61. Jonah Goodhart – Colonize-ing Right Media and building a Moat

Paleo Ad Tech

#Tech #Business #Marketing #Martin Kihn #Ad Tech

31:46

BE WARNED! This podcast will contain spoilers for Wednesday Season 2, episodes 1-4. Join host Caitlin Reilly each week as she takes you deep into the twisted world of Wednesday with an amazing group of guests! And producer Thing will be helping out to make sure everything goes to plan - well, mostly, anyway... In this episode: Jenna Ortega peels back the layers on the new tension between Wednesday and Enid. And that terrifying vision! Plus… Series showrunners Al Gough and Miles Millar reveal why they made Morticia Addams such a central character in this season, and what it means for Wednesday. Whether you’re a normie or an outcast, the Wednesday Season 2 Official Woecast will be the place for all things Nevermore! For more juicy details about Wednesday Season 2, head over to Tudum.com to get all of the latest updates. 1:15 Preparing for Season 2 3:25 Evolving Wednesday’s look for Season 2 4:12 Addams clan expands for Season 2 6:12 Joanna Lumley joining the cast 7:38 Wednesday and Enid's Friendship 9:00 Wednesday’s Vision 10:50 Jenna is a Producer 13:45 Al and Miles introduction 14:03 Wednesday takes down a Serial Killer 15:05 Intergenerational Relationships & the Addams Women 17:48 Catherine Zeta-Jones as Morticia in Season 2 20:48 Wednesday and Enid’s relationship 24:04 Steve Buscemi joining the cast 26:19 Wednesday’s popular! 27:45 Boy with the Clockwork Heart stop motion sequence…

2 years ago 37:02

MP3•Episode home

Goodhart was a recipient of the Ernst & Young Entrepreneur of the Year award in 2017. Jonah was also a member of Mayor Bloomberg’s Council on Technology and Innovation.

[Note: a more in-depth bio and discussion about Jonah’s intriguing career — which spans the arc of ad tech from the 1990s to today — can be found in this previous discussion with Marty, as well as of course in the episode itself.]

69 episodes

61. Jonah Goodhart – Colonize-ing Right Media and building a Moat

Paleo Ad Tech

published 2 years ago

MP3•Episode home

Goodhart was a recipient of the Ernst & Young Entrepreneur of the Year award in 2017. Jonah was also a member of Mayor Bloomberg’s Council on Technology and Innovation.

69 episodes

#Tech #Business #Marketing #Martin Kihn #Ad Tech

All episodes

Paleo Ad Tech

1
67. Ramsey McGrory – DoubleClick to Mediaocean via Right Media 36:54

49 weeks ago36:54

36:54

Ramsey McGrory started his career in the U.S. Army and later found himself at the mighty DoubleClick in 1999 at the peak of the dot-com boom as an ad sales exec “banging the phones” selling direct-response ads to finance and insurance companies. He joined the seminal Right Media in 2004 as VP of platform and ad sales, staying on after Yahoo acquired the company in 2007. Later, Ramsey was CEO at AddThis , acquired by Oracle, and president at Scout Media before joining his old friend and former PaleoAdTech guest Bill Wise at Mediaocean, where he is CDO. As Ramsey tells Marty in this fascinating episode, he fell into advertising by accident in the 1990s after starting his career in New York at Citibank, working on then-trendy derivatives; a hiring manager moved over to a little-known startup called DoubleClick and suggested he join up. Ten interviews later (none with founder Kevin O’Connor), he was hired as a display ads sales rep, a career change for this former Army logistics specialist. He thrived on the chaos and excitement of the boom. “It was a very diverse community,” he recalls. “You’d get the super-engineering quant types, you’d get the creative types and everything in between.” In the process, Ramsey learned a lot about how to make advertising work on the internet as part of a direct-response group (distinct from the more premium DoubleClick brand-sales group) led by Bill Wise and Mike Walrath. The process was manual: he got a daily spreadsheet describing publishers, impressions, cost, conversions; and he would make tweaks to targeting and frequency capping. Daily frustration led to innovation, years later: “The concept of Right Media came out of DoubleClick’s unwillingness to invest in an ad server and a media business that was focused on meeting direct-response goals,” Ramsey says. DoubleClick went through 7-8 rounds of layoffs after the dot-com crash as the brand-ad market cratered and colleague after colleague was called into the HR office on the 13th floor of the luxe “Click City” on 33rd and 10th. Ramsey’s niche in direct-response stayed relatively steady: “How many times have these direct response advertisers said, if you’re meeting my goals, I’ve got unlimited budget?” Ramsey followed ex-DoubleClicker Mike Walrath to Right Media, which Walrath founded in 2003 in the offices of Joe Zawadzki’ s Poindexter (later called [x+1]). Of course, Right Media gained an inestimable asset when the technically-brilliant Brian O’Kelley joined and a series of fundamental ad-serving and network innovations unrolled, setting up the era of RTB. Ramsey describes a market with rampant impressions on sites like MySpace, requiring scale (O’Kelley’s specialty as an engineer and the topic of his Princeton thesis paper) but also inspiring new ideas. Optimization was primarily by “suppression.” Meaning: the advertiser picked a price point (e.g., $2.50 CPM) and inventory would be optimized by changing geos, websites, frequency — optimization happening by removing placements, which lowered scale and decreased spend. The team experimented, creating campaign segments at different price points in the ad server. This tactic raised the frequency cap for ads: “You’re bombing the same ad unit and the ad unit is effectively sort of competing with itself,” Ramsey explains. At this point, O’Kelley had one of his insights: “Brian looked at it and said, ‘We just built this wrong.'” Meaning: the ad server (called Manage) optimized inventory against a set price. But what if that model could be changed — what if campaigns could flip the model from optimizing inventory against price to optimizing price against inventory? Thus: dynamic pricing. It was a fundamental conceptual and technical change. Now theoretically every advertiser could look at every impression, which improves yields for publishers. Advertisers were told that the eCPM (average CPM over the campaign) could be lower overall than the previously-set price but the scale would go up 5X (say) because more inventory is available. This technology, rebuilt by O’Kelley, became Yield Manager, and it was licensed to a number of ad networks including Right Media’s own. At this point the 3-4 networks in the group noticed they had all trafficked demand and supply tags into one another. This observation in turn led the ad server to morph into the first “exchange,” where users (at first, ad networks) would have a “seat” and connect to other seat-holders without having to use a lot of cross-tagging. This was the pioneering Right Media Exchange (RMX) of song and legend. The only tags used were the creative tags on the page. There was an auction for each impression. However, a limitation was that all the intelligence required had to be synched into the exchange. (This data-sharing requirement made some large buyers like P&G uncomfortable.) The next evolution was the emergence of DSPs and SSPs which pulled decision intelligence from the exchange itself into buy- and sell-side platforms. How did buyers and sellers react to the idea of an ad exchange? At first, Ramsey says, it was not difficult to describe an auction — after all, everyone knew how the stock market and paid search ads worked, — but “dynamic pricing” made buyers uneasy. The Right Media sales team came up with the idea of “PANT People,” styrofoam figures brought into meetings to demonstrate for visual-tactile learners how the platform worked. PANT stood for the parties in the exchange: Publisher-Advertiser-Network-Technology. The challenge with dynamic pricing was that it made ad serving fees (then materially higher than today, say, $0.05-0.07) difficult to forecast. Objections were met by focusing the market on eCPM and setting a maximum bid that was higher the eCPM so more inventory could be accessed. After Yahoo’s acquisition of Right Media, Ramsey stayed at Yahoo for four years, which he says he enjoyed. He started at Mediaocean eight years ago as CRO, building a sales function beyond the original holding-company core and now shepherds mergers and acquisitions, of which Mediaocean made 10-12 in recent years. The largest of these was Flashtalking, run by PaleoAdTech guest John Nardone , which powers the fast-growing digital component of Mediaocean’s business.…

