Best Stephen Moriarty Podcasts (2025)

1
93. Debbie Wolfe 51:26

9d ago51:26

51:26

On December 26th, 1985, 28-year-old nurse Debbie Wolfe left work in Fayetteville, North Carolina. Days later, her body was recovered, and law enforcement treated her death as an accident despite the suspicious circumstances. What happened to Debbie Wolfe? Follow us on Instagram ! Sources: https://www.fayobserver.com/story/news/2019/10/26/body-in-ba…

1
92. Kelly Moriarty and Doris Carter 41:47

23d ago41:47

41:47

In mid-December 2011, a Florida couple, Kelly Moriarty and Doris "Pat" Carter, disappeared. Weeks passed before they were reported missing, causing a delay in the investigation. Suspicion has fallen on some of Pat's family members, but no one has been charged, and the case remains unsolved. Instagram Sources: https://www.newspapers.com/image/319150…

1
91. Markia Benson 44:27

1M ago44:27

44:27

On March 30th, 2016, 36-year-old Markia Benson was found murdered in her Upper Darby, Pennsylvania apartment. The nature of the crime led the police to believe Markia's killer was full of rage. The investigators have a strong person of interest, but the case remains unsolved. Who killed Markia Benson? Instagram Email: [email protected] Sources…

1
90. Barbara Holik 38:59

2M ago38:59

38:59

On June 23rd, 1995, 33-year-old Barbara Holik met up with friends at a restaurant in Taos, New Mexico. Barbara was never seen again after leaving the restaurant. What happened to Barbara Holik? Email: [email protected] Instagram Sources: https://www.doenetwork.org/cases/3896dfnm.html https://www.newspapers.com/image/505988370/ https://www.news…

1
You Should Read: Something, Probably 46:59

2M ago46:59

46:59

Send us a text Hi, Should-Heads! We're here with an unfortunate episode. We're not reading the way we should and we're trying to get that back. We're discussing the things that have worked for us in the past and what new ideas we may try. If you've got any ideas, please text us (the link is here in the notes!). We'll also happily take any book reco…

1
89. Michelle Witherell 52:33

2M ago52:33

52:33

On December 19th, 1992, 24-year-old Michelle Witherell went out to dinner in Monroeville, Pennsylvania with her husband. Hours later, she was found deceased outside of her apartment from an apparent fall. Did Michelle die as a result of a tragic accident or was she murdered? Instagram Email: [email protected] Sources: https://www.newspapers.co…

1
You Should Read: Our Favorite 2025 Books and Our Summer TBR! (With Kathy Coe) 1:23:10

3M ago1:23:10

1:23:10

Send us a text Should-Heads, this is probably going to be a dangerous episode for you to listen to. First, our favorite reading enthusiast Kathy Coe is back, so automatically, you know it'll be fun. We've got a list of the best books we've read so far this year and the five books we're each most excited to read before Labor Day. LINKS MENTIONED: AI…

1
88. Attiin Shaw 33:39

3M ago33:39

33:39

On September 8th, 2021, 33-year-old Attiin Shaw was last seen by her husband at their home in Washburn, Maine. There have been zero signs of life since her disappearance. What happened to Attiin Shaw? Instagram Support the show! Sources: https://www.nbcnews.com/dateline/missing-in-america/authorities-search-washburn-maine-residence-connection-2021-…

1
You Should Read: Anything We Suggest; Happy Birthday To Us! 1:20:12

3M ago1:20:12

1:20:12

Send us a text We can't believe it, Should-Heads, but our podcast is five years old! We discuss our favorite episodes and guests, plus goals of where we would like to go from here. We've also got very fun stories about Julia, forever our Kristy Thomas. LINKS MENTIONED: Baltimore convention goes very wrong Judy Blume's novel Forever... is on Netflix…

1
87. Sean Drenth 1:02:38

3M ago1:02:38

1:02:38

On October 10th, 2010, Phoenix Police Sergeant Sean Drenth was found shot to death in an alley near the end of his shift. The investigation that followed focused on the key question: Did Sean die by suicide, or was he a homicide victim? Email: [email protected] Instagram Sources: https://mediaassets.abc15.com/html/pdf/autopsyreport.pdf https:/…

