Best Toby Cooper Podcasts (2025)

1
540 // Missing Eric Wein Located - Updates in New England Serial Killer Case w/ Prof Perlmutter 1:09:19

1h ago1:09:19

1:09:19

In this episode, Tim Pilleri & Lance Reenstierna try to understand the dark fascination with the possibility of a serial killer operating in New England. They are joined by Prof. David Perlmutter of Texas Tech University. Dr. Perlmutter is the professor of Media and Communications and he shares his unique insight into the motivations of how the med…

1
539 // Live Fundraiser w/ Trace Sargent, PI's Greg Overacker & Lou Barry - Part 2 of 2 1:22:42

2d ago1:22:42

1:22:42

In this new episode, Tim Pilleri and Lance Reenstierna host a live fundraiser for the non-profit, Private Investigations For the Missing. This is part 2 of 2. Guests for the evening include Julie Murray (sister of Maura Murray), Bobby Taghavi (Golden State Killer task force), Dr. Trace Sargent (profiler & search dog trainer), private investigator J…

1
538 // Live Fundraiser w/ Julie Murray, Bobby Taghavi - Part 1 of 2 1:05:04

3d ago1:05:04

1:05:04

In this new episode, Tim Pilleri and Lance Reenstierna host a live fundraiser for the non-profit, Private Investigations For the Missing. This is part 1 of 2. Guests for the evening include Julie Murray (sister of Maura Murray), Bobby Taghavi (Golden State Killer task force), Dr. Trace Sargent (profiler & search dog trainer), private investigator J…

1
537 // Franklin Evans - One of New England's First Serial Killers 1:00:10

5d ago1:00:10

1:00:10

In this episode, Tim Pilleri and Lance Reenstierna are joined by historian, public speaker, author and educator, Christopher Daley about one of America's first serial killers, Franklin Evans. After his niece Georgianna Lovering went missing on September 24th, 1872, Franklin Evans became a suspect due to his strange behavior. He eventually confessed…

1
536 // Zebb Quinn 1:00:08

9d ago1:00:08

1:00:08

In this new episode, Tim Pilleri and Lance Reenstierna speak about the disappearance of Zebb Quinn from Asheville, North Carolina since January 2nd, 2000. Robert “Jason” Owens, was a 21 year old co-worker who Zebb occasionally played pool with. On the night of January 2nd, 2000, Zebb had been working and clocked out of Walmart at 9:02 p.m. He met u…

1
535 // Mike Montijo 1:01:36

12d ago1:01:36

1:01:36

In this episode, Tim Pilleri and Lance Reenstierna speak with missing man Mike Montijo's sister Belinda and private investigator Lou Barry about Mike disappearance from Ridgeville, South Carolina on January 26th, 2020. This interview was previously published on Missing on October 20th, 2022. Mike Montijo has been missing from Ridgeville, South Caro…

1
534 // Bennington Triangle - Part 3 - James Tedford 1:20:12

16d ago1:20:12

1:20:12

In this new episode, Tim Pilleri and Lance Reenstierna speak with ⁠Worcester State University ⁠archives librarian Ross Griffiths about the mysterious Bennington Triangle disappearances of Vermont and the disappearance of James Tedford. 68 year-old World War I veteran James Tedford went missing on December 1st, 1949. Tedford had been visiting relati…

1
533 // Hunting Fugitive William Leslie Arnold 1:07:43

19d ago1:07:43

1:07:43

In this episode, Crawlspace Media's Tim Pilleri and Lance Reenstierna speak with Geoff Britton about his hunt for missing fugitive William Leslie Arnold. William Leslie Arnold murdered his parents in 1958, pled guilty and was sentenced in 1959. Then he escaped prison in 1967 and disappeared. Our guest Geoff Britton began searching for him and it le…

1
532 // Lilly & Jack Sullivan 1:24:00

21d ago1:24:00

1:24:00

In this new episode, Tim Pilleri and Lance Reenstierna speak with Jordan Bonaparte of the Nighttime Podcast about the mysterious disappearances of Lilly and Jack Sullivan from Pictou County, Nova Scotia, Canada on May 2nd, 2025. Recent media: https://halifax.citynews.ca/2025/05/28/rcmp-narrows-down-timeline-of-sullivan-children-disappearance-asks-f…

1
531 // Deanna Merryfield 1:15:51

23d ago1:15:51

1:15:51

In this new episode, Tim Pilleri and Lance Reenstierna speak with Melissa Twardowski about the mysterious disappearance of her sister Deanna Merryfield from Killeen, Texas in July of 1990. Deanna was reported missing on July 22nd, 1990. Her case was filed as a runaway. Deanna did not leave a note, told no one she was running away, and did not take …