Paleo Ad Tech

1
66. Daniel Jaye – starting it all with Engage 46:13

1 year ago46:13

46:13

Daniel Jaye was co-founder in 1995 of Engage, a pioneer in bringing database marketing to the internet. A competitor of DoubleClick, Engage built arguably the largest database of pseudonymous profiles at the time, and Daniel and his team created innovative technologies for ETL, large-scale analytics and behavioral targeting. Daniel was also the man behind much of the technical resourcefulness of the ad network Tacoda. In 2010, he co-founded another technically ingenious startup called Korrelate, an ad attribution solution. Today he is CEO Aqfer , a marketing data plataform-as-a-service company based in Florida. An astrophysicist inspired by Tom Swift stories in his youth, Daniel began his adult journey in management consulting and then joined Epsilon, where he worked on an early pen-based PDA before enlisting at Fidelity. At the time — as Daniel tells Marty in this erudite episode — there were two companies pushing the boundaries of data management: Walmart (supporting scale) and Fidelity (supporting complexity). At Fidelity, Daniel’s job was to run its Teradata-based massively-parallel processing (MPP) environment. In this era before Hadoop, Daniel developed a global reputation as a cross-platform high-scale data management expert. This reputation reached the ear of David Wetherell , the energetic CEO of CMGi, and Wetherell approached Daniel with a compelling (if rather vague) idea: “Bring database marketing to the internet.” It was 1995. Netscape was one year old. At the time, CMGi — the name stood for College Marketing Group Inc. — had a database of consumers linked to their book- and magazine-buying behaviors. So it could be used to tie people to their areas of interest and serve marketers. Seizing the opportunity of the nascent internet, Wetherell used some smart acquisitions to amass a warchest to fund a successful venture arm and an operating division to build its own ideas. At its peak during the dot-com boom, CMGI was a massive holding company with a roster of storied internet brands: Lycos (search engine), GeoCities (web hosting), Planet Direct (portals), FlyCast (ad network), AdKnowledge (ad server), etc. It eventually had 5,000 employees and $1.5 billion revenue and was #7-9 in terms of web traffic to its properties. The New England Patriots’ stadium was called CMGi Field. Daniel became CMGi’s acting CTO with the proto-database project as his day job. The company was based at Brickstone Square in Andover, Mass. After a privacy audit during his time at Fidelity, Daniel realized that there was actually no need to have personally-identifiable information (PII) to do the analytical work for database marketing: segmentation and list management. PII could be appended later, but it was not needed for analysis. “That’s what actually inspired online profiling,” he recalls. “We could raise the bar versus traditional direct mail because we did not need to know who you are in the real world in order to make … advertising and content relevant to you based on your interests.” So Engage was built on the Fidelity-inspired direct mail idea to build anonymous profiles, plus cookies. Daniel’s first technical challenge was scale, handling clickstream data and data from portfolio partners like Lycos. “I knew that the tools didn’t exist,” he admits. So he had to build them. He ended up crafting three products: The first parallel-ETL tool for data processing An analytics tool for discovery and iteration Interest-based anonymous profiles (which they called “cybertargeting”) At the end of 18 months, the tools were real. The first (called Engage Fusion) and the second (Engage Discover) were soon sold to the data warehousing company Redbrick for about $10 million. CMGi kept cybertargeting, which became Engage. Engage’s solution for cybertargeting could process log data and online event data — and then create cookie-based profiles to target and measure marketing campaigns and analyze web traffic. By 1998, DoubleClick had gone public and CMGI wanted to get into the ad serving game. It acquired Accipiter for $35 million, a rival of the on-premise ad server NetGravity (later acquired by DoubleClick). In the spirit of building things that don’t exist, Daniel also filed what may well have been the first patent for cookie-synching. So while PaleoAdTech’s friend Lou Montulli may have invented the cookie at Netscape, Daniel says, “I am the inventor of all the evil uses of cookies [wink].” There was also an algorithm that determined peoples’ interests from their browsing behavior and, eventually, got at various levels of interest. While Engage now offered an integrated data and ad server platform, it had challenges. It was difficult (aka impossible) to build an internet data-selling business until the real-time bidding era a decade later, when Exelate and BlueKai realized Engage’s original data-network dream. There was the persistent, rarely-discussed problem of decaying profiles and stale data. So while at one point Engage may have had 130 million unique profiles in its database, only a portion of them were actually useful. CMGi went public in 1999, launched its own ad network called AudienceNet (combining Accipter and Engage profile data), and was hammered of course by the dot-com meltdown that began in 2000, laying off staff and selling assets. For various dot-com financing reasons, the company didn’t have the cash to endure and eventually dissolved. After an exciting interlude at Tacoda — which we will (Marty hopes) discuss in a future episode [in the meantime, enjoy this previous episode with Tacoda’s founder Dave Morgan], — Daniel resurfaced in 2010 with Korrelate, an ad analytics company. It emerged from an problem related to AOL’s acquisition of Tacoda: how to get AOL’s other properties, like Ads.com, to work with it. Daniel’s solution included a forerunner of header bidding he called federated RTB (sold to Operative Media) and Korrelate, which tied digital clickstream data to offline events like sales. It performed online-to-offline attribution. Korrelate could tie ad impressions to offline sales — for example, partnering with Polk for DMV registration data, — as well as give marketers insights into the impact of their digital channels on sales. In this way, General Motors learned that their online form wasn’t nearly as powerful as their configurator for predicting sales. Ultimately, Korrelate couldn’t compete with Datalogix , which sold media targeting data and provided its measurement service like Korrelate’s for free. “We were competing with free,” he says. “And I learned my lesson then about selling analytics standalone.” Korrelate ran into trouble in 2014 and was sold to JD Power. Today at Aqfer, Jaye says, he’s still in a position to make use of his prolific technical imagination. “What I do,” he says, “is I sell the technology that I’ve had to build in every company … as a platform.”…

