more about your ad choices. Visit megaphone.fm/adchoices…

1
520 // The Anatomy of a Romance Scam w/ Brian Haugen & Andy Robertson 1:11:06

22d ago1:11:06

1:11:06

Welcome to Crawlspace. In this new episode, Tim Pilleri & Lance Reenstierna have a wild conversation with Brian Haugen and filmmaker Andy Robertson. Brian is the central character in an elaborate plot to scam women across the globe. Andy directed the docu-series on Hulu, "Hey Beautiful - Anatomy of a Romance Scam" which tells the story of Brian and…

1
Bottomless 33:14

22d ago33:14

33:14

For decades, paranormal researchers have heard tales of a strange anomaly in the hills of central Washington - a hole so deep that it devours everything thrown into it, and which seems to possess supernatural powers. In the late 1990s, a man named Mel Waters came forward, claiming to own the land upon which the bottomless pit resides. But after goi…

1
Sharks (we're gonna need a bigger podcast) 1:14:01

25d ago1:14:01

1:14:01

This week, we discuss sharks!!! Need we say more?By HOOT Studios

1
519 // From MISSING / The Disappearance of Diane Augat 1:00:50

25d ago1:00:50

1:00:50

Welcome to Crawlspace. This episode is a bonus taken from the recent archives of our other show, Missing (https://open.spotify.com/show/0yRXkJrZC85otfT7oXMcri?si=b585ed1c21db4e4a) which aired on 4/10/25. Tim Pilleri and Lance Reenstierna discuss the mysterious disappearance of Diane Augat from Hudson, Florida on April 10th, 1998. This episode was r…

1
Big Announcement for Season 2 of Milkhouse Podcast! 0:27

25d ago0:27

0:27

Mark your calendars! The Milkhouse Crew returns with video content starting June 8th! #milkhouse #90skids #nostalgiaBy Milkhouse Crew

1
270: Deadward Smitherhands 34:33

25d ago34:33

34:33

The episode where Sarah brings us the Curse of the White Star Line. If you’ve never heard of this, it’s okay because Sarah made it up but we’re trademarking it. The name is ours but the curse is real (probably), and it’s the story of the Titanic and its two sister ships, the Dicktanic and Satanic. Okay, jk, it’s actually the Britannic and the Olymp…

1
Milkhouse Ep. 12 – Finale: A Look Back at Milkhouse History (Feat. Brian!) 1:06:42

25d ago1:06:42

1:06:42

Join us for a hilarious journey through Milkhouse history, filled with storytelling, laughter, and the kind of nostalgia that takes you back to being a kid. #podcast #indiana #90skids #highschool #prank #growingup Subject Time Stamps: History of The Milkhouse - 01:22 Stories from The Milkhouse - 20:35 Milkhouse Food/Snack - 41:54 Summer Vacation - …

1
518 // Expert Insight on New England Serial Killer w/ Dr. Michael Arntfield 56:48

29d ago56:48

56:48

Welcome to Crawlspace. In this new episode, Lance Reenstierna is joined by the great Dr. Michael Arntfield, a criminologist, author, consultant and award-winning professor at Western University in Canada as well as a Fulbright Scholar and previous visiting chairman at Vanderbilt University in Nashville where he specialized in victimology and Americ…

1
The Khamar-Daban Mountain Deaths 36:28

29d ago36:28

36:28

In August 1993, a group of kayakers from Ukraine travelled to Irkutsk in Southern Siberia. Whilst enjoying the river and scenery south of Lake Baikal, they came across something haunting: a 17-year-old girl, covered in blood and mumbling incoherently about a tragedy that had befallen her and her friends. Her name was Valentina Utochenko, and the te…

1
517 // The King of The Thrill Pill w/ Shaahin Cheyene 1:06:03

1M ago1:06:03

1:06:03

Welcome to Crawlspace. In this new episode, Tim Pilleri & Lance Reenstierna are joined by a truly fascinating individual, Mr. Shaahin Cheyene. In the 1990s, when Shaahin was 17 years old, he created a drug which was a natural alternative to MDMA called Herbal Ecstasy. The success of his product was meteoric, the fame and money flooded in. Before he…

1
269: No Body, No Crime (Sticky Situation) 28:24

1M ago28:24

28:24

The episode where Boydston brings us a smorgy crime…aka a smorgasbord with a true crime thrown in! We’re gonna go to one of our favorite countries to discuss the Great Canadian Maple Syrup Heist. Yes, you read that right. Canada, you’re adorable and we love you. Taking place over several months, this is how over $18 million worth of syrup was stole…

