Best Joe Flaherty Podcasts (2025)

1
Season 4 Episode 5: Tywan Pouncy 31:13

2d ago31:13

31:13

Send us a text In this episode, Frank talks with a security associate who had a unique entry into Wrigley Field, that allowed him to meet Frank well before he worked his first baseball game. You can watch this episode on Patreon. Support the show Follow us: Twitter @PodcastMistaken Instagram @MistakenIdentityMedia Facebook @MistkenIdentityMedia Tik…

1
Gotcha! Feat. Mark Burns & Sydney Duncan 23:35

15d ago23:35

23:35

On this episode, Mark Burns tells us of his harrowing experience hunting down a yeti in Disney World and Sydney Duncan talks about going over 100 MPH (literally) to book acting roles in Texas! Hosted on Acast. See acast.com/privacy for more information.

1
Gotcha! Feat. Marissa Moorhead & Kimberly Dinaro 22:28

1M ago22:28

22:28

With summer on the horizon, today's guests look back at the summer jobs of their youths! Marissa Moorhead joins us to talk about fending off her Nosferatu-esque manager at an unnamed movie chain (it was probably AMC, though). Then, Kimberly Dinaro tells us how she...*GASP* killed Quiznos??! Hosted on Acast. See acast.com/privacy for more informatio…

1
Gotcha! Feat. Clare Donaher & Tony Ferraro 20:25

2M ago20:25

20:25

Don't come for Clare Donaher, or she might...spend the next few decades feeling guilty about it? Clare tells us about confronting her childhood bully how she helped shape Clare into the person she is today. Then, Tony Ferraro, tells us about an entire class uniting against their finance professor by cheating on their exam. Also: is Jonah Hill hot? …

1
2025 MLB World Tour Tokyo Series Podcast Special - Part 2 1:03:51

2M ago1:03:51

1:03:51

Send us a text Frank and Jordan take you through the rest of their trip exploring different areas of Tokyo, answer listener questions from our Patreon members , and give their final thoughts on Tokyo. To watch the daily blogs from Tokyo check out our Patreon page via the link below! Support the show Follow us: Twitter @PodcastMistaken Instagram @Mi…

1
Gotcha! LIVE Feat. Marie Faustin & Shosh Brodman 18:48

2M ago18:48

18:48

Recorded LIVE at the UCB theater in NYC, our first guest, Marie Faustin, talks about her semi-professional career in theft, then returning guest, Shosh Brodman, tells us a story that we like to call "Oh, the places you'll piss in public! (and private)" Hosted on Acast. See acast.com/privacy for more information.…

1
We Could've Been So Good Together 26:23

2M ago26:23

26:23

Holy relationship problems, Bat-, er, Careless Whisper! Deep in the heart of the Hudson Valley, lives millionaire film director, George, with his partner, that ruthless vigilante, The Careless Whisper! But when The Careless Whisper is kidnapped by a group of her most fearsome foes, The Freaky Four-Tet, strains in their relationship start to show. A…

1
2025 MLB World Tour Tokyo Series Podcast Special - Part 1 1:10:39

2M ago1:10:39

1:10:39

Send us a text Frank and Jordan take you through their first few days in Tokyo, from the airport, to the Cubs game, Disney Sea and beyond. This episode was recorded each night in advance and can be watched on our Patreon page below. To watch the daily vlogs mentioned in this episode and more than 1,000 videos and photos, head over to our Patreon pa…

1
Nobody "Yes And's" Forever 21:30

3M ago21:30

21:30

An all new Cole & Jane adventure, recorded LIVE at the UCB theater in NYC, and available to all of our loyal listeners, for the very first time! Cole and Jane are brought in to solve the murder of NYC's best improviser, but can they get past a temperamental artist, a faded star turned maintenance worker, and ...THE 1991 CHICAGO BULLS (?!?!?!) first…

1
Gotcha! LIVE Feat. Amelia Ritthaler & Kelley Heyer 14:25

3M ago14:25

14:25

Recorded LIVE at the UCB theater in NYC, our first live Gotcha! features two HERstorical icons: Amelia Ritthaler from the Girl's Rewatch Podcast, and creator of the Apple dance, Kelley Heyer! Queen out with Amelia and Kelley as they talk about airport thievery and warding off college film bros! Hosted on Acast. See acast.com/privacy for more inform…