Paleo Ad Tech

1
65. Adam Singolda – the tabula rasa of Taboola 32:37

1 year ago32:37

32:37

Adam Singolda is the Founder and CEO of Taboola , a performance-focused advertising company he started in 2007 after spending seven years as a cryptological engineer in the Israeli Defense Forces. Today, Taboola is a public company with 2023 revenues of $1.4 billion (and growing nicely ), around 2,000 employees in 22 countries, 18,000 advertiser customers reaching 600M daily users. It acquired Connexity (formerly Shopzilla) in 2021 for $800M, expanding its offering into commerce- and retail-focused recommendations and ads. It’s based in NYC and still has a large presence near Tel Aviv, where it was founded. Taboola took a circuitous route to its present incarnation. As Adam tells Marty in this lively episode, his vision after leaving the IDF was to start a company that was a video recommender system — to the solve the problem, he says, that he never knew what to watch on TV. Initial investors were friends and family and, on one memorable occasion, an acquaintance of his mother’s Adam accosted at a bat mitvah to which he had not been invited. Adam was always self-directed. Living in Israel as a kid, he tried to start a babysitting and tutoring syndicate and then a short-lived text-based news-and-entertainment alert company he called 24Go. And he had an entrepreneurial family: his father Avi Singolda is a well-known studio guitarist and band leader in Israeli who once played “Here Comes the Sun” with Sir George Martin (“the only time I’ve ever seen him nervous,” Adam says of his father). The name Taboola came from the Latin tabula rasa (“blank slate”), combined with the “oo” motif from successful internet companies Facebook, Yahoo and Google; and the domain taboola.com was available for $10 in 2007. The company had a hard time finding a business model, and Adam admits that in the beginning he didn’t know anything about the ad business (a trait shared with many PaleoAdTech founders). At first, he pitched publishers on the idea of paying a fee for a video recommendation engine; then he tried a revenue share from money made from recommended videos. Neither worked. “I almost shut down Taboola three times,” Adam says. “It’s a very hard moment because you’re very small, when you’re a company of 10 people or 15 people and you know, and nobody else does, that you have money for a month or two. It’s really stressful.” It was only in November, 2011 when for the first time Taboola allowed someone to pay them to be discovered on someone else’s site that “the revenue started to go up and to the right.” Adam doesn’t name his first client but admits it’s a large publisher we all know (like Forbes, perhaps). The idea of a content-and-article recommendation engine with sponsored links mixed in with organic links was born, and Taboola did not look back. The company went from almost no revenue in 2011 to $200M in 2014 and is on track to $2 billion by 2024 or so. It charges a CPC (which varies from pennies to dollars per click) or sometimes a CPM and shares some of the revenue with publishers. Its customers are “performance ninjas” who are looking for traffic and action, not upper-funnel branding. The algorithm uses pixels on the advertisers’ pages to see if ads result in actions, which improves targeting. So Taboola functions like a performance ad network. There were always competitors, including RevContent and Outbrain . The latter and Taboola were reportedly involved in merger talks for years that fell apart near the beginning of the Covid pandemic in 2020. In 2021, Taboola went public via a SPAC on the Nasdaq exchange at a valuation of about $2.6 billion. Adam’s goals remain lofty and he admits he’s an optimistic person by nature. He sees Taboola as a content recommendation engine for the open internet (outside the gardens), and the acquisition of Connexity as a way to become the web’s product recommendation engine. Recent features include Maximize Conversion, which is a kind of autopilot for outcomes similar to Google’s PerformanceMax, and an AI-enabled ad-design tool.…

Paleo Ad Tech

1
64. Greg Smith – Boomerang-ing through DoubleClick, EchoTarget and Aniview 26:58

1 year ago26:58

26:58

Greg joined DoubleClick in 1998 as a product manager after a stop in management consulting, and he became passionate about the early retargeting solution for advertisers called Boomerang. In 2005, he founded dynamic retargeting company EchoTarget, which was acquired by Acxiom in 2007. Today he is GM North America at Aniview , an Israel-based video monetization platform for web, mobile and CTV. Joining the diabolically-hot DoubleClick in NYC in the ’90s via a headhunter, Greg was hired by product leader David Rosenblatt, later to become the company’s turnaround CEO. At the time, Rosenblatt ran a small group called Closed Loop Marketing, one of DoubleClick’s three lines of business. (The other two were Wenda Millard’s media network and the original DART ad server.) Rosenblatt’s Closed Loop Marketing unit also had three power plays, as Greg tells Marty in this far-ranging chat. One was what would become DART for Advertisers; another was Boomerang cookie-based retargeting; and the other was DataBank, an ad database that helped tracking and conversion optimization. Sensing its potential, Greg adopted Boomerang and convinced the bosses that it should be part of the media group, under Millard; and thus it was moved. It was an incendiary time, with the legendary parties (just mention “Oompah Loompah” to any staffer of that era and watch their reaction). The staff doubled in 2000, its last boom moment for a long while. Retargeting “was successful right away,” Greg reports. With an early customer “we doubled click rate” — but more important, customers like Victoria’s Secret were able to show much better click-to-conversion rates using retargeting. The music stopped — for everyone — in 2001, and Greg in time found himself at Cendant , a megacorporation with some holdings in travel. While there, Greg was exposed to a technology which he believed could be configured into a dynamic retargeting solution. Rather than a static tag, like Boomerang’s, it could provide data about origin and destination of a trip, which might then be populated into an ad. Greg founded EchoTarget in 2005, using the dynamic tech and the Right Media and DoubleClick exchanges. Early customers like Spirit Airlines adopted what EchoTarget called “dynamic retargeting,” and the company claimed click-rate improvements from 2x-8x. It was an advantaged data solution, although competitors like Dotomi appeared. Greg at the Ad:Tech event Eventually signing up non-travel customers such as Nestle Waters, EchoTarget’s portfolio remained about 70% travel-focused at the time of the company’s acquisition by Acxiom in 2007, for an undisclosed amount. Today, Greg is GM North America at Aniview, which he describes as an “end-to-end video platform company,” predominantly serving publishers. It offers a video player, video ad server, CMS and server-side-ad-insertion for CTV. The biggest component of Aniview’s business is a marketplace.…

Paleo Ad Tech

1
63. Jason Fairchild – developing GoTo, OpenX and tvScientific 29:40

2 years ago29:40

29:40

Jason was the co-founder with his fellow Yahoo veteran Tim Cadogan of OpenX, a pioneering ad server and then programmatic exchange that launched in 2008. Today he is co-founder and CEO of tvScientific , a CTV-oriented programmatic platform. Jason began his journey in business development in Southern California at one of the original ISPs, Earthlink , which persists to this day. Then living in Pasadena, he was an avid follower of the Idealab incubator, led by the monumental Bill Gross , who became a mentor. One of Idealab’s startups that Jason noticed was GoTo.com – and he joined as one of the company’s first two dozen employees, powering business development and deal-making. As Jason tells Marty in this penetrating episode, it “almost didn’t matter” what GoTo actually did, so eager was he to join the Idealab orbit. As legend has it, GoTo started as an algorithmic search engine, until Bill Gross came back after a weekend’s thought and decided it should try something that had never been done before: rank results based on how much advertisers bid on the keyword(s). Paid search was born. It was a tough sell, as Jason admits. Advertisers had to become comfortable with keywords, bidding, measurement, a whole new vocabulary and method of paying for attention and intent. Ironically, it took the dot-com crash to catalyze GoTo’s business, as cash-strapped marketers realized search was a (seemingly) highly-accountable channel. GoTo (then renamed Overture) was acquired by Yahoo in 2003 for a reported $1.8 billion . Jason and Tim Cadogan founded OpenX in 2008 with the idea of building a “more real-time” version of Right Media. Originally offering an open source ad server, the founding pair assumed their thousands of ad-serving customers would happily join a proto-exchange and provide a willing source of inventory. They were wrong. What followed was a “brick by brick” assembly of an exchange, in the midst of the financial crisis. It was slow going. The build required recruiting a publisher, putting them on the exchange, then finding a buyer; and so on. What tipped the scales was a deal with Fox Audience Network, which was flush with user-level data from its MySpace acquisition and looking for a way to use that extend its inventory elsewhere. OpenX joined with the MediaMath DSP to do an experiment with Fox that provided an “aha moment” — and OpenX shifted from slow-growth to hyperspace. During his wind-down at OpenX, as Chief Revenue Officer and global expander, Jason started to become interested in Connected TV as a programmatic possibility, and by 2020 he has left OpenX to co-found tvScientific. Bill Gross was an early champion and investor, as was #PaleoAdTech friends’ Joe Zawadazki and Eric Franchi’s Aperiam Ventures . tvScientific’s mission is to make CTV as easy to buy as search and social, activating a heretofore dormant long tail of smaller advertisers outside the top 500 who dominate 85% of TV ad spend.…

