Honoring the Human Touch in a World of AI Photography with Shane Balkowitsch

The Beginner Photography Podcast

#581 Shane Balkowitsch is a dedicated wet plate collodion photographer whose passion for history, authenticity, and the human experience shapes both his artwork and his views on the future of photography. In this episode, Shane shares the journey that led him from having no experience with a camera to mastering one of photography’s oldest analog processes—a craft involving silver on glass that dates back to 1851. He highlights how the permanence and tangible nature of wet plate images, created through capturing real light and human presence, starkly contrast with the ephemeral, intangible nature of digital and AI-generated images.

KEY TOPICS COVERED

1. Defining Photography in the Age of AI - Shane and Raymond dissect the core of what makes an image a "photograph," highlighting the necessity of light, a subject, and a photosensitive medium or sensor. They underscore the risk of confusing AI-based image generation—which lacks these elements—with authentic photography, causing potential chaos in art, media, and historical documentation.
2. Ethics, Ownership, and Historical Accuracy - Shane raises significant ethical concerns about AI training on billions of images without permission, including his own work, and questions who owns the resulting visuals. He warns about the dangers this presents to historical accuracy, imagining future scenarios where AI-generated portraits of people who never existed could mislead researchers or the public, blurring the line between fact and fiction.
3. Terminology, Transparency, and the Future of Art - Shane advocates for distinct labeling of AI-generated imagery—suggesting terms like "promptography"—to prevent confusion and uphold the integrity of photography. He stresses the need for transparency so viewers know whether an image is a genuine photograph or an AI creation, believing that honesty and accurate terminology are essential as technology continues to evolve.

IMPORTANT DEFINITIONS & CONCEPTS

• Wet Plate Collodion Photography: An early analog photographic process invented in 1851, involving capturing images on glass plates coated with chemicals sensitive to light. Shane’s work in this medium exemplifies photography’s physical, archival, and intentional qualities.

IMPORTANT DEFINITIONS & CONCEPTS

1. What makes an image a photograph, and why does this distinction matter when considering AI-generated content?
2. Should AI-generated images be considered art? If so, who holds the authorship—the prompt user or the AI?
3. How might the widespread adoption of AI imagery change the way we perceive, document, or trust history?

RESOURCES:
Visit Shane Balkowitsch's Website - https://nostalgicglasswetplatestudio.zenfolio.com/
Follow Shane Balkowitsch on Instagram - https://www.instagram.com/balkowitsch/

Sign up for your free CloudSpot Account today at www.DeliverPhotos.com

Connect with Raymond!

• Join the free Beginner Photography Podcast Community at https://beginnerphotopod.com/group
• Get your Photo Questions Answered on the show - https://beginnerphotopod.com/qa
• Grab your free camera setting cheatsheet - https://perfectcamerasettings.com/

Thanks for listening & keep shooting!