1
530 // NESK - Brainscratch Collab - Is There a New England Serial Killer? 1:48:23

26d ago1:48:23

1:48:23

In this new episode Tim Pilleri, Lance Reenstierna, and Mike Morford speak on John Lordan's Brainscratch Youtube show about the possibilities of a new and active serial killer in New England. Check out this episode on John Lordan's LordanArts channel: https://youtu.be/YyXvnuLC7Po. Follow John Lordan's work: https://linktr.ee/lordanarts. Follow Mike…

1
529 // NESK - Reviewing Expert Insight in New England Serial Killer Case 1:10:02

28d ago1:10:02

1:10:02

In this new episode Tim Pilleri and Lance Reenstierna speak about the possibilities of a new and active serial killer in New England. We also play clips from Lance's conversation with expert Dr. Michael Arntfield that aired on Crawlspace on May 18th, 2025. Mike brings his unique and specialized insight into not only the dynamics of how the discover…

1
528 // Nicholas Marion 1:40:06

1M ago1:40:06

1:40:06

In this new episode, Tim Pilleri and Lance Reenstierna speak about the mysterious disappearance of Nicholas Marion with his father Carl, sister Cola, and Cola's wife Amanda. Nicholas went missing from Youbou Road in the Cowichan Valley on June 20th, 2024. If you have any information please call the Cowichan RCMP at 250-759-6668. And please refer to…

1
527 // Davohnte Morgan 51:54

1M ago51:54

51:54

In this episode Tim Pilleri speaks with Terri Barnes, Davohnte Morgan's mom about Davohnte's disappearance from Mount Shasta, California in May of 2020. If you have any information please call the Mount Shasta Police at 530-926-7540. This episode previously aired on Missing on November 3rd, 2022. Follow Terri on TikTok: ⁠⁠https://www.tiktok.com/@ma…

1
526 // Erik Larsfolk & John McCormick Jr 1:26:19

1M ago1:26:19

1:26:19

In this new episode, Tim Pilleri and Lance Reenstierna speak with Laura Riste about the disappearances of Erik Larsfolk and John McCormick Jr from the Mccormick Farm in Caledon, Ontario on August 24th, 1981. Laura's site: https://www.canadiangurl77.com/. Laura's FB page for Trenny: ⁠https://www.facebook.com/searching.for.trenny⁠. Sources: https://w…

1
525 // DB Cooper: New Discoveries w/ Eric Ulis 1:13:18

1M ago1:13:18

1:13:18

In this episode, Tim Pilleri & Lance Reenstierna are joined by Eric Ulis. Eric is an unwavering and tireless investigator who has made it a mission of his to discover the true identity of the legendary famous skyjacker, DB Cooper. This episode aired on Crawlspace on April 6th, 2025. Follow Eric Ulis: ⁠https://ericulis.com/⁠. YouTube:⁠ https://www.y…

1
524 // Continuing Coverage of Possible Active Serial Killer in New England 53:54

1M ago53:54

53:54

In this new episode, Tim Pilleri & Lance Reenstierna discuss updates on the possibility of a new and unidentified serial killer in New England. This is part 3 of a special report we're doing on the possibility of a new and active serial killer in New England. On March 6th, 2025 the remains of a woman were found near Norwalk, Connecticut by Norwalk …

1
523 // Percy Fawcett 55:52

1M ago55:52

55:52

In this new episode, Tim Pilleri and Lance Reenstierna discuss the 1925 disappearances of Percy Fawcett, his son Jack, and Jack's friend Raleigh Rimmell in the wilds of Brazil while looking for the lost city of El Dorado. Research by Kathleen Studer. Sources: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Percy_Fawcett. https://www.amazon.com/Lost-Amazon-Enigma-Per…

1
522 // True Crime Garage Crossover - Maura Murray, Brian Shaffer - Part 2 1:21:00

2M ago1:21:00

1:21:00

In this new episode, Tim Pilleri and Lance Reenstierna speak with Captain and Nic Edwards of True Crime Garage. In part one we discuss the cases that have stuck with us over the years. We speak a bit about Maura Murray's disappearance in part one and about Brian Shaffer's disappearance in part two. This is part two of two. Follow True Crime Garage:…

1
521 // True Crime Garage Crossover - Maura Murray, Brian Shaffer - Part 1 1:17:20