Paleo Ad Tech

1
62. John Nardone – Flashtalking about Modem Media and [x+1] 31:00

2 years ago31:00

31:00

John is President at Mediaocean and former CEO of Flashtalking, which Mediaocean acquired in 2021 for a reported $500 million . He led [x+1] into Rocket Fuel and MMA before that — and his real #PaleoAdTech cred was acquired during his time at legendary Modem Media in the mid-1990s, when he was involved with the very first paid ad campaign on the internet. As John tells Marty in this raconteurial episode, his collegiate dreams of being a psychiatrist were derailed by a frat brother’s father who happened to be Bill Tragos (the T in TBWA), who delivered a rousing talk at Duke to a susceptible young Nardone. John joined Ogilvy in 1988 after business school and was there less than a year before Martin Sorrell staged a hostile takeover, freeing hundreds of employees and losing American Express as an account, feeing hundreds hundreds more. It was a crash course in the bipolarity of the ad business. John landed at P&G as a brand manager, and then Pepsi, handling the Stoli Vodka account, before being recruited to join Modem Media by its charismatic founder, G. M. O’Connell . Then a 12-person shop in an unfashionable part of Connecticut, Modem can claim to be the first digital agency, building multi-media, CD-ROM and then internet-focused campaigns for clients such as General Electric and Coors. It was Coors’ clear Zima beverage brand that brought John into the internet age, when they were one of 12 sponsors for the first-ever paid campaign on Wired magazine’s Hotwired.com. (For more on this epochal campaign, check out our Steven Comfort episode .) The cost was $15,000 for the three-month beta trial, which John says “seemed outrageous.” The AT&T ad that was also part of the campaign gained at 25% click-through-rate (likely an all-time industry high) due to its novelty, and John tells Marty the mind-numbing way these ads were measured: log files were printed out and individual “gifs” were counted, manually. The world awaited its first ad server, which was forthcoming (see our chat with Kevin O’Connor ). Did those banner ads on Hotwired.com seem revolutionary or just a gimmick? “It did [seem major],” recalls John. “G.M. was an evangelical character. After he sold Modem he went off to live in Patagonia for ten years and sort of disappeared from the industry, so people forget how incredibly charismatic and passionate he was that digital technology was going to change advertising forever.” After a stint at MMA, an analytics company, John found himself a first-time CEO at [x+1], the latest incarnation of Poindexter Systems, founded by Joe Zawadzki , who later founded Mediamath. It was 2008, and John inherited a difficult situation at a difficult time; shortly after raising money, the market turned and he was left with a single client (Delta Air Lines) and nothing to do but try to “turn lemons into lemonade,” in the words of his CTO. So the team rebuilt the tech stack and delivered a proto-DMP, capable of developing targeting insights based on first-party databases (such as Delta’s SkyMiles accounts) and using those insights for website personalization, landing-page personalization and then ad targeting. [x+1] was ready to be part of Google’s first RTB experiments in 2010. The company was acquired by Rocket Fuel in 2014 for an estimated $230 million. #PaleoAdTech has long been interested in probing the mysterious inner-space that is Rocket Fuel’s history but has so far been frustrated; and so it proved this time, as John would only say “It’s probably a story for another day. [Rocket Fuel] was not our intended destination. We had a different suitor that we thought we were selling the company to and at the last moment, quite unexpectedly, that suitor dropped out. Rocket Fuel was the only one left, and so they won the bid.” Ultimately, Rocket Fuel became part of Sizmek in 2017, and Sizmek itself filed for bankruptcy two years later. John’s next stop was Flashtalking, a dynamic-creative technology provider. Challenged by Adobe’s deprecation of the Flash format, he was forced to diversify into measurement and analytics — acquiring Encore from our friend Steve Latham in 2018 — and rich media. And as we have seen, Flashtalking became part of the Mediaocean family in 2021.…

Paleo Ad Tech

1
61. Jonah Goodhart – Colonize-ing Right Media and building a Moat 37:02

2 years ago37:02

37:02

Jonah Goodhart is a co-founder of Montauk Labs , a technology venture studio. Jonah was the CEO and co-founder of Moat ( acquired by Oracle in 2017), founding investor of Right Media ( acquired by Yahoo in 2007), and co-founder of WGI Group, an entrepreneur investment fund. Goodhart was a recipient of the Ernst & Young Entrepreneur of the Year award in 2017. Jonah was also a member of Mayor Bloomberg’s Council on Technology and Innovation. [Note: a more in-depth bio and discussion about Jonah’s intriguing career — which spans the arc of ad tech from the 1990s to today — can be found in this previous discussion with Marty , as well as of course in the episode itself.]…

Paleo Ad Tech

1
60. Katrin Ribant – giving us the data on Datorama 28:26

2 years ago28:26

28:26

Katrin was a co-founder of Datorama in 2012, and the platform was acquired by Salesforce in 2018 for a reported $800 million. Datorama built an innovative data aggregation, transformation and visualization engine that allowed digital marketers to understand campaigns holistically and in detail, and to optimize ROAS. It proved particularly attractive to large media agencies. These days she is an angel investor and CEO of the early stage startup Ask-Y, also in the data analytics space. A native of Belgium, Katrin began her advertising career around the digital planning function at Havas, first in Belgium and then in London. Her domain was digital marketing analytics, and she ended up guiding Havas Digital’s Artemis platform. Artemis came to Havas, a French holding company, via the acquisition of Hook Media, an agency founded by Don Epperson, who became global CEO of Havas Digital. As Kat describes it, Artemis was basically “what we would later call a DMP,” but aimed at measurement, not tracking. Its user data was incorporated into Havas’ Adnetik platform, an early agency buy-side platform or DSP. (Epperson later went to Simpli.fi and is now CEO of FreshBooks.) A moment of reckoning came when Google acquired Havas’ favored ad server, DoubleClick, and the team began to wonder what might happen if Mountain View restricted access to ad serving log-files. (This happened, but it took a while .) Prudently, Havas looked for viable alternatives. It first tried Atlas, then owned by Microsoft, but was not able to match Atlas’ data aggregations. Next stop was MediaMind, formerly Eyeblaster, a rich-media ad server. (MediaMind was later acquired by DG, morphed into Sizmek, acquired Rocket Fuel, was acquired by Vector PE in 2016 and filed for bankruptcy in 2019.) Havas endured a “long and involved” integration with MediaMind. During this project, Kat met two Israeli MediaMind technicians who would become her co-founders: Ran Sarig and Efi Cohen . The three bonded over the programmatic shift around 2007-08 and recognized there was an opportunity to provide some kind of data management/measurement tool for regular people aka marketers. “We felt there was a real opportunity in this,” she recalls. “And so we decided to quit our secure high-paying executive jobs and become scrappy entrepreneurs.” Datorama’s first logo – later redesigned Very quickly, the trio recognized that “the issue was ETL for non-technical users.” Media practitioners in those days had to handle multiple data sources in different formats, somehow synthesize and organize them, and provide useful reporting and optimization — all using Excel. They decided to build a tool that could relatively easily ingest and harmonize campaign-level data, then provide B.I.-like visualization and data exploration. The vision didn’t change, and “we never pivoted,” Kat says. Datorama’s first US offices near Union Square, Manhattan Funding was a challenge for three first-time founders — two Israelis, one a (then) non-US citizen in America — so angels and friends were enlisted. Early on, a large agency signed on, and thus was Datorama’s core buyer base defined: media buyers of significant scale, including the then-nascent category of trading desks. Salesforce acquired Datorama to join its Salesforce Marketing Cloud in 2018. (It is now called Salesforce Marketing Cloud Intelligence.) Katrin was invited to her first Dreamforce in 2018 to showcase the acquisition. Katrin on stage at Dreamforce 2018, shortly after the acquisition by Salesforce. Katrin left Salesforce in 2022. After some downtime, Kat came to a realization: “I realized that I do need to create and that I love data, and that was simply part of who I am. And I decided that I was going to try again.” Her new venture, Ask-Y, is “a full stack operational analytics platform.” It’s in an early stage, too early to describe in detail, but Kat is excited about its prospects. It may even have a generative AI component. Asked whether there really are not many women in ad-tech or if it’s just that #PaleoAdTech bookers are biased, Kat admits: “When we [i.e., Kat and Marty] started, it was a very much of a male-dominated area. I spent my entire career mostly being the only women in the room. So I think that really is factual.” “It is changing now,” she continues, “and that’s great. But you can’t change the past.”…