1
You Should Read: Stephen King (a starter kit for beginners!) 1:14:39

3M ago1:14:39

1:14:39

Send us a text You Should Read: Stephen King! (With special guest Mom of the Pod Becky Hall)! Should-Heads, our favorite mom is back to discuss Stephen King! We've got great recommendations for you and no matter your comfort level with horror, there are a handful of stories you'll love without losing any sleep. Links mentioned: John Lithgow Open le…

1
You Know What We Should Read? We Don't! (With Kathy Coe) 1:04:11

4M ago1:04:11

1:04:11

Send us a text Hello, Should-Heads! We had such a great time with this episode a few weeks back that we decided to make it a regular feature. Our friend Kathy came back to help us choose what our next reads should be and we discuss how this experiment went last time. Also, you can text the podcast now! There's a link in each episode's show notes. F…

1
86. Bill Dwayne Shipley 41:14

4M ago41:14

41:14

On July 19, 2011, 47-year-old Bill Dwayne Shipley vanished from Goldsby, Oklahoma. He was scheduled to start a painting job out of state but never arrived. What happened to Bill Shipley? Instagram Sources: https://www.newson6.com/story/5e35b05c83eff40362bec648/publics-help-needed-in-finding-missing-goldsby-man https://www.news9.com/story/5e34e9cce0…

1
85. Heather Uffelman 33:59

4M ago33:59

33:59

On October 24th, 1992, 22-year-old Heather Uffelman and her fiancé, Jeremy Rolfs, traveled to Marietta, Georgia, to sell computer equipment to a man who identified himself as Tom Johnson. They met Tom at a motel where he attacked them - Jeremy survived the attack, but Heather succumbed to the injuries. The killer fled and remains unidentified. Inst…

1
You Should Read: Our Favorite Books from Jennifer Weiner and Liane Moriarty (a Starter Kit episode)! 1:00:37

4M ago1:00:37

1:00:37

Send us a text Should-Heads, we’ve talked about doing starter kit episodes for years but we’re finally doing it! Every starter kit episode will feature at least one but usually two authors with extensive backlists and we’ll help you figure out where to start. Links mentioned: The Testaments: https://variety.com/2025/tv/news/handmaids-tale-sequel-th…

1
84. Stephen Spina 36:23

4M ago36:23

36:23

On September 17, 2007, 36-year-old Stephen Spina, a well-known postal worker, was found stabbed to death in his Mamaroneck, New York apartment. Despite numerous leads, no arrests have been made. Email: [email protected] Instagram Sources: https://www.newspapers.com/image/915924790/?match=1&terms=Stephen%20Spina https://www.newspapers.com/imag…

1
You Should Read: Fanfiction! (With Amanda!) 1:15:30

4M ago1:15:30

1:15:30

Send us a text As you know, we’re very in love with books…but we’re also in love with TV and movies. When we find a fictional place that feels like home, sometimes we find additional stories that let us stay there a bit longer. Our friend Amanda stops by to discuss her favorite fanfic stories. Links: Independent Bookstore Day catalog https://www.bo…

1
83. Fiona Yu 37:21

4M ago37:21

37:21

On August 4th, 1997, college student Fiona Yu was murdered and sexually assaulted in her Tempe, Arizona apartment. Despite DNA evidence at the scene, her case remains unsolved. Who killed Fiona Yu? Email: [email protected] Instagram Sources: https://www.newspapers.com/image/124177972/?match=1&terms=Fiona%20Yu https://www.newspapers.com/image/1…

1
Replay: Mont Highley IV 46:24

5M ago46:24

46:24

This episode originally aired in June 2024 On November 28th, 2003, 33-year-old Mont Highley IV headed to his family's hunting trailer in rural Macon County, Alabama. He planned to hunt with his father the following day, but when his father arrived Mont was nowhere to be found. What happened to Mont Highley IV?…

1
You Should Read: Our Favorite Books from Book of the Month Club! (With Mom of the Pod Becky!) 1:05:52

5M ago1:05:52

1:05:52

Send us a text Hello, Should-Heads! We're giant fans of the Book of the Month Club and we've been subscribers for years. Mom of the Pod Becky comes on and we discuss our favorite picks and the ones we hope to get to soon. Book News: Tori Woods and Daddy's Little Toy And there's an update! She was arrested. For Fun! Mom's Advent Calendar Minisode Ep…