2M ago1:17:20

1:17:20

In this new episode, Tim Pilleri and Lance Reenstierna speak with Captain and Nic Edwards of True Crime Garage. In part one we discuss the cases that have stuck with us over the years. We speak a bit about Maura Murray's disappearance in part one and about Brian Shaffer's disappearance in part two. This is part one of two. Follow True Crime Garage:…

1
520 // Updates on Possible Active Serial Killer in New England 46:34

2M ago46:34

46:34

In this new episode, Tim Pilleri & Lance Reenstierna discuss updates on the possibility of a new and unidentified serial killer in New England. On March 6th, 2025 the remains of Paige Fannon are found near Norwalk, Connecticut by Norwalk police scuba team and fire rescue team. Authorities located clothing and personal items left on the bank of the …

1
519 // Lewis Lent & Hidden Demons of the Berkshires 1:09:56

2M ago1:09:56

1:09:56

In this episode, Tim Pilleri & Lance Reenstierna are joined by author Margery Metzger to speak about her new book Hidden Demons. In Hidden Demons Margery writes about child serial killer Lewis Lent and much more. This episode was previously published on Crawlspace January 4th, 2023. Get Hidden Demons here: https://wildbluepress.com/hidden-demons-ma…

1
518 // Is There a New Serial Killer in New England? 47:01

2M ago47:01

47:01

In this new episode, Tim Pilleri and Lance Reenstierna discuss the possibility of a new and unidentified serial killer in New England. Since March of 2025 at least six bodies have been found and people have starting wondering if there was a serial killer. We discuss each case and weigh the possibilities of foul play. On March 6th, 2025 the remains …

1
517 // Bennington Triangle - Part 2 - Paula Welden 1:44:33

2M ago1:44:33

1:44:33

In this new episode, Tim Pilleri and Lance Reenstierna speak with Worcester State University archives librarian Ross Griffiths about the mysterious Bennington Triangle disappearances of Vermont and the disappearance of Paula Welden on December 1st, 1946. Paula Welden was last seen on the afternoon of December 1st, 1946. She left the campus that aft…

1
516 // The Unsolved Murder of Karen Bodine - Part 2 55:39

2M ago55:39

55:39

In this new episode Tim Pilleri and Lance Reenstierna speak with Karlee Bodine, daughter of Karen Bodine, about her mom's unsolved murder and her family's fight for justice. Karen's body was found the morning of Jan 22nd, 2007 at a gravel pit adjacent to Littlerock Road Southwest in Olympia, Washington. For more information or to submit tips to the…

1
515 // New Trenny Gibson Updates w/ Laura Riste 1:33:11

2M ago1:33:11

1:33:11

In this new episode, Tim Pilleri and Lance Reenstierna speak with Laura Riste about the mysterious disappearance of Trenny Gibson from the Smoky Mountain National Park on October 8th, 1976. This is part 8 of our series on Trenny Gibson. Laura's site: www.canadiangurl77.com. Laura's FB page for Trenny: https://www.facebook.com/searching.for.trenny. …

1
514 // Teresa Ann Davidson-Murphy - Part 2 51:13

2M ago51:13

51:13

In this episode Tim Pilleri, Lance Reenstierna, and Jennifer Amell speak about the mysterious disappearance of Teresa Ann Davidson-Murphy from Rainier, Oregon in October of 1999. Included are clips from Jennifer's interview with Teresa's mother Yvonne. This is part 2 of a 2 part episode. This episode was previously published on February 17th, 2022.…

1
513 // Teresa Ann Davidson-Murphy - Part 1 55:11

2M ago55:11

55:11

In this episode Tim Pilleri, Lance Reenstierna, and Jennifer Amell speak about the mysterious disappearance of Teresa Ann Davidson-Murphy from Rainier, Oregon in October of 1999. Included are clips from Jennifer's interview with Teresa's mother Yvonne. This is part 1 of a 2 part episode. This episode was previously published on February 10th, 2022.…

1
512 // Diane Augat 59:29

2M ago59:29

59:29

In this new episode, Tim Pilleri and Lance Reenstierna discuss the mysterious disappearance of Diane Augat from Hudson, Florida on April 10th, 1998. This episode was researched by Kathleen Studer. If you have any information about what happened to Diane Augat, please contact The Pasco County Sheriff’s Office, Detective Mark Celeste at (727) 847-587…

1
511 // Crawlspace Bonus - Infiltrating The White Supremacy w/ Scott Payne 1:11:49

3M ago1:11:49

1:11:49

In this episode of Crawlspace, Tim Pilleri & Lance Reenstierna are joined by Scott Payne, aka - Pale Horse. Scott spent years infiltrating hate groups and white supremacy cells in the United States in an attempt to eradicate as much hate as possible. He made it out alive and shares some of his most harrowing stories in this episode. To pick up your…