Paleo Ad Tech

1
59. Andy Atherton – optimizing Yahoo, Brand.net and AppNexus 30:08

2 years ago30:08

30:08

Andy was VP of pricing and yield management at Yahoo and helped lead a revamp and professionalization of the portal’s approach to pricing and selling ads. He brought on both Rapt (via our previous guest Tom Chavez ) and Right Media (via Brian O’Kelley ) to improve yield management and to gain access to demand on RM’s exchange. After Yahoo, Andy co-founded Brand.net, a media buying platform for upper-funnel campaigns, and was SVP and GM of Marketplaces at AppNexus. Today he is Chief Operating Officer at Solestial , a company in space tech that develops solar panels. After graduating from MIT, Andy was a management consultant and later got into the nascent digital music scene at IUMA and EMusic . And at the height of the dot-com boom on the west coast, he was President and Co-Founder of Optivo, which provided pricing optimization software for e-commerce storefronts. Optivo launched in 1999 and was a casualty of the market meltdown. In 2002, Andy brought his passion for price optimization to Yahoo, which was entering a new and more energetic era under the Hollywood player Terry Semel. Andy’s job was to help maximize the monetization of display ads on Yahoo’s properties and network, forecasting supply and demand, and revamping sales processes. His boss was the legendary Wenda Harris Millard , who had lately been at DoubleClick . “So you know, looking in the rear-view,” he recalls, “we had two years of panic selling and an inventory glut. … [Wenda] was strategic enough to look forward and say, as the market rebounds, we’re going to have … increasing sales discipline and increasing inventory constraints.” Changes included a revamped algorithm that didn’t “hammer [people] with continual ads” for maxed-out brands like Columbia House; a new (real) rate-card and price-data cleanup; and a new incentive structure for the sales team that took into account price attainment and not just total revenue. Andy brought Tom Chavez’s Rapt into Yahoo, realizing that its focus on hardware pricing optimization was beside the point; the underlying math could work for ads. “I remember vividly sitting in Tom’s office,” Andy tells Marty and Jill in this illuminating episode, “going like ten rounds with him, ‘Oh, internet media is going to be a thing, trust me. This is worth you tweaking your model a little bit, move away from hardware’….” He encountered Brian O’Kelley in a vivid scene previously recounted to loyal listeners by O’Kelley himself. Right Media’s co-founder Mike Walrath had pitched Yahoo on its optimization capabilities, but Andy needed demand and supply; O’Kelley tried again, flying across the country to meet with Andy during a work-from-home Friday in San Francisco. O’Kelley described the proto-network he was building at RM, and Andy admits “he got me excited.” In time, Right Media was acquired by Yahoo. Andy co-founded Brand.net in 2007. Its mission was to programmatize the buying and selling of digital ads for premium and upper-funnel inventory rather than remnant and class-two, which was basically all other programmatic. It required building forecasting and delivery management solutions, quality filtering and measurement of offline sales in partnership with Nielsen. The company was acquired by Valassis in 2012. Our hero’s next stop was AppNexus, in 2012, working for his old friend O’Kelley, who hired him to open a SF office for the company and work with big brands. Andy managed the Microsoft relationship and the FBX integration – back when Facebook was in the programmatic space, and was still called Facebook. He was most associated with Twixt , a buyside programmatic reserve workflow tool developed by AppNexus, and coordinated with the acquired sellside tool Yieldex . In concept similar to Brand.net, Twixt aimed to make the buying and selling of premium and direct-sold ads more automated and efficient. He describes Twixt: “So essentially you’ve got what amounts to like a Google sheet between the media planner and all the publishers. Where you’ve got this sort of integrated media plan at the line item level that connects to the ad server and actually creates the booking.” Circa 2013, Andy wrote an impassioned series of columns on programmatic reserve for AdExchanger. Unfortunately, Twixt was ultimately shuttered in 2016 after a major holding company deal fell through. The cause: a significant investment made by rival holding company WPP into AppNexus, which was seen as a potential conflict. After AppNexus, Andy applied his hard-won expertise at Healthline Media as SVP and GM. Since 2021, he has worked at Solestial, which is a company in the space tech, um, space. Why did he leave ad tech after all those years? “I wanted to do something that I believed in,” he admits, “was excited about; you know, that I would do almost if I wasn’t getting paid.” You can read about his exit from the industry and much more on his personal blog here .…