1
82. Nancy MacDuckston 32:45

5M ago32:45

32:45

On August 11th, 2003, 52-year-old Nancy MacDuckston took a day trip to one of her favorite parts of Santa Cruz County, California. Witnesses spotted Nancy throughout the day, but she hasn't been seen since. What happened to Nancy MacDuckston? Instagram Sources: https://www.newspapers.com/image/81118044/?match=1&terms=Nancy%20MacDuckston https://www…

1
You Should Read: All the Book News! (a minisode) 40:02

5M ago40:02

40:02

Send us a text You Should Read: All the Book News! (a minisode) Should-Heads, you wouldn't believe what's going on these days. There's so much book news that we needed a special episode just to break it all down. (And as a bonus, Rachael and Kelly give an update on how their reading resolutions are going.) STORIES MENTIONED: Roxane Gay's book list …

1
81. Kyle Morgan 33:10

5M ago33:10

33:10

On June 16th, 2016, 15-year-old Kyle Morgan was found dead under the Fort Henry Bridge in Wheeling, West Virginia. The exact circumstances surrounding Kyle's murder remain unknown, but his family continues to seek answers. Sources: https://www.wtrf.com/ohio-county/four-years-and-no-new-leads-a-look-back-on-the-kyle-morgan-case/ https://www.wtrf.com…

1
You Know What We Should Read? We don’t! (With Kathy Coe) 1:09:53

5M ago1:09:53

1:09:53

Send us a text We’re not sure if there’s ever been a time when Rachael, Kelly AND our guest host Kathy have all been unsure of what to read next. Fortunately, we’re better at choosing for other people… Twitter and Instagram: wysr_podcastBy Kelly Hager, Julia Hall, Rachael Hall

1
80. Amy Gellert 54:42

5M ago54:42

54:42

On March 20th, 1994, 21-year-old Amy Gellert was stabbed to death outside of her home in Cocoa Beach, Florida. Her parents were attacked moments earlier but managed to survive. There are multiple suspects yet no one has been arrested in relation to Amy's murder. Instagram Email: [email protected] Sources: https://www.newspapers.com/image/17844…

1
You Should Read: Books About Friendship (with Bekki) 1:00:48

5M ago1:00:48

1:00:48

Send us a text Hi, Should-Heads! Kindred Spirit of the Pod Bekki joins us to discuss books about friendship. We examine the differences between friendship and found family and, of course, a lot of book recs. Twitter and Instagram: wysr_podcastBy Kelly Hager, Julia Hall, Rachael Hall

1
79. Cherryl Pearson 35:11

5M ago35:11

35:11

On January 5th, 2002, 37-year-old pediatrician Cherryl Pearson disappeared from her home in Bartlett, Tennessee. Her absence was surprising, as she was supposed to watch her sister's children that morning. Could the last phone call Cherryl received be the key to her disappearance? Email: [email protected] Instagram Sources: https://www.newspap…

1
You Should Read: Books About Love by Black Authors (With Dr. Nae!) 1:00:44

6M ago1:00:44

1:00:44

Send us a text Welcome back Should-Heads! Today we are joined by Dr. Sherna Ann Phillips to discuss more books by Black Authors! This time we are focusing on books that highlight different types of Love. Enjoy! Twitter and Instagram: wysr_podcastBy Kelly Hager, Julia Hall, Rachael Hall

1
78. Phyllis Ward 38:57

6M ago38:57

38:57

On July 23rd, 2012, neighbors of 74-year-old Phyllis Ward saw smoke billowing from her home in Boise, Idaho. Inside, the police found Phyllis's body. Who killed Phyllis Ward? There were some unresolvable audio issues in this episode, mostly in the first five minutes but a few throughout as well. Thank you for understanding. Sources: https://www.new…

1
You Should Read: Books with AI (with Martha Brockenbrough!) 1:13:46

6M ago1:13:46

1:13:46

Send us a text Should-Heads, this episode will take you on quite a journey. AI has been increasingly prevalent and controversial of late, and so we talked to author Martha Brockenbrough about what all this means and what, if anything, can be done. Links mentioned: No more blurbs: https://lithub.com/in-a-dazzling-move-simon-schuster-is-dropping-thei…