1
510 // Dorothy Arnold 1:13:57

3M ago1:13:57

1:13:57

In this new episode, Tim Pilleri and Lance Reenstierna discuss the mysterious disappearance of Dorothy Arnold from Manhattan, New York City on December 12th, 1910. This episode was researched by Kathleen Studer. Sources: https://charleyproject.org/case/dorothy-harriet-camille-arnold. https://www.americanheritage.com/girl-who-never-came-back. https:…

1
509 // The New Bedford Highway Serial Killer w/ Maureen Boyle 1:04:46

3M ago1:04:46

1:04:46

In this episode, Tim Pilleri and Lance Reenstierna speak with author Maureen Boyle about her book Shallow Graves: The Hunt For the New Bedford Highway Serial Killer. Maureen's site: https://www.maureenboylewriter.com/. Get her book here: https://www.amazon.com/Shallow-Graves-Bedford-Highway-Serial/dp/1512600741. Follow Maureen on Instagram: https:/…

1
508 // Solving Missing Persons Cases Using Digital Forensics 1:23:40

3M ago1:23:40

1:23:40

In this new episode Tim Pilleri and Lance Reenstierna speak with private investigator Colman Ryan about his methods solving missing persons cases using digital forensics. We also speak about Jason Landry's disappearance in the second half of the interview. Jason Landry went missing from Lulling, Texas on December 13, 2020. Check out Colman's PI fir…

1
507 // Archer Ray Johnson 47:24

3M ago47:24

47:24

In this episode Tim Pilleri and Lance Reenstierna chat with Niki and Taylor Johnson about the disappearance of their father and grandfather Archer Ray Johnson from Brooklyn, Washington on April 1st, 1986. This interview previously aired on January 14th, 2021. Check out episodes 212 and 213 for the first two episodes about Archer's disappearance. Fo…

1
506 // Morris Ray McDonald 1:10:42

3M ago1:10:42

1:10:42

In this new episode Tim Pilleri and Lance Reenstierna speak with private investigator, case advocate, and searcher Jason Watts to discuss the mysterious disappearance of Morris Ray McDonald from Crowley, Texas on January 28th, 2022. If you have any information please call Detective White at 817-297-2276 ext: 6303 or your local law enforcement. Emai…

1
505 // Homicide Timeline w/ Jane Monckton-Smith 1:20:24

3M ago1:20:24

1:20:24

In this episode Tim Pilleri and Lance Reenstierna speak with Professor Jane Monckton-Smith about her new book In Control: Dangerous Relationships and How They End in Murder. We also discuss her 8 stage Intimate Partner Homicide Timeline. Jane is Professor of Public Protection at University of Gloucestershire. More info on the Homicide Timeline: htt…

1
504 // Toby Anderson 1:28:27

3M ago1:28:27

1:28:27

This episode deals with mature subject matter. In this new episode Tim Pilleri and Lance Reenstierna speak with Denise McGarity about the disappearance of her cousin Toby Anderson from Selma, Oregon in late October / early November 1986. If you have any information please call the Oregon State Police: 1-800-442-2068. Case #SP19-290842. Join the Bri…

1
503 // The Unsolved Murder of Karen Bodine - Part 1 1:00:34

3M ago1:00:34

1:00:34

In this episode Tim Pilleri and Lance Reenstierna speak with Karlee Bodine, daughter of Karen Bodine, about her fight for justice for her mom. Karen's body was found the morning of Jan 22nd, 2007 at a gravel pit adjacent to Littlerock Road Southwest in Olympia, Washington. For more information or to submit tips to the Thurston County Sheriff’s Offi…

1
502 // Dark Tetrad Personality w/ Thais Gibson 1:04:47

4M ago1:04:47

1:04:47

In this new episode, Tim Pilleri and Lance Reenstierna speak with Dr. Thais Gibson about the dark tetrad personality type and the characteristics that come with it. The tetrad is made up of narcissism, psychopathy, machiavellianism, and sadism. Check out the Personal Development School: https://university.personaldevelopmentschool.com/. Follow the …

1
501 // Bennington Triangle - Part 1 - Middie Rivers 1:23:30

4M ago1:23:30

1:23:30

In this new episode, Tim Pilleri and Lance Reenstierna speak with Worcester State University archives librarian Ross Griffiths about the mysterious Bennington Triangle disappearances of Vermont and the disappearance of Middie Rivers from Bickford Hollow, Vermont on November 12th, 1945. 74 year old Middie Rivers was known to be an outdoorsman and di…

