Go offline with the Player FM app!
Podcasts Worth a Listen
SPONSORED


1 How AI is saving billions of years of human research time | Max Jaderberg 19:15
How to master internal board evaluations that generate real insights for Directors | Chloe Barry, Company Secretary Kingfisher
Manage episode 431765949 series 2846777
Corporate Governance Codes worldwide state that an internal board evaluation shall be conducted in years one and two after a fully facilitated external evaluation. It is one of those tasks on a Company Secretariat's calendar that has to be done. But how?
In this podcast, Dr Sabine Dembkowski, Founder and Managing Partner of Better Boards, discusses mastering internal board evaluation with Chloe Barry. Chloe is Group Company Secretary at Kingfisher, an FTSE100 organisation.
“I'm fortunate to have moved from one engaged chair to another”
Chloe starts by explaining her board evaluation process, with the next one planned for the autumn, which will be conducted internally. She outlined how this is notable for two reasons: it is the first led by the new board chair. Chloe is excited to work with them on what she is certain is a robust process. Secondly, they will use most of last year's question set, allowing them to measure progress.
“We want the directors to leave the process feeling assured that they have identified the appropriate actions”
Chloe admits that board evaluations can be seen as unnecessary and time-consuming. However, her experience with engaged boards and directors shows that they often appreciate the outcome. Despite the time it takes, directors recognise that meaningful participation enhances the quality of subsequent reporting and discussions, and by engaging honestly and sharing views on potential obstacles, board effectiveness can significantly improve. In her opinion, a good evaluation process is measured by the practical actions it identifies for improvement.
“Perhaps counterintuitively, my starting point is always to look back and reflect on the previous few years' reviews”
To prepare for an internal evaluation, Chloe explains that she starts by reflecting on past reviews, considering the format, tone, actions set in the previous years, and feedback from directors. This helps her decide on the type of review to propose, whether internal or external and if it aligns with their three-year cycle. If changing the mechanism or provider, she will always create a shortlist, benchmark with peers, and possibly conduct a full tender. She explains that while board evaluations, particularly internal ones, can take almost any form – verbal, paper or online - the most important thing is to ensure that you are evolving and improving in all respects.
“You need to be honest with your chair”
Chloe emphasises that honesty with your chair about past successes and areas for improvement is essential when making proposals. She relates that she introduced Better Boards for their interim evaluation last year to focus on peer reviews. Considerations included various factors such as the new platform, question set, reporting format, timetable, and communication plan. The most positive feedback from last year's review was about the display of the results and the insightful peer review section.
The three top takeaways from our conversation are:
1. Learn from past evaluations by reviewing agreed actions, feedback, and the process. Show directors you are improving the experience to maintain their eng
Remember to subscribe and never miss an episode of the Better Boards Podcast Series. It’s available on Apple, Spotify, or Google.
To find out how you can participate in the Better Boards Podcast Series or for more information on Better Boards’ solutions, please email us at info@better-boards.com.
139 episodes
Manage episode 431765949 series 2846777
Corporate Governance Codes worldwide state that an internal board evaluation shall be conducted in years one and two after a fully facilitated external evaluation. It is one of those tasks on a Company Secretariat's calendar that has to be done. But how?
In this podcast, Dr Sabine Dembkowski, Founder and Managing Partner of Better Boards, discusses mastering internal board evaluation with Chloe Barry. Chloe is Group Company Secretary at Kingfisher, an FTSE100 organisation.
“I'm fortunate to have moved from one engaged chair to another”
Chloe starts by explaining her board evaluation process, with the next one planned for the autumn, which will be conducted internally. She outlined how this is notable for two reasons: it is the first led by the new board chair. Chloe is excited to work with them on what she is certain is a robust process. Secondly, they will use most of last year's question set, allowing them to measure progress.
“We want the directors to leave the process feeling assured that they have identified the appropriate actions”
Chloe admits that board evaluations can be seen as unnecessary and time-consuming. However, her experience with engaged boards and directors shows that they often appreciate the outcome. Despite the time it takes, directors recognise that meaningful participation enhances the quality of subsequent reporting and discussions, and by engaging honestly and sharing views on potential obstacles, board effectiveness can significantly improve. In her opinion, a good evaluation process is measured by the practical actions it identifies for improvement.
“Perhaps counterintuitively, my starting point is always to look back and reflect on the previous few years' reviews”
To prepare for an internal evaluation, Chloe explains that she starts by reflecting on past reviews, considering the format, tone, actions set in the previous years, and feedback from directors. This helps her decide on the type of review to propose, whether internal or external and if it aligns with their three-year cycle. If changing the mechanism or provider, she will always create a shortlist, benchmark with peers, and possibly conduct a full tender. She explains that while board evaluations, particularly internal ones, can take almost any form – verbal, paper or online - the most important thing is to ensure that you are evolving and improving in all respects.
“You need to be honest with your chair”
Chloe emphasises that honesty with your chair about past successes and areas for improvement is essential when making proposals. She relates that she introduced Better Boards for their interim evaluation last year to focus on peer reviews. Considerations included various factors such as the new platform, question set, reporting format, timetable, and communication plan. The most positive feedback from last year's review was about the display of the results and the insightful peer review section.
The three top takeaways from our conversation are:
1. Learn from past evaluations by reviewing agreed actions, feedback, and the process. Show directors you are improving the experience to maintain their eng
Remember to subscribe and never miss an episode of the Better Boards Podcast Series. It’s available on Apple, Spotify, or Google.
To find out how you can participate in the Better Boards Podcast Series or for more information on Better Boards’ solutions, please email us at info@better-boards.com.
139 episodes
All episodes
×
1 The Role of the Board in Owner-led Organisations 19:35

