Ep16: Scouting with Constraints — How Real-World Limits Shape Smart Decisions

Football Insights Academy Podcast

19:15

Can AI compress the years long research time of a PhD into seconds? Research scientist Max Jaderberg explores how “AI analogs” simulate real-world lab work with staggering speed and scale, unlocking new insights on protein folding and drug discovery. Drawing on his experience working on Isomorphic Labs' and Google DeepMind's AlphaFold 3 — an AI model for predicting the structure of molecules — Jaderberg explains how this new technology frees up researchers' time and resources to better understand the real, messy world and tackle the next frontiers of science, medicine and more. For a chance to give your own TED Talk, fill out the Idea Search Application: ted.com/ideasearch . Interested in learning more about upcoming TED events? Follow these links: TEDNext: ted.com/futureyou TEDAI Vienna: ted.com/ai-vienna Hosted on Acast. See acast.com/privacy for more information.…

about a year ago 43:09

MP3•Episode home

Luis Enrique and Kylian Mbappe

Summary

In this episode, hosts David Bromley and Tom Butterfield discuss the dynamics of their podcast, personal updates, and the impact of technology on traditional roles. They delve into the constraints faced in football recruitment, particularly financial limitations and the importance of player fit within a team's system.

The conversation emphasises the need for adaptability and understanding in the evolving landscape of football analytics and recruitment. In this episode, Tom Butterfield and David Bromley delve into the intricacies of football recruitment, focusing on the evaluation of player fit within team dynamics, the impact of time constraints, and the importance of understanding player motivation. They discuss the necessity of building a balanced squad and how constraints can serve as catalysts for focused recruitment strategies.

The conversation emphasises the significance of having a structured recruitment process and the value of incremental improvements. Additionally, they explore the future of football recruitment in the context of AI and the importance of simulating real-world challenges to prepare for upcoming changes in the industry.

Takeaways

The podcast's informal style helps connect with listeners.
Personal stories enhance the relatability of the hosts.
Technology is reshaping traditional roles in various fields.
Constraints in recruitment can lead to better decision-making.
Financial constraints are a significant factor in football recruitment.
Understanding player fit is crucial for team success.
The human element in recruitment cannot be overlooked.
Data analytics is becoming increasingly important in football.
Adapting to changes in technology is essential for success.
Awareness of constraints can help identify opportunities. Evaluating player fit is crucial for team dynamics.
Time constraints can significantly impact recruitment decisions.
Understanding player motivation is key to performance.
Building a balanced squad is essential for success.
Constraints can help focus recruitment efforts.
A structured recruitment process is vital for effective scouting.
Incremental improvements lead to long-term success in recruitment.
Simulating real-world challenges prepares teams for recruitment.
AI will revolutionize football recruitment in the future.
Networking and learning from others accelerates growth in recruitment.

Useful Links

#Sports #Podcasting Education #Soccer #Tom Butterfield & David Bromley #David Bromley #Tom Butterfield #Euro 2024

Support The Show - Buy David and Tom a bag of peanut M&M's.

Instagram

Youtube Channel

119 episodes

Football Insights Academy Podcast

Ep16: Scouting with Constraints — How Real-World Limits Shape Smart Decisions

Football Insights Academy Podcast

published about a year ago

MP3•Episode home

Luis Enrique and Kylian Mbappe

Summary

Takeaways

The podcast's informal style helps connect with listeners.
Personal stories enhance the relatability of the hosts.
Technology is reshaping traditional roles in various fields.
Constraints in recruitment can lead to better decision-making.
Financial constraints are a significant factor in football recruitment.
Understanding player fit is crucial for team success.
The human element in recruitment cannot be overlooked.
Data analytics is becoming increasingly important in football.
Adapting to changes in technology is essential for success.
Awareness of constraints can help identify opportunities. Evaluating player fit is crucial for team dynamics.
Time constraints can significantly impact recruitment decisions.
Understanding player motivation is key to performance.
Building a balanced squad is essential for success.
Constraints can help focus recruitment efforts.
A structured recruitment process is vital for effective scouting.
Incremental improvements lead to long-term success in recruitment.
Simulating real-world challenges prepares teams for recruitment.
AI will revolutionize football recruitment in the future.
Networking and learning from others accelerates growth in recruitment.