Paleo Ad Tech

1
58. Jeff Hirsch – all the -Clicks in SoCal lead to AudienceScience 29:19

2 years ago29:19

29:19

Jeff was founder and CRO of the FastClick ad network, acquired by ValueClick. He was later the CRO and then CEO at AudienceScience, which may have invented the DMP for clients WSJ and P&G. He was also CMO at SundaySky and Chief Commercial Officer at Pubmatic. Today he is a strategic advisor with Pubmatic, based in NY. Jeff spent the dawn of the internet and its frenetic aftermath in the luxe milieu of Santa Barbara, where a number of pragmatic ad tech players got their start (e.g., AdECN, Commission Junction, The Trade Desk). As he tells Marty in this fast-paced episode, his parents were entrepreneurial; his dad claims to have invented a punch-card driven dating service, which helped him meet his second wife. In 1996, Jeff wrote a business plan for a company he called AdClick – in those days, a “-Click” was required to indicate both hipness and proximity to DoubleClick, as our previous guest (and InterClick founder) Michael Katz told us . To prep, Jeff “actually printed every page you could find on the web about online advertising.” AdClick didn’t click, but Jeff was able to take the business plan into ValueClick’s original founder Brian Coryat, who signed him up to build publisher relationships. ValueClick was an ad network that sold excess (so-called “remnant”) inventory from publishers using a CPC model. CPC seemed more accountable than CPM, but it put a burden on the network to get the math right (buying CPM, paying CPC – it’s complicated). This is a formula Advertising.com later mastered. ValueClick managed to go public in early 2000, just before the crash. (DoubleClick had invested $85 million in the company for 35% stake pre-IPO, interestingly.) Using the IPO cash, ValueClick then swept up a number of affiliate and other networks including Commission Junction and ClickAgents. (It later rebranded as Conversant, was acquired by Alliance Data, and lives on within Epsilon.) Also in 2000, Jeff left ValueClick and started FastClick, another ad network. Originally a version of ValueClick that was designed to be faster (co-founded by aerospace engineers from UCSB), the dot-com meltdown required a retooling toward a CPA model. This model was even more mathematically demanding but did well during hard times; FastClick signed up Casale Media, Right Media, and others as customers. By the time of its IPO in 2005 (5 years “to the day” after ValueClick’s), FastClick said it had 9,000 third-party web sites in its network reaching 112 million unique U.S. internet users. By this time, Jeff had made his way back to ValueClick as SVP of business development and helped in the acquisition of FastClick for $214 million. In 2006, Jeff’s adventure with AudienceScience began when he was brought on as CRO, becoming CEO in 2008. AudienceScience began life as digiMine, which merged with CoRelate to become Revenue Science. CoRelate was co-founded by our previous guest Omar Tawakol as a recommendation engine for ecommerce sites such as Barnes & Noble. Publishers installed the system on their websites and gained insights into groups of visitors, or audiences, and by 2002 or so publishers such as the Wall Street Journal were moving it toward segmentation and targeting, focusing on unsold inventory. This move is its claim to being the first publisher DMP. After Jeff joined the company, it rebranded as AudienceScience and started an audience-based ad network, in time becoming one of the top 10 US networks with a true marketer-side DMP, which caught the eye of P&G. P&G was turning against media agencies’ opacity and fees, and in 2008 signed with Right Media’s exchange. But P&G had issues with RM because it was both a tech and media partner (Yahoo owned RM at this point), and there were some limitations in the RM product. Herein enters previous guest Bill Wise , a Right Media/Yahoo mainstay who introduced P&G to AudienceScience. “Yahoo didn’t really have the PMP chops to be able to support it,” Jeff recalls. “So Bill [Wise] and I talked and my goal was to get Yahoo to basically white-label us to P&G and create a contingency that would mean that Yahoo would eventually have to buy AudienceScience.” P&G’s famous Project Hawkeye started as a three-way relationship between Yahoo/Right Media, AudienceScience and P&G. AS acquired a DMP from Germany called Wunderloop in 2010. That and other moves cemented AS’s relationship with the client, who became by far their biggest source of revenue. It was a mixed blessing, as Jeff recalls. Around 2009-10 P&G shifted over to AS for technology and buying, and its ambitious Project Hawkeye aimed to build “a global system housing all of its data across all of its brands in multiple markets.” It made P&G likely the first big brand to in-house media, putting multiple regions on the same platform. AS became known as a strident in-housing advocate , and it moved out of media into the DMP technology business. However, AS wasn’t allowed to talk about P&G. It was a poorly-kept secret, but it was a commercial handicap. Then P&G’s vocal CBO Marc Pritchard started to complain frequently and publicly about the digital ad ecosystem in aggregate (aka “ crappy supply chain ”) and eventually ditched AudienceScience in 2017. “The first time that the relationship between P&G and AudienceScience was spoken about publicly was when we broke up,” Jeff recalls. AudienceScience closed up shop within a month. During Jeff’s seven years there, it went from 80 to 220 employees and gained an estimated $300 million in fees from P&G. After the AS adventure, Jeff joined SundaySky as CMO and in 2016 became CCO at Pubmatic, a leading SSP. Pubmatic IPO’d in 2020, and Jeff recently transitioned to a strategic advisory role with the company.…

Paleo Ad Tech

1
57. Mike Yavonditte – optimizing Alta Vista, Quigo and Yieldmo 32:13

2 years ago32:13

32:13

Mike Yavonditte is the CEO and co-founder of Yieldmo , an advertising platform specializing in mobile, optimization and curation. He was formerly CEO of Quigo, an innovative semantic ad network that built a formidable competitor to Google’s AdSense and was acquired by AOL in 2007 for a reported $340 million. Before that, he worked at Alta Vista and Juno, a pioneering ISP that launched a number of luminous ad tech careers at the dawn of the internet. Mike’s journey began with a “desktop news” startup, built with his first cousin Ray LaChance, which was scrutinized, rejected and then copied by Halsey Minor’s then high-flying CNET. He left that startup in late 1994, around the time of the launch of Netscape, and joined ZDNet (Ziff-Davis) and then DE Shaw, the technical publisher that incubated and ultimate spun-off Juno. Juno greeted the dawn of online advertising and simultaneously spawned multiple proto-legends, including Gokul Rajaram (later of Google’s AdSense) and David Jakubowski (later of Facebook, etc.). Juno was a free ISP that subsidized its email service with targeted ads, using demographic data. Mike’s next stop was AltaVista, at one time the leading search engine, which had both pay-per-click (ultimately outsourced to Overture, formerly GoTo.com and the inventor of PPC) and banner ads tied to keywords. Mike was on the team that signed strategic partnerships with big-money advertisers, many of them dot-coms flush with IPO and venture capital and in need of click-driven traffic to their sites. AltaVista displayed banner ads linked to keywords entered by the searcher After the crash, Mike relocated back to NYC and met with a couple of Israeli co-founders of Quigo, which they pitched to him as “the world’s best web crawler.” Impressed, he joined the four-man team as CEO and helped redirect the founders from their original strategy of selling to governments. Quigo was a legitimately advanced web crawler, capable of locating and analyzing text deep in the cryptosphere of the web. Quigo’s next move was to package semantic analysis of web pages it had crawled, using ML to identify keywords (topics) that could be associated with the page and pushed to search engines, which used the topics for indexing and SEO. The semantic analysis tech competed with Applied Semantics , acquired by Google (for AdSense); and addressing the void after the Semantics acquisition, Quigo licensed its tool to Google’s then-search competitors, including Overture and Yahoo. Ultimately, Quigo took the semantic tech back from the licensees and built its own stack to compete head-to-head with AdSense. The company was successful in signing premium publishers, including CNN, Fox News, ESPN and Time, Inc. The latter deal encouraged AOL to acquire the company in 2007, the same year it acquired TACODA ; it was folded into Advertising.com and became a part of AOL’s publisher offering. After a break from ad tech, Mike got back into it in 2012, co-founding Yieldmo to build measurement and testing tools for the then-new mobile ad formats. “Everyone was so obsessed with [mobile] programmatic,” he remembers, “but I didn’t [think] that a lot of people were going to build testing systems and measurement systems and all the things that you might have to build in order to test new types of ad formats. And so we decided that we were going to do that and ultimately merge it into the programmatic world.” Yieldmo became known for its creative mobile ad formats (which Mike points out are often patented). The best-known is probably the ‘ hyperscroller ,’ which determines where the person is on the page relative to the ad tag and the viewable window, and uses motion to capture attention, giving the viewer the illusion they are controlling animation in the ad unit. Today, Yieldmo is focused on ML/AI and analysis of its data set, aimed at the challenge of inventory curation, including matching inventory to creative and optimizing to the advertisers’ KPIs.…