1
Milkhouse Ep. 11 - The Strangest History You've Never Heard Of 1:05:10

1M ago1:05:10

1:05:10

In this episode, we dive headfirst into the bizarre side of history—stories so strange, they sound made up. We kick things off with the infamous Great Emu War of Australia, where birds outmaneuvered the military. Then, we explore Stalin’s chilling quest to create superhuman hybrids, blending science fiction with Soviet ambition. Then, we meet Wojte…

1
516 // Continuing Coverage of Possible Active Serial Killer in New England 53:27

1M ago53:27

53:27

In this new episode, Tim Pilleri & Lance Reenstierna discuss updates on the possibility of a new and unidentified serial killer in New England. This is part 3 of a special report we're doing on the possibility of a new and active serial killer in New England. On March 6th, 2025 the remains of a woman were found near Norwalk, Connecticut by Norwalk …

1
515 // All The Poisons! w/ Prof. Deborah Blum 1:06:17

1M ago1:06:17

1:06:17

Welcome to Crawlspace. In this new episode, Tim Pilleri & Lance Reenstierna are joined by new friend of the show, Prof. Deborah Blum. Deborah is the Director of the Knight Science Journalism at MIT in Cambridge Massachusetts. Deborah is also a prolific writer and an expert on the wonders and the deadly nature of all the poisons! Check out all of De…

1
The Vanishing of Doveland 33:30

1M ago33:30

33:30

Plenty of towns have disappeared over the years. In most cases, the explanations range from economic problems to government initiatives to resources drying up. But what about the towns that truly and quite literally vanished without a trace? It’s not as rare a phenomenon as some people might think. And for thousands of people in the U.S. state of W…

1
514 // Grasping Bigfoot w/ Dr. John Baranchok 1:07:28

1M ago1:07:28

1:07:28

Welcome to Crawlspace. In this new episode, Tim Pilleri & Lance Reenstierna are joined for the first time by Dr. John Baranchok, a neuropsychologist and clinical psychologist who now uses his scientific approach to break down how to research and responsibly encounter the elusive Bigfoot. Check out John's work here: https://hangar1publishing.com/col…

1
268: Cambre House and Farm On Location 34:05

1M ago34:05

34:05

The episode where we share our recent investigation at Cambre House in Nauvoo, Illinois. This place is a haunted wedding venue, so we of course had to spend the night! Who knew that the history behind this place involves a utopian society that gives off culty vibes. We saved Sarah from joining yet another cult. Through our investigation, you’ll mee…

1
Milkhouse Podcast Ep. 10 - Cryptids you’ve never heard of — and ones you wish you hadn’t 1:23:59

1M ago1:23:59

1:23:59

We’re back with another episode of Milkhouse! First up, our take on the Predator: Badlands teaser — what we loved, what we’re curious (or worried) about. Then we dive into the world of cryptids: Giants stomping through folklore, the Jersey Devil screeching in the Pine Barrens, Loch Ness doing its thing, and the creepy little Pukwudgie lurking in th…

1
513 // The Crack City Strangler Benjamin Atkins w/ B.R. Bates 1:07:02

1M ago1:07:02

1:07:02

Welcome to Crawlspace. In this new episode, Tim Pilleri and Lance Reenstierna speak with author B. R. Bates about her new book on serial killer Benjamin Atkins. Her book is called The Crack City Strangler, and it's the second in her series on Murders in the Motor City. Don't miss B. R. tell us about her book the Babydoll Serial Killer on episode 48…

1
Roadways and Waterways 41:27

1M ago41:27

41:27

Story One – The Manchester Pusher Over the past decade, close to a hundred people have lost their lives in the canal network of one northern English city. In this chapter, we examine evidence, which suggests that a significant number of these deaths were the work of one person, the Manchester Pusher. Story Two – The Uniondale Hitchhiker The N9 is o…

1
512 // Updates on Possible Active Serial Killer in New England 46:21

1M ago46:21

46:21

In this new episode, Tim Pilleri & Lance Reenstierna discuss updates on the possibility of a new and unidentified serial killer in New England. On March 6th, 2025 the remains of Paige Fannon are found near Norwalk, Connecticut by Norwalk police scuba team and fire rescue team. Authorities located clothing and personal items left on the bank of the …

1
511 // The Blood In The Water w/ Casey Sherman 1:04:19

2M ago1:04:19

1:04:19

Welcome to Crawlspace. In this new episode, Tim Pilleri & Lance Reenstierna are joined once again by renowned journalist & author, Casey Sherman. Casey’s latest book, Book in the Water tells the tragic story of Nathan Carman and the fall of the Chakalos family. You can pick up Casey’s book at you local book seller or at the following: https://www.a…