Useful Links

#Sports #Podcasting Education #Soccer #Tom Butterfield & David Bromley #David Bromley #Tom Butterfield #Euro 2024

Support The Show - Buy David and Tom a bag of peanut M&M's.

Instagram

Youtube Channel

119 episodes

All episodes

Football Insights Academy Podcast

1
Ep18: The Shadow Team Model: Training to Build Multi-Window Strategy 34:14

6 weeks ago34:14

34:14

Join the Waiting List - Free Beginners Course Summary In this episode of the Football Insights Academy podcast, hosts Tom Butterfield and David Bromley discuss the intricacies of football recruitment strategies. They explore the importance of persistence in achieving success, the concept of a shadow team for future planning, and the tools necessary for effective player evaluation. The conversation emphasises the need for a consistent recruitment system that can withstand personnel changes and the significance of aligning player strengths with team strategies. Useful Links Join the Waiting List - Free Beginners Course Support The Show - Buy David and Tom a bag of peanut M&M's. Instagram Youtube Channel…

Football Insights Academy Podcast

1
Ep17: The Thinking Behind the Shortlist — How to Justify Player Picks Like a Pro! 36:11

7 weeks ago36:11

36:11

Join the Free Kickstart Challenge Course Summary In this episode of the Football Insights Academy podcast, hosts Tom Butterfield and David Bromley discuss various aspects of football recruitment, including the challenges faced by players in international matches, the constraints that scouts encounter, and the importance of evaluating players from multiple perspectives. They emphasise the need for a systematic approach to player evaluation and the necessity of understanding the different concerns of stakeholders within a football club. In this episode, David Bromley and Tom Butterfield delve into the intricacies of player recruitment in football. They discuss the importance of understanding role fit, behavioral evidence, and strategic fit when evaluating players. The conversation emphasizes the need for a structured approach to recruitment, including anticipating challenges and preparing for future windows. The hosts also highlight the significance of aligning player selections with the club's philosophy and the necessity of ongoing analysis and adaptation in the recruitment process. Takeaways The mental pressure on players can affect their performance. Constraints in recruitment include budget, playing style, and player age. Evaluating players requires both technical analysis and live scouting. Different stakeholders in a club have varying perspectives on player recruitment. It's crucial to prepare for questions from decision-makers in recruitment discussions. Player evaluations should be treated as case studies, not just lists. Understanding the context of a player's performance is essential. Consistency in evaluation criteria is key to effective recruitment. The recruitment process involves balancing financial and performance considerations. Every player signed represents an opportunity cost for the club. The role fit is crucial in player recruitment. Behavioural evidence complements numerical data in evaluations. Strategic fit aligns player choices with club philosophy. Anticipating questions can strengthen recruitment arguments. Preparation for recruitment challenges is essential. Building a shadow team helps in long-term planning. Self-imposed restrictions can clarify recruitment goals. Understanding player behavior is as important as metrics. Recruitment is a continuous process of improvement. Effective communication with stakeholders is key in recruitment. Useful Links Join the Free Kickstart Challenge Course Support The Show - Buy David and Tom a bag of peanut M&M's. Instagram Youtube Channel…