1
77. Patricia Jauron 38:45

6M ago38:45

38:45

On May 26th, 1998, 45-year-old Patricia Jauron met someone at her old home in Sioux City, Iowa. This person wanted to buy a waterbed she was looking to sell. Not long after, her husband found her body in the yard outside of the home. Who killed Patricia Jauron? Email: [email protected] Instagram Sources: https://www.newspapers.com/image/336971…

1
"We Listen and We Don't Judge" - Bookish Bad Habits (With Christa!) 40:20

6M ago40:20

40:20

Send us a text We’ve got a confession, Should-Heads. We’re not perfect. Our friend Christa joined us to discuss our bad book habits. We listen and we don’t judge (mostly). Twitter and Instagram: wysr_podcast

1
You Should Read: Y.A. Horror (A Kelly Wheelhouse Episode)! with Amanda! 1:01:40

6M ago1:01:40

1:01:40

Send us a text Should-Heads, have you ever wondered what’s wrong with Kelly? (It’s okay; she wonders too.) This episode answers that question. DISCLAIMER: Please forgive our sound and editing mishaps this episode - we were having some technical difficulties. We love you, Should-heads! Twitter and Instagram: wysr_podcast…

1
76. Jacob Cabinaw 1:00:11

6M ago1:00:11

1:00:11

On March 31st, 2010, 31-year-old Jacob Cabinaw played disc golf in Traverse City, Michigan. After the game, he set out on a cross-country journey for reasons unknown. Why did Jacob Cabinaw leave Traverse City, and where is he? Instagram Email: [email protected] Sources: https://www.record-eagle.com/news/local_news/10-years-gone-seeking-jacob/a…

1
75. Brandy Dyson 32:22

7M ago32:22

32:22

On November 5th, 2005, 32-year-old Brandy Dyson was found deceased in Lake Charles, Louisiana. Her manner of death was ruled a homicide, and a few months later, the key suspect was arrested in relation to her murder. He was set free after new evidence emerged, and the case remains unsolved today. Special thanks to Brandy's daughter, Holly, for spea…

1
You Should Read: Our Last Zodiac Books (with Kendell)! 1:11:26

7M ago1:11:26

1:11:26

Send us a text Well, Should-Heads, we’re finally doing our last Zodiac recommendations, so if you’re a Taurus, Leo or Aquarius, you’ll want to take some notes. Links mentioned: Neil Gaiman. Vulture posted an article where they spoke with four of the five women who have accused Neil Gaiman of sexually assaulting them. The article is explicit in spel…

1
74. Louise Chaput 41:32

7M ago41:32

41:32

On November 15th, 2001, 52-year-old psychologist Louise Chaput headed to the White Mountains in New Hampshire for a weekend of hiking. When she didn't return home a few days later, her partner reported her as a missing person. Not long after, her body was found near where she was last seen in New Hampshire. Instagram https://www.newspapers.com/imag…

1
You Should Read: Books About Pop Culture! (With Kristine Kittridge!) 57:24

7M ago57:24

57:24

Send us a text Should-Heads, you know how much we love pop culture. It’s probably our favorite thing (except for books, obviously). Our friend Kristine came back to discuss our favorite books centering around pop culture (both nonfiction and fiction and dealing with any facet of pop culture). Links mentioned: Emily Henry’s Having a Moment Twitter a…

1
73. Raymond Lamar Green Jr. 36:23

7M ago36:23

36:23

On November 6th, 1978, Raymond Lamar Green Jr. was abducted from his Atlanta, Georgia home at just five days old. His abductor has evaded police for nearly 47 years. Raymond's mom holds out hope that he is alive and well, unaware of his true identity. Instagram Email: [email protected] Sources: https://www.newspapers.com/image/506907213/ https…

1
You Should Read: Overdue Books (with Amanda Hutson) 57:30

7M ago57:30

57:30

Send us a text We hate to admit this, Should-Heads, but we can’t read everything. Today, Rachael and Kelly are joined by their friend Amanda to discuss the books they haven’t read. What are some of your overdue books? Links Mentioned: Fable controversy Fable site Bookly Goodreads Storygraph Twitter and Instagram: wysr_podcast…