1
Basic (Instinct) White Female 21:56

3M ago21:56

21:56

On the surface, Jane Flame has it all. A partner who cares about her, very little money, no mom, a warrant for her arrest, that weird mole on her face. Ok maybe not, but she's very tough, and cool, and sexy ok! Why would you want to be yourself, when you can be...Jane? That's the question hitchhiker Meredith asks herself after being picked up by Co…

1
Cole Steeley Dan 19:10

3M ago19:10

19:10

On this week's episode, Cole and Jane are reelin' in the years! Tired of doing your dirty work and strapped for cash, Cole and Jane get roped into starting a band by a Soviet Svengali and take the nation by storm in a phenomenon we like to call : Cole Steeleamania. Only a fool would say that things go well though, because Cole and Jane's songs are …

1
Gotcha! Feat. Joan Flaherty & Neel Ghosh 24:24

3M ago24:24

24:24

April Fools! It's March 17th! (Isn't that St. Patrick's day? Sshhh!) Our guests, Joan Flaherty and Neel Ghosh share stories of pranks gone wrong and also pranks gone right. Plus, I am woman, hear me...neigh?? Meredith dishes to Cole and Jane about her past as a horse girl. Hosted on Acast. See acast.com/privacy for more information.…

1
The "My Fair Horsey" Score 25:26

3M ago25:26

25:26

Heists are a job, and should be done by professionals, like any other. At least that's what career criminal Peters thinks. They require careful thought, planning, and execution. Not to mention...wait why is Cole wearing a horse costume and singing showtunes? And Jane keeps loudly talking about a double cross in front of everyone? This job will test…

1
Blood Complicated 24:06

4M ago24:06

24:06

COLE STEELE AND JANE FLAME ARE BACK!!! And they're stupider and more money hungry than ever! Er...we mean smarter, cooler, and sexier than ever? (Please don't hurt us). After Jane receives a mysterious note that may be from her long-thought-lost mom, Cole and Jane set-off on a cross-country road trip for answers. Join us for a season of Communist m…

1
Gotcha! Feat. Michelle Chan Bennett & Sabeen Sadiq 23:00

4M ago23:00

23:00

On this episode of Gotcha! we're going back to school! With tales ranging from cute and wholesome to...a sobering look at the contemporary American school system, these crimes have to be heard to be believed! Don't forget to rate, review, and subscribe so you never miss an episode. And you can follow the show on Instagram @colesteelepod. Hosted on …

1
Bonus: Nancy Helps Us With An Itinerary For Japan! 1:00:36

4M ago1:00:36

1:00:36

Send us a text In this extended episode, Nancy Sullivan chats with Frank, from Japan, and helps him put together a fun list of things to do while in Japan for the MLB World Tour! Support the show Follow us: Twitter @PodcastMistaken Instagram @MistakenIdentityMedia Facebook @MistkenIdentityMedia Tik Tok @FrankWalkerIV Patreon (watch our episodes) Mi…

1
Gotcha! Feat. Sam Kieffer & Tina Sieben 30:11

4M ago30:11

30:11

In the game of therapy, you either win or you get healthy. Our first guest, Sam Kieffer, talks about dealing with the Pattys & Selmas at the unemployment office and why he makes it a mission to win every therapy session. Then, Tina Sieben, talks about meeting the coolest person she's ever met, while in prison. The myth, the legend, the 81 year old …

1
Bonus: Nancy Sullivan Gets Us Ready To Travel To Japan! 36:45

4M ago36:45

36:45

Send us a text Former Cubs Supervisor Nancy Sullivan, who now resides in Japan, walked Frank through the steps he needed to take as he prepared to go to Japan in this pre-recorded episode that aired on Patreon for members a few months ago! Be sure to head on over to Patreon to check out all of our Japan related videos and more! (Link below) Support…

1
Gotcha! Feat. Joe Palana & Paris Adkins 20:59

5M ago20:59

20:59

For Pete's sake, our first guest, Joe Palana, tells a roller-coaster of a story about being arrested by the evil Marge Gunderson from Fargo, that needs to be heard to be believed. Then Paris Adkins shares their best shoplifting tips and tricks, and tells about how their love for acting was eventually overshadowed by their love for stealing. Don't f…

1
Season 4 Episode 4: Sergio Silva 37:57

5M ago37:57

37:57

Send us a text It's a long time coming but Frank finally caught up with one of his favorites to discuss hot topics and current events Support the show Follow us: Twitter @PodcastMistaken Instagram @MistakenIdentityMedia Facebook @MistkenIdentityMedia Tik Tok @FrankWalkerIV Patreon (watch our episodes) Mistaken Identity Podcast Website PodPage Email…

