Yankees-Red Sox 2004 ALCS Game 3 with Liam Kerr - Remember That Game

Rotoviz Radio

Liam Kerr (The Welcome Party) joins host Thomas Emerick for some early-aughts Boston angst — and rebirth. It’s October 2004. The Red Sox are down 0-2 in the ALCS. Game 3 at Fenway turns into a historic beating—and somehow, the start of everything. We talk baseball, politics, and comebacks from the edge.

2004 ALCS Game 3 Final Score: New York Yankees 19, Boston Red Sox 8

• NYY takes 3-0 series lead in American League Championship Series
• BOS now needs to win four straight to reach the World Series
• Game stats via Pro Baseball Reference

Episode threads:

• How the weight of Red Sox history—from Ruth to Buckner to Boone—hung over every fan in 2004.
• The 2004 ALCS offseason shakeups: Nomar out, A-Rod almost in, and what that meant.
• The Varitek vs. A-Rod brawl and how it defined the season’s edge and rivalry tone.
• Boston’s midseason slump and rebound: 55% playoff odds at one point, 64% the rest of the way.
• Game 3 unravels fast—Yankees drop 19 runs behind A-Rod, Sheffield, Matsui, and Bernie Williams.
• Coping mechanisms as Sox fans watched one of the worst home losses in franchise history.
• Where Liam watched Game 3, and how that night felt personally and politically.
• Parallels between Red Sox down 3-0 and Democrats down three branches of government.
• What Boston’s "Idiots" mentality says about staying loose under pressure—"Don’t let us win tonight."
• Kevin Millar’s walk, Dave Roberts’ steal, Bill Mueller’s hit—the spark of the comeback.
• How Theo Epstein and Billy Beane saw value in overlooked talent like Millar.
• The Red Sox win two Ortiz walk-offs in one calendar day—belief starts to return.

HOST

RotoViz contributor Thomas Emerick

Guest

The Welcome Party co-founder Liam Kerr (@LiamKerr)

SPONSORS

BetterHelp - This episode is brought to you by BetterHelp. Give online therapy a try at betterhelp.com/ROTOVIZ and get on your way to being your best self.

Underdog Fantasy – Get a 100% deposit match on your first deposit up to $100 when you sign up at Underdogfantasy.com using this link or the promo code ROTOVIZ.

Listeners of RotoViz Radio can save 10% on a one-year RotoViz subscription by visiting RotoViz.com/podcast or by using the promotional code "rvradio2025" at the time of purchase.

SHOW NOTES

RotoViz Radio provides the power for Remember That Game: Subscribe to the RotoViz Radio on YouTube

Direct message: Bluesky @ThomasEmerick | Twitter @ThomasEmerick

Email: [email protected]

Follow: Apple and Spotify

Subscribe: Remember That Game on YouTube