1
72. Jaspal and Geeta Singh 36:20

7M ago36:20

36:20

On January 23rd, 2007, married couple Jaspal and Geeta Singh were murdered in their Syosset, New York home. The couple had no enemies and were well-liked in their community. Who killed the Singhs? Instagram Sources: https://www.newspapers.com/image/730431883/?match=1&terms=Jaspal%20and%20Geeta%20Singh https://www.newspapers.com/image/713830172/?mat…

1
BONUS: Julia Tribute Episode 1 47:00

7M ago47:00

47:00

Send us a text Welcome back, and today we have a very special episode. One year ago today, we lost our beloved cohost/sister/friend Julia. Today we have just a few of her many loved ones on to talk about some bookish memories in her honor. Please enjoy this trip down memory lane with us. Side note: We recorded these about 8 months ago so keep that …

1
You Should Read: Our Most Anticipated 2025 Releases! 1:13:46

7M ago1:13:46

1:13:46

Send us a text Hey Should Heads! Welcome back. Today we are joined by our tastemaker of the pod, Kathy Coe! Kathy is here to help us discuss the books we are most excited to see released in 2025! You won't want to miss this one. Follow Kathy @glassofwine81 on social media! Twitter and Instagram: wysr_podcast…

1
71. Dylan Ellis and Oliver Martin 42:44

8M ago42:44

42:44

On June 13th, 2008, Dylan Ellis and Oliver Martin were shot to death in Toronto, Ontario. To date, the police haven't established a motive behind the murders. Who killed the lifelong friends and why? Instagram Email: [email protected] Sources: https://www.newspapers.com/image/503121023/?match=1&terms=Dylan%20Ellis%20and%20Oliver%20Martin https…

1
You Should Read: Our 2024 Favorites! 1:05:36

8M ago1:05:36

1:05:36

Send us a text We're back again, Should-Heads! We're so excited to get back into the swing of podcasting. Kelly and Rachael return with this one-on-one discussion of our bookish highlights of the year and discuss our hopes for continuing this podcast in the future. Stay tuned for more episode, we have some great plans for you all! And Happy New Yea…

1
70. Bob Ballard 38:45

8M ago38:45

38:45

On April 27th, 2023, 56-year-old Larry "Bob" Ballard vanished after getting his truck stuck in rural Douglassville, Texas. He planned to stay with his vehicle overnight until someone came to help him the following morning, but when they arrived, Bob was missing. What happened to Bob Ballard? Instagram Sources: https://www.cbs19.tv/article/news/loca…

1
69. Mikiko Kasahara 40:14

8M ago40:14

40:14

On December 13th, 2002, 21-year-old college student Mikiko Kasahara hosted an end-of-semester party in Seguin, Texas. A few hours after the party ended, Mikiko's apartment was set ablaze. Who killed Mikiko Kasahara? Instagram Email: [email protected] Sources: https://seguingazette.com/news/article_ced0b27a-b194-5835-8773-f7931d109c9c.html http…

1
68. Geetha Angara 58:18

8M ago58:18

58:18

On February 8th, 2005, 43-year-old chemist Geetha Angara disappeared while at work in Totowa, New Jersey. When her body was discovered at her place of employment, her colleagues fell under scrutiny. What happened to Geetha Angara? Instagram Sources: https://www.newspapers.com/image/220074928/?match=1&terms=Geetha%20Angara https://www.newspapers.com…

1
67. Philip Fraser 35:58

8M ago35:58

35:58

On June 14th, 1988, 23-year-old Philip Fraser began the long drive from Alaska to Washington, where he was to start college. After picking up a hitchhiker in British Columbia, Philip was never seen alive again. That hitchhiker remains the key suspect in Philip's murder and has evaded the police since 1988. Email: [email protected] Instagram So…

1
66. Julie-Anne Leahy and Vicki Arnold Part 2 1:06:06

9M ago1:06:06

1:06:06

On July 26th, 1991, Julie-Anne Leahy and her friend Vicki Arnold disappeared while on an apparent night fishing trip in Atherton, Queensland. A couple of weeks later, their bodies were recovered inside Julie-Anne's vehicle. What happened to Julie-Anne and Vicki? And did the police get it right? Instagram Email: [email protected] See part 1 epi…

Podcasts Worth a Listen

Stephen Moriarty Podcasts

Podcasts Worth a Listen

Quick Reference Guide