Paleo Ad Tech

1
56. Tom Chavez – giving us the Rapt on Krux and data 28:11

2 years ago28:11

28:11

Tom co-founded the Data Management Platform (DMP) Krux in 2010, and it was acquired by Salesforce in 2016 and became part of its Marketing Cloud. Before Krux, Tom co-founded a company called Rapt in the late 1990s, a yield-management optimization platform that sold into supply chain providers before making a hard pivot into advertising, managing publisher inventory by applying the same mathematical principles used for supply chains. Rapt was acquired by Microsoft as part of its impressive ad tech acquisition binge in 2007-08, when it also swept up aQuantive, Ad:ECN , and more. Currently, Tom is co-founder of Super{set} , a startup studio with multiple products in its portfolio, all focused in one way or another on challenges around data management. Marquee brands under the Super{set} umbrella are clean-room tech solution Habu and privacy-management tech Ketch . As Tom tells Marty and Jill in this intriguing episode, he grew up in Albuquerque, NM as the middle child in a house “with a lot of love” and a strong bias toward academic achievement. Although Tom’s Mexican-American mom didn’t go to college, she vowed early on that she’d send all five of her kids to Harvard — and she did. Tom enjoyed a double major in computer science and philosophy, at the intersection machines and people, and like a surprising number of comp-sci types pursued an avocation for music (which persists). He ended up at Rockwell and then Sun Microsystems as a systems architect in the late 1990s, joining just after the exit of Sun’s legendary founder Jim Clark. Clark of course co-founded Netscape, the first commercial browser , in 1994. At Sun, Tom developed supply-chain optimization software, and its success at Sun and then Cisco led him to co-found Rapt in 1999. At first, Rapt focused exclusively on the same supply-chain challenges, building software to optimize — for example — configurations for hardware; there was not a pixelated banner ad in sight. But around 2003, he made contact with Yahoo at a time when Yahoo was looking for a yield management solution. “This is funny,” Tom admits, “but I had no idea what CPM stood for. Literally … So we just learned, right? That’s the game, just learn fast. We started to wrap our heads around advertising and discovered that all of the math that we had developed for the pricing of high-tech components like microprocessors could be pointed directly — and much more productively — [at advertising].” Then came a hard pivot into ad tech and a slide away from supply-chain. Yahoo became a major customer of the newly ad-tech-ified Rapt, as did AOL and Microsoft. In 2008, Microsoft lost DoubleClick to Google, failed to acquire Yahoo, and acquired Aquantive for $6 billion, along with the much smaller AdECN and Rapt . Tom worked at Microsoft for a few years on its publisher solutions, alongside the legendary Jeff Green and under Scott Howe. (For more on Microsoft’s peregrinations in the ad space, check out Marty’s oral history here.) In 2010, Tom and Vivek Vaidya co-founded Krux. (Vivek had been the first person hired at Rapt, as an engineer.) The vision was to focus on the ad world’s data layer, rather than its endpoints (publishers, content). There wasn’t yet a DMP category. Demdex was founded in 2008 and BlueKai even earlier, in 2007, but the latter didn’t add DMP functionality until a few years before its acquisition by Oracle in 2014. Krux’s go-to-market focused on data sovereignty. “We used to have stickers,” says Tom, “we put them on our laptops … and the slogan was, ‘Krux — it’s your data.'” Data belonged to the principal, not third parties or partners or others who “coast behind you and take your data.” It also emphasized segmentation on useful attributes, building out audiences at vast scale, using some early and innovative AWS techniques. Salesforce acquired Krux in 2016 for a reported $700 million, after a period of partnership. After the acquisition, Tom says, “I was sitting on my couch saying, ‘My goodness, this company building stuff sure is fun. Please, God, could there be more than one? … Can we parallelize company building? “Can we take lessons learned from the prior 20 plus years? Can we capture those lessons and bring them to bear so that when we are working with new teams, as I like to say, why make old mistakes? There are all of these new mistakes just crying out for attention?”…

Paleo Ad Tech

1
55. Ari Paparo – influencing DoubleClick, Beeswax and more 34:05

2 years ago34:05

34:05

Ari Paparo is a well-known ad tech influencer, blogger, fellow podcast host, serial entrepreneur, raconteur and man-about-town in his longtime home of Manhattan. He worked in product management at DoubleClick, AppNexus and Nielsen – and was the CEO and co-founder of Beeswax, which was acquired by Comcast’s Freewheel division in 2020 for an undisclosed amount at a time when it had raised $28 million. Ari co-founded Marketecture.tv in 2022 with our friend Zach Rodgers , Eric Seufert and Mike Shields , and he recently launched yet another company, called LaunchScience , focused on product launch workflow and content. Not surprisingly, entrepreneurship runs in Ari’s family. His father Michael was a prolific dreamer with an insatiable portfolio of new business ideas. (We recommend reading Ari’s moving profile of his dramatic dad on the occasion of his passing.) The elder Paparo holds a patent for the lubriciously-titled “Binding a previously prepared grain-based product to a support member” (Ari’s paraphrase: “French toast on a stick”) … and another one for “Golf shoe insoles for improving the golf swing” (each insole is different, of course). The younger Paparo’s NYC childhood was “not chaotic,” he insists, “but there were fat times and there were lean times.” Intriguingly, Paparo’s friend and longtime Manhattan-based ad tech co-conspirator Joe Zawadzki , founder of MediaMath, told #PaleoAdTech that he had a similarly quixotic, idea-machine dad. After enjoying a Georgetown liberal arts and marketing education, with a minor in oil painting, Ari worked at a couple of pre-internet startups before landing at Blink.com, an online bookmarking service. While bookmarking enjoyed a brief vogue in the ‘90s and Blink.com managed to raise at least $10 million during the dot-com days, it ultimately liquidated itself to the Vendare Group in 2002. Ari later re-acquired part of it as a profitable side-hustle. Then Ari landed at DoubleClick, which was enduring some difficult turn-around years. (For more on this, we recommend two ‘oral histories’ of DoubleClick, one in print and another actually oral: Marty’s 2018 piece for AdExchanger , which quotes Ari; and Ari’s own recent podcast for Marketecture.tv , which accesses usually inaccessible sources within the Googleplex, and more.) But when Ari joined, in 2004, co-founder Kevin O’Connor had left and the company was “at its nadir.” What followed was “a masterful management job,” led by new CEO David Rosenblatt , who pared down a “sprawling” product portfolio, divesting non-ad related businesses like email and search; reorganized the engineering team along agile lines; and energized a spiritually depleted post-crash culture. Ari focused on rich media product management, and he continued on at Google after the search monolith acquired DoubleClick in 2008. At Google, Ari admits, he was a non-engineer in a cult of engineers. Fit was suboptimal. Yet there began another stage of Ari’s career – this time, as an influencer – when Business Insider, then pathologically obsessed with Google, ran a story called “ Who’s Who at Google New York ,” by Nicholas Carlson (who later wrote a very good book about Marissa Mayer and Yahoo ). The BI story provided oddly detailed resumes of random Googlers, including a squib about Ari alongside this picture: The Gossip: Liked, but ‘lower level,’ Ari is one of many DoubleClick executives who others say don’t get enough respect from Mountain View. Business Insider The phrase “lower level” did not sit well with our hero. (He was Group Product Manager, a fairly senior role at Google, and had been a VP at DoubleClick.) So he marched down to Starbucks, where BI was camped out live-blogging, and confronted the scribes. BI promptly became pathologically obsessed with Ari Paparo, elevating him to the ranks of Top Follows on Twitter, and Ari’s career as a prolific, clever, widely-followed tweeter began. The real @aripap is currently at almost 24K followers on Twitter. Ari was adept at writing popular columns for the industry’s preferred trade publication, AdExchanger. As an insider with an outsiders’ skeptical gaze, Ari was quick to identify in plain-spoken, deft prose what we did and didn’t really know about hot topics, including the “ Programmatic Waterfall Mystery ” (featuring header bidding when nobody knew what that was) … and, famously, the “death” of the cookie, channeling Charlton Heston (“ Google, You Finally Really Did It! ”). The latter was written so fast that some of us suspected supernatural intervention. However, Ari explains that he “writes a greater amount of content, at scale, than just about anyone I’ve ever met.” A production machine. That industrious streak thrived during lockdown, when he YouTubed things like a poolside chat on the future of advertising and hosted a number of Beeswax webinars that were actually informative. Our personal favorite was “ Les cas d’utilisation de la Log Data ,” en francaise avec une phrase en anglais. (Ari n’apparait pas dans celui-ci.) From 2014-2020, Ari ran the buy-side platform Beeswax, which he founded. The idea for the company came to Ari when he worked at AppNexus, co-founded by esteemed #PaleoAdTech friend Brian O’Kelley . Ari says he was “a big supporter” of AppNexus’ vision of being a customizable platform for ad tech, but he felt the product could be more flexible – and cheaper. So he launched Beeswax as a bidder-as-a-service(tm), providing separate, highly customizable SaaS software for a subscription price starting around $10K per month. The highly flexible Beeswax team – Ari is standing, second from right. The product did well among ad networks, who preferred it to the more established IPONWeb, run by the Godfather of Ad Tech, aka Dr. Boris , discovered in his Right Media days by O’Kelley. Selling Beeswax to brands direct proved more difficult, as they favored plug-and-play over micro-tuning and didn’t have the elite athletic requirements of the networks. Comcast’s Freewheel video-focused division acquired Beeswax in 2020. Although Beeswax didn’t set out to be a video DSP, a growing portion of its traffic took that form, and many of its ad network customers dealt in video. Also – as Ari explains to Marty (Jill is off this week) in this fascinating ride – Freewheel historically avoided programmatic technology because its TV customers didn’t want or need it (yet). After a year at Comcast, Ari finally combined his content-creation and company-founding impulses into Marketecture.tv . The purpose of the venture is to produce video, audio and written content, including interviews with CEOs and founders, focused on particular (mostly ad- and mar-) tech products “to help buyers evaluate tech vendors minus the B.S.” It’s a freemium subscription product. At the same time, the indefatigable amateur baker recently unleashed the private beta of LaunchScience. The product helps product management teams organize their workflows and launches and is based on Ari’s workplace experience with Google’s so-called “readiness” launch process. If you’d like to be in the beta, you can get on the list . What’s next for our guest? Perhaps a better question is: What isn’t?…