1
267: No Pants Jennifer 29:32

2M ago29:32

29:32

The episode where Sarah brings us an unsolved true crime. This is the Oslo mystery woman case, aka the Jennifer Fairgate case. It’s May 1995, Oslo, Norway. A mysterious woman checks into the hotel and is found dead, alone, in her room. To this day, we still don’t know who she is. Government conspiracy? Possibly. Really what we do know is that she i…

1
Milkhouse Ep. 9 - What If the Zombie Apocalypse Started Tomorrow? 1:11:07

2M ago1:11:07

1:11:07

Imagine waking up tomorrow to a world in chaos — empty streets, emergency alerts flashing across your phone, and survival becoming your new reality. In this episode, we dive headfirst into the ultimate "what if" scenario: a sudden zombie apocalypse. We'll break down the weapons we'd choose for defense, the safest places to bunker down, the survival…

1
510 // Missing Dorothy Arnold 1:14:58

2M ago1:14:58

1:14:58

Welcome to Crawlspace. In this episode originally published on Missing on April 3rd, 2025, Tim Pilleri and Lance Reenstierna discuss the mysterious disappearance of Dorothy Arnold from Manhattan, New York City on December 12th, 1910. If you enjoyed this episode, make sure to subscribe to Missing. This episode was researched by Kathleen Studer. Sour…

1
National Delicacies (southern cough syrup) 1:07:19

2M ago1:07:19

1:07:19

This week, we continue our series on national delicacies and explore some cocktails and entrees from around the world.By HOOT Studios

1
509 // Is There a New Serial Killer in New England? 46:28

2M ago46:28

46:28

In this new episode, Tim Pilleri and Lance Reenstierna discuss the possibility of a new and unidentified serial killer in New England. Since March of 2025 at least six bodies have been found and people have starting wondering if there was a serial killer. We discuss each case and weigh the possibilities of foul play. On March 6th, 2025 the remains …

1
508 // The Trials of Karen Read w/ Brad Mielke 1:03:28

2M ago1:03:28

1:03:28

Welcome to Crawlspace. In this new episode, Tim Pilleri & Lance Reenstierna are joined by ABC journalist Brad Mielke to discuss the phenomenon that is the second trial of Karen Read. In the early morning hours of January 29, 2022, Boston Police Department Officer John O'Keefe was found dead outside the home of Boston Police Officer Brian Albert in …

1
What Happened to the Jamison Family? 32:21

2M ago32:21

32:21

During the closing stages of 2009, a family residing in Oklahoma vanished under suspicious circumstances, leaving little clue as to what had happened to them. When evidence of their tragic fate did eventually surface five years later, it only prompted further questions as to what exactly had transpired, rather than providing any useful answers. Joi…

1
507 // The Blazing Eye w/ Leah Sottile 1:08:54

2M ago1:08:54

1:08:54

Welcome to Crawlspace. In this new episode, Tim Pilleri & Lance Reenstierna are joined by journalist, author, podcaster and new friend of the show, Leah Sottile. Leah has written a new book called Blazing Eye Sees All. Sottile seeks to understand the quest for New Age spirituality in an era of fear that has made us open to anything that claims to b…

1
266: The Hills are Alive (pt 2) 40:22

2M ago40:22

40:22

The episode where we finish our story on the Hills and their alien abduction. Make sure you catch last week’s episode to hear Boydston start the story (or you might be confused). This episode, we will discuss the aftermath of the abduction. We get to learn more about the humanoids..who are just teen emo alien cadets who have a lot of feelings. They…

1
Milkhouse Ep. 8 - Raising Kids in a Pre-Google World ft. Steve-Oh! 55:48

2M ago55:48

55:48

In this episode of Milkhouse, we dive into a 90's parent's perspective on raising kids in a pre-big tech world. Steve-Oh reflects on what parenting was like without smartphones and shares stories about family vacations and the simpler, sometimes tougher, days of the past. He also gets nostalgic—and hilariously honest—about 90s kids' foods, from his…

1
506 // The Redemption of a Felon w/ Jonathan Schwartz 1:17:58

2M ago1:17:58

1:17:58

Welcome to Crawlspace. In this new episode, Tim Pilleri & Lance Reenstierna are joined by Jonathan Schwartz, the former business manager of high profile clients like Alanis Morissette, Beyonce, Linkin Park, Halsey and more. In 2017 Schwartz pled guilty to embezzling nearly 5 million dollars from Morissette and was sentenced to 6 years in prison. He…

Podcasts Worth a Listen

Cracking Cryptids Podcasts

Podcasts Worth a Listen

Quick Reference Guide