Football Insights Academy Podcast

1
Ep16: Scouting with Constraints — How Real-World Limits Shape Smart Decisions 43:09

8 weeks ago43:09

43:09

Join the Waiting List - Free Beginners Course Luis Enrique and Kylian Mbappe Summary In this episode, hosts David Bromley and Tom Butterfield discuss the dynamics of their podcast, personal updates, and the impact of technology on traditional roles. They delve into the constraints faced in football recruitment, particularly financial limitations and the importance of player fit within a team's system. The conversation emphasises the need for adaptability and understanding in the evolving landscape of football analytics and recruitment. In this episode, Tom Butterfield and David Bromley delve into the intricacies of football recruitment, focusing on the evaluation of player fit within team dynamics, the impact of time constraints, and the importance of understanding player motivation. They discuss the necessity of building a balanced squad and how constraints can serve as catalysts for focused recruitment strategies. The conversation emphasises the significance of having a structured recruitment process and the value of incremental improvements. Additionally, they explore the future of football recruitment in the context of AI and the importance of simulating real-world challenges to prepare for upcoming changes in the industry. Takeaways The podcast's informal style helps connect with listeners. Personal stories enhance the relatability of the hosts. Technology is reshaping traditional roles in various fields. Constraints in recruitment can lead to better decision-making. Financial constraints are a significant factor in football recruitment. Understanding player fit is crucial for team success. The human element in recruitment cannot be overlooked. Data analytics is becoming increasingly important in football. Adapting to changes in technology is essential for success. Awareness of constraints can help identify opportunities. Evaluating player fit is crucial for team dynamics. Time constraints can significantly impact recruitment decisions. Understanding player motivation is key to performance. Building a balanced squad is essential for success. Constraints can help focus recruitment efforts. A structured recruitment process is vital for effective scouting. Incremental improvements lead to long-term success in recruitment. Simulating real-world challenges prepares teams for recruitment. AI will revolutionize football recruitment in the future. Networking and learning from others accelerates growth in recruitment. Useful Links Join the Waiting List - Free Beginners Course Support The Show - Buy David and Tom a bag of peanut M&M's. Instagram Youtube Channel…

Football Insights Academy Podcast

1
Ep15: What a Recruitment Department Actually Does — and How You Can Train Like You're Already Inside One 44:18

9 weeks ago44:18

44:18

Join the Free Beginners Course Summary In this conversation, David Bromley and Tom Butterfield explore the intricacies of football analysis and recruitment. They discuss the importance of contextualizing metrics, the process of translating coach requirements into actionable data, and the significance of key performance indicators in player evaluation. The dialogue emphasizes the transition from amateur scouting to professional recruitment, highlighting the systematic approach needed to identify and evaluate talent effectively. They also introduce the concept of the 'war room' for practical application and community engagement through the Kickstarter Challenge. Takeaways Most courses focus on features rather than simulating functions. Context is crucial for effective analysis in football. Translating coach requirements into metrics is essential. Key performance indicators help streamline player evaluation. Scouting should be systematic and goal-oriented. The process of recruitment evolves from amateur to professional. Community engagement enhances the learning experience. Starting simple allows for gradual improvement. Creativity and resourcefulness are key in analysis. Training with constraints leads to better scouting outcomes. Useful Links Join the Free Beginners Course Support The Show - Buy David and Tom a bag of peanut M&M's. Instagram Youtube Channel…

Football Insights Academy Podcast

1
Ep14: Future-Proofing Yourself — Why Augmented Analysts Will Lead the Next Generation of Football Clubs 37:25

10 weeks ago37:25

37:25

Join the Waiting List - Free Beginners Course Summary In this episode of the Football Insights Academy podcast, hosts Tom Butterfield and David Bromley delve into the integration of AI in football recruitment. They discuss the importance of understanding AI's capabilities, particularly neural networks and natural language processing, and how these technologies can enhance the recruitment process. The conversation emphasizes the significance of prompt engineering to obtain valuable insights from AI, and introduces the concept of the 'war room' as a practical application of AI in recruitment strategies. The hosts highlight the evolving nature of AI in football and the competitive advantage early adopters will have in leveraging these technologies for effective recruitment. In this episode, David Bromley and Tom Butterfield discuss the integration of AI technology in the recruitment process within the football industry. They emphasize the importance of effective prompting to maximize AI's potential, the need for a structured approach to using AI, and the introduction of the War Room as a collaborative learning experience for aspiring recruiters. The conversation highlights the necessity of adapting to technological advancements and the benefits of engaging with AI as a supportive tool rather than a replacement for human insight. Takeaways AI can enhance the recruitment process in football. Understanding AI's capabilities is crucial for effective use. Prompt engineering is essential for getting valuable insights from AI. Specificity in prompts leads to better AI responses. The war room concept allows for practical application of AI in recruitment. AI's potential in football is still evolving and improving. Recruitment strategies must adapt to incorporate AI effectively. Collaboration and communication are key in using AI tools. AI can provide insights similar to a junior colleague's analysis. Early adopters of AI in recruitment will have a competitive advantage. The importance of using technology effectively in recruitment. AI can significantly reduce research time and improve efficiency. Quality of AI responses is directly linked to the quality of prompts. Understanding how to structure prompts can enhance AI training. Many users are not fully utilising AI's capabilities. Engaging with AI early can provide immediate results. AI can simplify processes, reducing the need for technical expertise. The War Room offers a hands-on approach to learning recruitment. Collaboration and diverse opinions enhance the learning experience. Useful Links Join the Waiting List - Free Beginners Course Support The Show - Buy David and Tom a bag of peanut M&M's. Instagram Youtube Channel…

