Guest: Bryce Whitlow (The Hall of Pretty Good) | @MLBHallofGood, Underrated Legends, & Baseball's Most Random Memories | 87

Tablesetters: A Baseball Podcast

Welcome to Episode 87 of Tablesetters! Today we’re joined by Bryce Whitlow, the creator of the wildly popular Instagram account @mlbhallofgood, a page dedicated to honoring baseball’s most criminally underrated legends. With sharp humor, heartfelt nostalgia, and a deep love for the game, Bryce has built a digital shrine to the players who may not be in Cooperstown, but who will always have a place in fans’ memories.

We dive into how the Hall of (Pretty) Good came to life, who qualifies for induction, and why the page has resonated so strongly with baseball fans across generations. Bryce shares stories of players reacting to their surprise enshrinement, talks about his first pitch with the Portland Sea Dogs, and updates us on the growing movement to buy the Pittsburgh Pirates.

We also get into current MLB storylines:
– Who’s the real World Series favorite right now (besides the Dodgers)?
– Which young stars would Bryce build around today?
– Which current players are quietly building their case for the Hall of Pretty Good?

Plus:
• Blind Rankings of 2010–2015 position players
• A “Did They Really Play There?” journeyman challenge
• Lightning Round: Name as many Edwin Jackson teams as possible in 60 seconds
• And yes… we tried to get an early scoop on this Thursday’s inductee.

This one’s full of laughs, nostalgia, and a genuine love for the guys who made baseball feel personal — even if they didn’t make the Hall of Fame.

Follow us on Instagram and X @TablesettersPod for bonus content, updates, and more. Subscribe and join us each week — Tablesetters is where stories shape the season.