1
Season 4 Episode 3: Bradley Pyke 38:17

5M ago38:17

38:17

Send us a text From Guest Services Ambassador to front office, one of Frank's favorite young minds sits down to tell his life story...so far! Support the show Follow us: Twitter @PodcastMistaken Instagram @MistakenIdentityMedia Facebook @MistkenIdentityMedia Tik Tok @FrankWalkerIV Patreon (watch our episodes) Mistaken Identity Podcast Website PodPa…

1
Gotcha! Feat. April Lavalle & Alex Murdoch 25:10

5M ago25:10

25:10

Meet Brad, a forty year old man from Tennessee, his hobbies are...musical theater and Runescape? And he's never seen a movie? GOTCHA!! That's because it's really April Lavalle, you nerd! April tells us about a childhood catfishing strangers online into thinking she was an adult southern man instead of a fifteen year old girl from Long Island. Then,…

1
Season 4 Episode 2: Shipping Up to Boston (Fenway Park Recap) 28:09

5M ago28:09

28:09

Send us a text Frank and Tyler recap their Spring trip to Boston, including a guided tour of Fenway Park and (of course) a Cubs/Red Sox Game! For a deeper dive into the experience, including photos and videos from the entire Boston trip, head on over to our Patreon Page! Support the show Follow us: Twitter @PodcastMistaken Instagram @MistakenIdenti…

1
Gotcha! Feat. Esther Fallick & Ian Lockwood 19:04

5M ago19:04

19:04

We're back from a holiday hiatus with two more tales of trials and tribulations! Our first guest, Esther Fallick, tells a story of a family reunion gone awry and a friendship shattered due to a case of mistaken identity. Then Ian Lockwood tells us about the biggest crime of all...an age gap relationship? (It's not problematic, we promise!) Our Gotc…

1
A Special Message from Cole and Jane 1:00

6M ago1:00

1:00

A very special message from Cole and Jane. You know if they're taking a break from solving crimes, trying to get money, or getting drunk, then it has to be good! Join Cole & Jane at the UCB theater in NYC on Friday 12/13 at 10:30 PM, for an all new original adventure and a special live Gotcha! segment with special guests Marie Faustin (Mess, MTV's …

1
Gotcha! Feat. Freddie Shanel & Rapid Fire Round 11:30

6M ago11:30

11:30

Join guest Freddie Shanel as we explore the world of unintentional cheating and good students gone bad! Then, Don, Joyah, and Meredith sit down and quickly run through all of the worst (and we do mean WORST) things they've ever done. R.I.P. Puddins the micro-kitten. Join Cole & Jane at the UCB theater in NYC on Friday 12/13 at 10:30 PM, for an all …

1
Gotcha! Feat. Winnie Stack & Lida Darmian 17:54

7M ago17:54

17:54

I love you, you love...sharks??! Our first guest Winnie Stack, talks about how her acts of childhood chaos made her who she is today and how she carefully cultivates the Joker inside of her. Then, Lida Darmian tells us a cautionary tale of why productions should always take care of their actors...and show's off her very chic jacket! (You'll just ha…

1
Gotcha! Feat. Jamie Linn Watson & Jacob Davis 25:10

7M ago25:10

25:10

It's a bird! It's a plane! It's a...19 year old girl who feels like she's been betrayed? Our first guest, Jamie Linn Watson, takes us through a series of poor decisions following an imagined betrayal. Then, one crime isn't enough for Jacob Davis, who decides to tell us the three worst crimes he's ever committed! From childhood thievery to graveyard…

1
Gotcha! Feat. Andrew Barlow & Natasha Vaynblat 15:31

7M ago15:31

15:31

It's Bertuccis, when you're there, you're family! Our first guest, Andrew Barlow, tells a tale of teenage thievery worthy of any 80's movie (and immediately rats out all of his friends in the process.) Then, Natasha Vaynblat reveals an old money saving hack she learned from her mother (stealing), and discusses why she views crime as "more of a game…

1
Gotcha! Feat. Grogan & Rose Kelso 28:19

8M ago28:19

28:19

How far would you go for family? Our first guest, Grogan, talks about their herculean quest to avenge their grandfather's honor. Involving closets full of bugs, 20th century erotica, and all the cow facts you can handle! Then, if Rose Kelso sh*ts in prospect park, does she make a sound? Our next guest Rose Kelso undertakes an equally herculean task…