1
500 // Cyber Sleuthing & Protecting Yourself w/ Theresa Payton 1:02:54

4M ago1:02:54

1:02:54

In this new episode, Tim Pilleri and Lance Reenstierna speak with author Theresa Payton about cyber security and best practices to keep your online life safe. Theresa M. Payton served as the first female Chief Information Officer for the White House during the President George W. Bush administration and is currently CEO and founder of Fortalice Sol…

1
499 // The Mysterious Death of Sarah Maria Cornell w/ Kate Winkler Dawson 1:10:49

4M ago1:10:49

1:10:49

In this new episode, Tim Pilleri and Lance Reenstierna speak with author and podcaster Kate Winkler Dawson about her new book The Sinners All Bow. Acclaimed journalist, podcaster, and true-crime historian Kate Winkler Dawson tells the true story of the scandalous murder investigation that became the inspiration for both Nathaniel Hawthorne’s The Sc…

1
498 // Retired FBI Jen Coffindaffer on Luigi Mangione, Karen Read, Idaho 4 & More 1:11:17

4M ago1:11:17

1:11:17

In this new episode Tim Pilleri & Lance Reenstierna are joined by retired FBI agent Jennifer Coffindaffer to speak about her coverage of recent crime cases - including Luigi Mangione, Karen Read, the Idaho 4, OJ Simpson and more. Follow Jennifer on Twitter: https://x.com/coffindafferfbi. Follow Jennifer's podcast: Apple: https://podcasts.apple.com/…

1
497 // Fmr Homicide Prosecutor Matt Murphy on LISK Suspect Rex Heuermann & Prosecuting Rodney Alcala 1:14:44

5M ago1:14:44

1:14:44

In this new episode Tim Pilleri & Lance Reenstierna are joined by former homicide prosecutor and current legal analyst for ABC News, Matt Murphy. In this new interview, we speak about serial killers, Rodney Alcala, LISK suspect Rex Heuermann, and much more. In his new book, The Book of Murder, Matt pulls the curtain back for readers as he discusses…

1
496 // The Murder of Trish Haynes - Part 2 1:12:19

5M ago1:12:19

1:12:19

In this new episode, Tim Pilleri & Lance Reenstierna speak with Chloe French about the murder of her former classmate Trish Haynes from Grafton, New Hampshire. Trish was last seen in 2017. If you have helpful information about the murder of Trish Haynes please call the New Hampshire Attorney General's office at 603-271-3671 or 603-223-4381. FB grou…

1
495 // Erica Franolich - Part 5 50:11

5M ago50:11

50:11

In this episode Tim Pilleri and Lance Reenstierna speak with private investigator Greg Overacker about the disappearance of Erica Jayne Franolich from Middleburgh, New York in October of 1986. We discuss and show video from a recent search. This is part five of five. This episode originally aired in 2020. Erica Jayne Franolich was last seen around …

1
494 // Erica Franolich - Part 4 48:25

5M ago48:25

48:25

In this episode, Tim Pilleri and Lance Reenstierna speak with Erica's sister Nada and private investigator Greg Overacker about the disappearance of Erica Franolich from Middleburgh, New York in October of 1986. This is part four of five. This episode originally aired in 2020. Erica Jayne Franolich was last seen around 9 pm on October 13, 1986, nea…

1
493 // Erica Franolich - Part 3 55:50

5M ago55:50

55:50

In this episode, Tim Pilleri and Lance Reenstierna speak with Erica's sister Nada and private investigator Greg Overacker about the disappearance of Erica Franolich from Middleburgh, New York in October of 1986. This is part three of five. This episode originally aired in 2020. Erica Jayne Franolich was last seen around 9 pm on October 13, 1986, ne…

1
492 // Erica Franolich - Part 2 52:47

6M ago52:47

52:47

In this episode, Tim Pilleri and Lance Reenstierna speak with private investigators Greg Overacker and Lou Barry about the disappearance of Erica Franolich from Middleburgh, New York in October of 1986. If you have any helpful information please contact Private Investigations For the Missing at 1-866-331-6660 to leave a message for our investigator…

1
491 // Erica Franolich - Part 1 55:19

6M ago55:19

55:19

In this episode, Tim Pilleri and Lance Reenstierna speak with private investigators Greg Overacker and Lou Barry about the disappearance of Erica Franolich from Middleburgh, New York in October of 1986. If you have any helpful information please contact Private Investigations For the Missing at 1-866-331-6660 to leave a message for our investigator…

Podcasts Worth a Listen

Toby Cooper Podcasts

Podcasts Worth a Listen

Quick Reference Guide