Paleo Ad Tech

1
54. Lee Nadler – marketing DoubleClick in Silicon Alley 33:49

2 years ago33:49

33:49

Lee was the first head of marketing at DoubleClick, hired by co-founder Kevin O’Connor in 1996 as employee #17 with a mandate to help the other 16 people meet Kevin’s vision-quest to “dominate internet advertising.” The startup had been clicked-off barely two years earlier in the basement of O’Connor’s home in suburban Alpharetta, Georgia. These days, Lee is a fractional CMO, executive guide and founder of the Sherpa Marketing agency, based in New York. He’s also an ad industry influencer, entwined with the Advertising Club for years, inducted into the AAF Hall of Achievement and named by Ad Age as one of 21 people to watch in the 21st century. Lee started his career on the account side of New York ad shops, beginning at a small agency in New Jersey that handled the Prodigy account. A joint venture between IBM and Sears, Prodigy was a proto-walled garden and ISP that was able to do some basic banner ad targeting for subscribers. Next stop was KBS&P, where Lee worked on the legendary Snapple account. “That showed me the power of building a movement,” he tells Jill and Marty in this thoughtful episode. Lee’s entree into DoubleClick was via a connection at the Ad Club, where he was then a “young pro.” At the time, highly-respected print publishing exec Wenda Harris Millard was a member of the board and was hired by Kevin O’Connor to help legitimize DoubleClick’s proposition to publishers and media buyers in NYC. Millard was DoubleClick employee #16 and she recommended Lee as the start-up’s first professional marketing lead. Lee recalls the extreme skepticism, even disrespect, that greeted his move into digital, particularly among some high-caste agency creatives. “You can’t always get validation,” he recalls. “Sometimes you have to kind of put yourself out there … for what you believe.” When he joined, Lee met a furiously-growing ad network and server with a charismatic co-founder and a lot of new ideas — but no real marketing discipline. Quickly, Lee got to work on a positioning statement, a brand identity, and a flurry of brilliant guerilla-style tactics that were rapidly noticeable even to New Yorkers who didn’t work in media. Early logos and treatments took full advantage of the click-click DoubleClick gimmick: The best-known click-click placement was a sign Lee put up by the Flatiron Building at 22nd Street and Broadway in Manhattan that read: “DOUBLECLICK WELCOMES YOU TO SILICON ALLEY.” Despite some gentle skepticism — this time, from his bosses, “the Kevins” O’Connor and Ryan — the sign showed immediate impact and stayed up for five years. (The spot is now taken by Apple.) Other tactics included providing umbrellas outside agencies during rainy days; dragging banners behind planes over the Hamptons with a sign saying Turn over, DoubleClick is watching your ad campaign ; rewarding people at industry events who remembered to click-click their glasses in a particular way … and so on. As the company grew from 20 to over 1,000 employees in a few years, Lee tried to clarify and preserve the culture. He printed up a mission statement on the back of everyone’s business card: Building one-to-one relationships millions at a time DoubleClick business card And he put together a booklet that summed up the culture of the “Clicker,” or DoubleClick employee. Here are some excerpts: Most notable was a crisp set of definitions to guide new recruits and those in need of recalibration. Herein — for those who wonder — are the tenets of those who are “Clickers” and those other types: “We weren’t just a bunch of lunatics kind of running around,” Lee says. “There was a purpose, which was, have fun, work hard and also create a movement.” In 1998, Lee himself moved from marketing to NYC marketers to helping to build out the international expansion of the company, starting in Japan. He recalls being in Australia when the IPO occurred, and he “took a pause … and went to Nepal for the first time.” So began another phase of the ad-man’s career, as he’s exposed to the Tibetan Sherpa people and “very taken by the whole culture.” Impressed by the native resilience and grounded optimism of the Sherpas, Lee had a jarring return to dot-com reality at the Biltmore in Arizona for the DoubleClick salesforce conference and IPO celebration. Early DoubleClickers convening at the Biltmore in Arizona circa 1998 “In Nepal, in the villages, the kids were saying, ‘Namaste, do you have a pencil?’ And I came back to the Biltmore and the internet sales guys were pounding their fists on the table … saying, ‘Why is the fucking internet so slow?!’ And I was, like, wow, this is the same planet.” Lee left DoubleClick in 1999, but he didn’t go far. Co-founding an agency called Digital Pulp (which still exists, sans the original founders), he continued to market for DoubleClick and help some of its customers build plans and digital assets. He went on to manage marketing, new product launches and a start-up accelerator for MINI/BMW Group. And he stays in touch with the Sherpas, after whom he named his agency Sherpa Marketing and his blog called the TheSherpa Path . Looking back on his time at DoubleClick — when it arguably reinvented advertising for the digital age — Lee remains positive: “For me, DoubleClick allowed me to be at my best. I think it pushed a lot of other people to be at their best at a pretty early age in their career. … There was an ability to try new things without fear. And we were there, creating something very special. And we knew it.”…

Paleo Ad Tech

1
53. Omar Tawakol – from BlueKai to AI and the all-new Rembrand 39:09

2 years ago39:09