1
Gotcha! Feat. Tatiana Frank & Shosh Brodman 20:38

8M ago20:38

20:38

Babe, KICK HER ASS! Our first guest, Tatiana Frank, talks about her law & order Russian father teaching her a lesson after taking his car for an unexpected joyride and how a guy she pissed off sicced his girlfriend on him like a henchman. Then, picture this, you're on a cruise lapping up some rays and feeling the ocean breeze, you think "Boy a nice…

1
All About All Hallows' Eve 18:53

8M ago18:53

18:53

Turn those Jack O'Lantern frowns upside down, because Cole & Jane are back for an ALL NEW Halloween adventure! When a small town is terrorized by escaped serial killer William Murray, Cole & Jane take it upon themselves to look after the town's troubled teens, free of charge! Ok, so maybe they don't actually do it "free of charge", maybe they do it…

1
Gotcha! Feat. Riylan Mills & Maggie Olmsted 21:00

8M ago21:00

21:00

Love is in the air, and so are crimes! Our first guest Riylan Mills describes her epic crusade of karmic justice against Bushwick boys (taking little souvenirs from their rooms). Then, fellas, is it a crime to be confused? Maggie Olmsted tells a cautionary tale about how simply being thirsty at the beach led to a string of nutcrackers, firecrackers…

1
Gotcha! Feat. Sam Naismith & Meredith Dietz 15:43

8M ago15:43

15:43

Check your back for kick-me sign's and get ready to be stuffed in your locker because on this week's episode we have bad boy of comedy, Sam Naismith! Sam tells us about a high school prank that made him truly understand the meaning of "digital footprint" and almost ended his burgeoning comedy career before it even started. Our second guest, (and so…

1
Gotcha! Feat. Tessa Belle & Bridget Foley 18:32

8M ago18:32

18:32

The Ivy's may be the United State's top universities...but they're also Tessa Belle's bitch. Cole and Jane interview Tessa about the booming business of being a for-hire college admission essay author and the seedy underbelly of higher education. Meanwhile, our second guest Bridget Foley takes us on a journey through another seedy underbelly...your…

1
Gotcha! Feat. Jess Elgene & Monique Moses 11:40

9M ago11:40

11:40

From harassing teens in the Texas heat to causing crimes in the Canadian cold, this one has it all! Our first guest, Jess Elgene, talks about being a good girl turned evil due to the corrupting influence of driving a used cop car; while our second guest Monique Moses discusses the irresistible urge of free Archie comics (Oh, and also the intricacie…

1
Gotcha! Feat. Lukas Arnold & Chet Siegel 17:05

9M ago17:05

17:05

CURSE YOU TOOTSIE POP OWL!!! Our first guest is Lukas Arnold; your fears made flesh!! Join us as Lukas shares how a childhood crime led to obsession and bewilderment that haunts him to this very day. Then, our next guest, Chet Siegel, shares how her love of snacking led to an ill-advised childhood joyride, but still she persists as a snacky lil' b*…

1
Gotcha! Feat. Steve Jeanty & Carson Olshansky 21:04

9M ago21:04

21:04

Move over Danny Ocean! Today's episode features Steve Jeanty describing the heist of a lifetime...that happened when he was only in middle school! Join us for a tale we like to call..."Yu-Gi-Ohcean's 11"! Our second guest Carson Olshansky talks about using their superpower of time-thievery to strike back at capitalism in an epic worthy of the MCU (…

1
Gotcha! Feat. Megan Bitchell & Mary McDonnell 17:26

9M ago17:26

17:26

How do Cole and Jane prepare for a whole new season of wild and wacky adventures? By interviewing NYC and LA's hottest comics about the biggest crimes they've ever committed, of course! By popular demand, extended audio versions of our popular social media series "Gotcha!" will now be released every Monday! Starting with a totally unreleased interv…

1
Gotcha! Feat. Yoni Lotan 29:07

9M ago29:07

29:07

How do Cole and Jane prepare for a whole new season of wild and wacky adventures? By interviewing NYC and LA's hottest comics about the biggest crimes they've ever committed, of course! By popular demand, extended audio versions of our popular social media series "Gotcha!" will now be released every Monday! Starting with a totally unreleased interv…