Football Insights Academy Podcast

1
Ep13: How to Work With AI Like a Football Recruitment Analyst, Not Like a Casual User 35:28

11 weeks ago35:28

35:28

Join the Waiting List - Free Beginners Course Episode Summary: In this episode, Tom and David dive deep into how AI, particularly large language models like ChatGPT, can be integrated professionally into the football recruitment process. It's not about asking vague questions and hoping for magic — it’s about treating your AI assistant like a valued member of your recruitment team. The duo discuss the critical difference between casual and professional use of AI, highlighting prompt engineering , context-building , and the anatomy of a strong prompt. They explain how these tools, when used correctly, can drastically improve efficiency and decision-making in scouting and recruitment. And the big announcement? The Football Insights “War Room” experience — a live, interactive, small-group simulation of a professional club's recruitment process. You’ll go from defining a club’s identity and playing style, all the way through to player valuation and transfer decision-making using real data and AI-supported tools. It’s hands-on learning for anyone serious about working in football recruitment. 🔍 Topics Covered: Why most people misuse AI like a search engine — and how to do it better How to brief AI tools like you'd brief a real Head of Recruitment The anatomy of a high-quality prompt in football analysis The importance of structured, context-rich input for meaningful output What makes the War Room such a unique and powerful learning experience How prompt templates will guide learners through real-world scenarios 💡 Key Takeaways: AI in football isn’t a replacement — it’s an amplifier when used with clarity and precision Good prompts = good insights. Vague prompts = wasted time Real recruitment decisions are layered with complexity: style of play, budgets, coach philosophy, data filtering, and scouting The War Room will simulate this entire process, allowing participants to learn by doing , just like real football departments do. 🎯 Who This Episode Is For: Aspiring scouts, analysts, and recruitment professionals Coaches curious about data-driven recruitment processes Football students or early-career professionals wanting to future-proof their skillset Anyone eager to use AI properly in a football context Useful Links Join the Waiting List - Free Beginners Course Support The Show - Buy David and Tom a bag of peanut M&M's. Instagram Youtube Channel…

Football Insights Academy Podcast

1
Ep12: The Recruitment Process That Helps You Think Like a Real Football Club 48:04

12 weeks ago48:04

48:04

Join the Free Football Analyst Kickstarter Challenge Recruitment Process with AI Integration PDF Summary In this episode of the Football Insights Academy podcast, hosts Tom Butterfield and David Bromley discuss the evolving landscape of football recruitment, emphasizing the importance of a structured process that incorporates AI and data analysis. They break down the recruitment process into three key stages: Talent Identification Player Evaluation Target Acquisition Highlighting the need for clubs to adapt to changing circumstances and maintain effective communication between coaching and recruitment teams. In this conversation, David Bromley and Tom Butterfield delve into the complexities of football recruitment, emphasising the importance of objective processes in player valuation and squad dynamics. They discuss the integration of AI into recruitment strategies, highlighting the potential benefits of prompt engineering to enhance decision-making. The conversation also touches on the War Room experience, a practical approach to recruitment, and concludes with insights on nutrition and healthy living. Takeaways Recruitment in football is evolving with AI and data analysis. A structured recruitment process is essential for success. Talent identification involves filtering a large pool of players. Player evaluation focuses on fit within a team's style of play. Target acquisition requires understanding player values and contract demands. The recruitment model is a three-part process: identification, evaluation, acquisition. Continuous evaluation and adaptation of processes are necessary. Understanding the psychological profile of players is crucial. Clubs must balance short-term needs with long-term squad building. Effective communication between coaches and recruitment teams is vital. You need an objective process for player valuation. Overpaying for players can lead to significant problems for clubs. AI can enhance recruitment processes by providing valuable insights. Prompt engineering is crucial for maximizing AI effectiveness. The War Room experience offers practical recruitment training. Understanding player roles is essential for effective recruitment. AI can help distill complex conversations into actionable insights. Nutrition plays a vital role in overall well-being. Continuous improvement in AI interactions leads to better outcomes. Celery juice is an acquired taste!! Useful Links Join the Free Football Analyst Kickstarter Challenge Support The Show - Buy David and Tom a bag of peanut M&M's. Instagram Youtube Channel…

