The Last Letter That Changed Everything

Hold My Cutter

Send us a text

Baseball journeys rarely follow a straight path, and Sean Casey's story proves just how winding and meaningful that road can be. The man known as "The Mayor" opens up about the Pittsburgh mentors who shaped his career long before he reached the majors, revealing the profound impact of figures like Joe Ringel and Frank Porco who believed in him when college scouts weren't calling.
In this emotionally charged conversation, Casey takes us back to his teenage years when his father delivered the tough message that would change his life: "Nobody's coming for you." That lesson sparked a determination that led him to write 31 college recruitment letters—the final one opening the door that would eventually lead to a stellar MLB career.
The podcast captures several tearful moments, including a surprise live call to Joe Ringel, the man who took teenage Casey to Three Rivers Stadium for batting practice sessions that helped him develop into a .296 hitter against lefties. When discussing his trade to his hometown Pirates, Casey's voice breaks as he describes the pride of representing Pittsburgh and seeing his family in the stands.
Casey also shares fascinating insights from his recent stint as Yankees hitting coach, discussing the delicate balance between analytics and simplicity in modern baseball. His perspective on transitioning from player to coach to broadcaster offers valuable wisdom about life after playing days end.
Whether recounting borrowing Manny Ramirez's bat for his first MLB hit or describing the Pittsburgh dedication to community that shaped his character, Casey's stories illuminate why baseball connections run so deep. For anyone who understands that sports careers are built on the shoulders of unsung heroes, this conversation will remind you why we fall in love with the game in the first place.
Check out Hold My Cutter podcast for more conversations with baseball's most insightful personalities. Subscribe wherever you get your podcasts.

THANK YOU FOR LISTENING!!!!
www.holdmycutter.com

Chapters

1. Welcome to Hold My Cutter (00:00:00)

2. Sean Casey: Hitting Coach Philosophy (00:03:29)

3. The Art of Teaching MLB Hitters (00:10:15)

4. Numbers vs. Simplicity in Baseball (00:17:51)

5. Life After Baseball and Transition Struggles (00:25:57)

6. The Trade to Pittsburgh: Coming Home (00:35:00)

7. The Influence of Pittsburgh Mentors (00:44:22)

8. The Power of One Letter and Opportunity (00:52:13)