1
Season 4 Episode 1: Cubs at San Diego Padres/Petco Park Tour 28:47

10M ago28:47

28:47

Send us a text We're kicking off season 4 with a road trip with the Cubs! Petco Park is a magnificent ballpark! To watch this episode, and every episode of this season, click the link to our patreon page below! There is also a bonus episode of the San Diego Zoo there to watch! https://www.patreon.com/MistakenIdentityPodcast Music from #Uppbeat (fre…

1
⭐️ Transcend With Tyler Podcast: Episode 4: Mental Health 36:45

12M ago36:45

36:45

Send us a text Tyler is back with his Tuesday podcast and tackles the topic of mental health with Jakatadajour Barrett. Support the show Follow us: Twitter @PodcastMistaken Instagram @MistakenIdentityMedia Facebook @MistkenIdentityMedia Tik Tok @FrankWalkerIV Patreon (watch our episodes) Mistaken Identity Podcast Website PodPage Email: MistakenIden…

1
⭐️ Transcend With Tyler Podcast: Episode 3: The Difference Between Sex and Gender 33:57

1y ago33:57

33:57

Send us a text In this episode, Tyler chats with Grayce Sweetman about the difference between sex and gender in a very much needed conversation. Its a podcast within a podcast, on select Tuesdays! Catch a special episode of Transcend with Tyler on the Mistaken Identity feed, always FREE and available on every podcast platform. Support the show Foll…

1
⚾️ Season 3 Finale : Episode 12 - Keston Edwards 45:38

1y ago45:38

45:38

Send us a text It's the final episode of Season 3 so Frank chats with the only person to appear on every season of the podcast (multiple times), his favorite person, Keston Edwards! REDUCE ANXIETY AND STRESS WITH THE FIST EVER PRODUCTIVITY DRINK! Magic Mind - here's your chance to try one of Frank's favorite things! Get 20% off your first purchase …

1
⚾️ Season 3: Episode 11 - JaylenGreen 36:27

1y ago36:27

36:27

Send us a text Frank chats with a member of the Events Crew, and newly appointed supervisor, Jaylen Green - and as usual, he learns something about a co worker that shocks him. CRUSH PROCRASTINATION, REDUCE ANXIETY AND STRESS WITH THE FIST EVER PRODUCTIVITY DRINK! Magic Mind - here's your chance to try one of Frank's favorite things! Get 20% off yo…

1
⚾️ Season 3: Episode 10 - Tyler Dauster 40:56

1y ago40:56

40:56

Send us a text Frank has a fascinating chat with Tyler about growing up in Alabama, his transition, the ballpark and more! CRUSH PROCRASTINATION, REDUCE ANXIETY AND STRESS WITH THE FIST EVER PRODUCTIVITY DRINK! Magic Mind - here's your chance to try one of Frank's favorite things! Get 20% off your first purchase or 50% off your subscription in the …

1
⚾️ Season 3: Episode 9 - Jakatadajour Barrett 36:18

1y ago36:18

36:18

Send us a text Frank chats with one of the most unique names at Wrigley Field about his happenings outside of the ballpark. CRUSH PROCRASTINATION, REDUCE ANXIETY AND STRESS WITH THE FIST EVER PRODUCTIVITY DRINK! Magic Mind - here's your chance to try one of Frank's favorite things! Get 20% off your first purchase or 50% off your subscription in the…

1
⭐️ Transcend With Tyler Podcast: Episode 2: Sergio Transcends With Tyler 33:34

1y ago33:34

33:34

Send us a text It's Tuesday which means it's time for another episode from our brother podcast, Transcend With Tyler, In this episode he chats with Sergio Silva! Note: New episodes of Mistaken Identity Beyond the Ballpark will still air on select Mondays, but on select days of the week, we invite others to host shows on our feed. Looking for the mo…

1
Episode 50 (RIP Joe Flaherty/ Trump Relates to Black People/Good Times 2024) 1:13:32

1y ago1:13:32

1:13:32

**RIP Joe Flarety**, **Trump Relates to the Blacks**, **The Acolyte Trailer**, **La Cervasa Cristal**, **Better than Us**, **Ghostbusters Frozen Empire**, **RoadHouse 2024**, **Dune Part 2**, **Good Times Netflix**By The Canadian Bacon Podcast

Podcasts Worth a Listen

Joe Flaherty Podcasts

Podcasts Worth a Listen

Quick Reference Guide