Football Insights Academy Podcast

1
Ep11: Why the Future of Football Recruitment Belongs to the Process-Driven and AI-Savvy Analyst 34:32

13 weeks ago34:32

34:32

Join the Waiting List - Free Beginners Course Summary In this episode of the Football Insights Academy podcast, Tom Butterfield and David Bromley discuss the evolving landscape of football recruitment, emphasising the significant impact of AI on analysis and decision-making. They outline essential skills for future analysts, including building a repeatable recruitment process, working with AI as a copilot, and the importance of storytelling in presenting data. The conversation highlights the urgency for professionals in the field to adapt to these changes and embrace the opportunities presented by AI technology. Takeaways Football recruitment is changing rapidly due to AI. Analysts must equip themselves with core skills for the future. Building a repeatable recruitment process is essential. AI can serve as a valuable copilot in analysis. Data alone won't impress decision-makers; storytelling is key. The recruitment process should be a work in progress. AI presents a massive opportunity for analysts. Professionals need to get on board with AI technology. The impact of AI on recruitment is imminent and significant. Embracing change is crucial for success in the industry. Useful Links Join the Waiting List - Free Beginners Course Support The Show - Buy David and Tom a bag of peanut M&M's. Instagram Youtube Channel…

Football Insights Academy Podcast

1
Ep10: What Makes A Good Recruitment Decision? 37:20

14 weeks ago37:20

37:20

Join the Waiting List - Free Beginners Course Episode 10 Tables and Charts Summary In this episode of the Football Insights Academy podcast, Tom Butterfield and David Bromley discuss the intricacies of football recruitment. They explore what constitutes a good recruitment decision, the importance of having a clear process, and the challenges of evaluating player fit versus talent. The conversation also delves into the global market for players and the adaptability challenges that come with it. A case study on Chelsea's recent recruitment strategy highlights the potential pitfalls of over-recruitment and the consequences it can have on team dynamics. In this conversation, David Bromley and Tom Butterfield discuss the complexities of football management, focusing on Chelsea's recent challenges with squad management and player recruitment. They explore the impact of managerial changes, the importance of a structured recruitment process, and the need for alignment between club vision and player signings. The discussion also highlights the significance of developing young talent and the potential pitfalls of rushed recruitment decisions. The episode concludes with an introduction to the Kickstart Challenge, aimed at preparing individuals for the intricacies of football management. Takeaways Good recruitment decisions are based on a structured process. Having a clear brief is essential for effective recruitment. Filtering players is a massive challenge due to the vast number available. Evaluating player fit is more important than just assessing talent. The global market introduces adaptability challenges for players. Intangible elements play a crucial role in player recruitment. Chelsea's recruitment strategy raises questions about fit and culture. Over-recruitment can lead to tactical imbalances within a team. The pressure on managers increases with poor recruitment decisions. Successful recruitment requires a balance of talent and team dynamics. Chelsea's managerial instability has led to a bloated and unbalanced squad. The influx of attacking players can hinder the development of young talent. A clear pathway for youth players is essential for their growth. Recruitment decisions should align with the club's long-term vision. Opportunistic signings may not fit into a team's playing style. Young players often need time to develop before being thrust into the spotlight. A structured recruitment process can help mitigate risks in player signings. Collaboration between management and scouting is crucial for effective recruitment. Football management requires adaptability to changing circumstances. The Kickstart Challenge offers a foundational understanding of football management. Useful Links Join the Waiting List - Free Beginners Course Support The Show - Buy David and Tom a bag of peanut M&M's. Instagram Youtube Channel…

