Aaron Smith: Great coaches admit mistakes and know when to stop coaching

Coaching Culture with Ben Herring

What separates championship team cultures from the rest? For legendary All Blacks halfback Aaron Smith, it comes down to something invisible yet incredibly powerful: "that feeling that binds you all together."
Drawing from his extraordinary career spanning 185 games for the Highlanders and 124 tests for the All Blacks, Smith reveals the stark contrasts between navigating life as both an underdog and a world-beater simultaneously. The Highlanders' 2015 championship season emerged from what Smith calls "pain" - struggling teams that transformed adversity into brotherhood through their "1-39" philosophy where every squad member had equal voice and value.
Smith's most pointed insights target coaching authenticity. "I like when coaches admit they make mistakes," he reflects, explaining how this human quality builds trust that mechanical perfection never can. The greatest coaches, according to Smith, understand timing - knowing when preparation ends and player ownership begins: "Past Thursday night, coaches need to just wait till the game." His candid frustration with coaches who pull out laptops in hotel lobbies draws laughter but carries profound truth about respecting boundaries.
The balance between fun and intensity emerges as a recurring theme. "I always found it helped us switch on more, knowing during the week we'd filled up our fun meter," Smith explains. This counterintuitive approach - that focused enjoyment actually enhances performance when it matters most - challenges conventional thinking about high-performance environments.
Through stories of championship seasons and relationships with coaches like Steve Hansen and Tony Brown, Smith constructs a blueprint for cultural excellence that extends far beyond rugby. Whether you're coaching, leading, or building any team, these lessons in psychological safety, authentic leadership, and the delicate balance between joy and intensity will transform how you think about cultivating championship cultures.
What's your team's invisible thread? How do you fill your fun meter while maintaining intensity when it matters most? Join the conversation beneath this episode – we'd love to hear how these principles translate to your world.

Send us a text

Support the show

Chapters

1. Creating balance in high-pressure moments (00:00:00)

2. Defining culture through feeling (00:02:32)

3. Underdog versus top dog team dynamics (00:04:50)

4. Leading through pain to victory (00:10:05)

5. Tony Brown's coaching brilliance (00:16:45)

6. Brotherhood: The 1-39 culture concept (00:24:35)

7. Building rapport with coaches (00:32:56)

8. Leadership evolves and adapts naturally (00:43:42)

9. Managing teams through wins and losses (00:53:31)

10. Key lessons on coaching authenticity (01:00:19)