))
Episode 4 | Burn the Math, Save the Girl: Why We Need a New Parable
Manage episode 488261329 series 3667468
Content provided by Katie Smith and Beth Rudden. All podcast content including episodes, graphics, and podcast descriptions are uploaded and provided directly by Katie Smith and Beth Rudden or their podcast platform partner. If you believe someone is using your copyrighted work without your permission, you can follow the process outlined here https://ppacc.player.fm/legal.
In this probing and philosophical episode of And We Feel Fine, Beth Rudden and Katie Smith unravel the myth of effective altruism. Starting with the well-known "drowning girl" parable, they trace the roots of utilitarian thinking and its influence on Silicon Valley billionaires and AI ethics. Through a mix of humor, critique, and care, they call out the harm of individualistic philanthropy, the false promise of "earning to give," and the moral sleight-of-hand in today's tech race.
Instead, they offer humanism—not as a perfect alternative, but as a path grounded in dignity, collaboration, and embodied belonging. This episode is a rallying cry for new stories, shared responsibility, and sacred scholarship.
🔑 Topics Covered:
- The parable of the drowning girl and the rise of effective altruism
- Utilitarianism vs. humanism: what's the real moral framework?
- Billionaire philanthropy, moral math, and systemic harm
- The hidden cost of AI: water, power, and planetary resources
- Collective care vs. the myth of the lone savior
- The case for consent, rituals, and shared decision-making
- Why we need a new parable—and more than one
📌 Key Takeaways:
- Effective altruism often cloaks power in moral math.
- Human beings thrive in collaboration, not competition.
- Ethics without context or consent fails the people it claims to serve.
- Parables shape belief—and we need better ones rooted in care.
- AI must be accountable to those it claims to serve, not just those who build it.
⏱️ Chapters (Timestamps):
- 00:00 The Parable of the Drowning Girl
- 02:30 Utilitarianism and Its Consequences
- 06:00 “Earn to Give” and Billionaire Logic
- 10:00 AI Arms Race and Hidden Costs
- 19:00 Collaboration Over Competition
- 27:00 Consent, Power, and Giving Circles
- 34:00 Religion, Ritual, and the Reclamation of Space
- 44:00 Humanism, Hope, and the Case for New Parables
- 54:00 Sacred Scholarship and Peer-Reviewed Progress
9 episodes
Share