Football Insights Academy Podcast

1
Ep9: We're Building A Football Club - Want In? 36:31

15 weeks ago36:31

36:31

Join the Waiting List - 4-Day Football Analyst Kickstart Challenge Summary In this episode of the Football Insights Academy podcast, hosts Tom Butterfield and David Bromley delve into the critical role of data analysis in football, discussing its implications for recruitment and scouting. They explore the recruitment process within football clubs, emphasising the importance of collaboration between coaches, analysts, and scouts. The conversation introduces the concept of a 'War Room' simulation to help aspiring analysts understand the recruitment process better. The hosts also highlight the significance of consistency in evaluating players and building a target matrix for acquisitions. They conclude with an invitation to join the 4-Day Football Analyst Kickstart Challenge, aimed at providing foundational knowledge for those interested in football analytics. Takeaways Data analysis in football is lagging behind other sports. Clubs need to collaborate effectively for successful recruitment. Simulating a recruitment team can enhance understanding. Understanding playing styles is crucial for player evaluation. Consistency in scouting is key to successful recruitment. Building a target matrix helps streamline player acquisition. Data should complement, not replace, subjective evaluations. Proactive recruitment strategies prevent panic buys. The Kickstart Challenge offers a great introduction to football analytics. Learning by doing is essential in understanding recruitment processes. Useful Links Join the Waiting List - 4-Day Football Analyst Kickstart Challenge Support The Show - Buy David and Tom a bag of peanut M&M's. Instagram Youtube Channel…

Football Insights Academy Podcast

1
Ep8: Does Momentum Make A Difference? 44:41

17 weeks ago44:41

44:41

Join the Waiting List - Free Beginners Course As we get towards the business end of the season we get cup finals, promotion races, play off scrambles, and relegation battles. Pundits, Coaches and Fans will start talking about the need to 'Get Some Momentum' moving into this critical stage of the season.... We can probably think of a team who stormed into the play offs, made the great escape from relegation.... but does it happen as often as we think? Frankly, we wanted to see if momentum was real, or is it a myth? Here's an old episode where David put in the hours to find us an answer based on the available data for the EFL Championship. Useful Links Join the Waiting List - Free Beginners Course Support The Show - Buy David and Tom a bag of peanut M&M's. Instagram Youtube Channel…

Football Insights Academy Podcast

1
Ep7: How Important Is Scoring The First Goal? Is It Different For Every Team? 42:09

18 weeks ago42:09

42:09

Join the Waiting List - Free Beginners Course How many times do you watch a game of football where the commentators or pundits say 'The first goal will be vital today.' Yeah of course you always want to score first, because you want to score!! But does it really make a difference who scores the first goal in an EFL Championship game? We threw that logical hand grenade to David Bromley who set about collecting the data and changed the raw information into a format that gave us a clear insight into; 1) Is scoring the first goal important? 2) Is There a Difference Related To The Team Playing Style? 3) Which Teams Struggle When Conceding The First Goal? 4) Which Teams Are Least Affected By Going Behind? It was a very interesting dive into a commonly asked question and it left us in no doubt about the answer. Charts and Tables For Episode 29 First Goal Playing Styles First Goal Teams - Scatter Plot Team - First Goal Table Useful Links Join the Waiting List - Free Beginners Course Support The Show - Buy David and Tom a bag of peanut M&M's. Instagram Youtube Channel…

Football Insights Academy Podcast

1
Ep6: Why It's So Important To Try And Create A Process.....Not Perfection! 27:41

19 weeks ago27:41

27:41

Join the Waiting List - Free Beginners Course Summary In this episode of the Football Insights Academy podcast, hosts Tom Butterfield and David Bromley discuss the importance of transforming raw data into actionable insights in football analytics. They emphasise the need for storytelling through data, the significance of context in interpreting numbers, and the value of visualising data to enhance understanding. The conversation also highlights the necessity of simplifying complex information to make it accessible and actionable for coaches and recruitment personnel. Ultimately, the episode aims to equip listeners with the knowledge to effectively analyse player performance and make informed decisions based on data. Takeaways Storytelling through data is essential in football analytics. Data provides unassailable facts about player performance. Context is crucial for interpreting numbers effectively. Visual representations of data enhance understanding. Simplicity in data presentation is key to engagement. Actionable insights are the ultimate goal of data analysis. Avoiding jargon helps communicate insights better. The best analysts focus on boiling down data into insights. Understanding the 'so what?' of data is vital for decision-making. Data is powerful only when it is understood and actionable. Useful Links Join the Waiting List - Free Beginners Course Support The Show - Buy David and Tom a bag of peanut M&M's. Instagram Youtube Channel…

Football Insights Academy Podcast

1 year ago1:27:13