1 Overcoming misconceptions and lies in the boardroom 19:38

1 10x Your Impact – How the Smartest Directors Are Using AI 21:17

1 Beyond Minutes: Reimagining the Board Secretary in the Age of AI 21:25


1 Boards - What do capital markets think of them? The unfiltered perspective of a credit analyst 19:02

1 Living with Uncertainty: The Importance of Transformation, Culture, and Talent 20:00

1 Future proofing the board with AI | Moya Hayhurst, Company Secretary 18:33

1 Cutting past the noise on the climate/energy transition | David Harris, Sustainable Finance Strategic Initiatives, London Stock Exchange Group 21:37

1 Employee representation on the board | Gabriele Bornemann, CEO Management Alliance 11:20

1 The Boardroom Tango: Where strategy meets execution | Carol Ouko-Misiko, Executive & NED 18:35

1 Navigating Misjudgement: A Practical Framework for Better Board Performance | Nuala G Walsh, CEO & NED 25:49

1 Selling Bold Ideas in the Boardroom | Dr Andy Palmer, CEO 25:20

1 How to lead through complexity | Dr Nadine Rinck, Partner, Egon Zehnder 16:50

1 Crisis & the Board: How to prepare for “Anything" | Barbara Lambert, Chair Audit, Risk and Nomination Committees 24:00

1 The Boardroom Awakening: Can Corporate Governance Survive the Sustainability Reckoning? | Frederik Otto, Director of Advisory and Head of Europe, AccountAbility 23:21

1 On the crucial relationship between the Chair and the CEO | Sir David Norgrove, Chair 21:12

1 Being on the Board – Keeping it Simple | Sir John Tusa 23:39

1 The Joy Of Working On Boards In Five Continents | Christof Kutscher, Chair & CEO 24:03

1 Tech Boards – What matters to investors | Irene Arias Hofman, CEO, IDB Lab 17:00

1 Insights into the German Corporate Governance Debate - learnings, changes and implications for Directors | Dr Cordula Heldt, Head of Corporate Governance and Company Law at the German Share… 17:46

1 Is Diversity, Equity and Inclusion bad for business? | Prof Grace Lordan, London School of Economics 20:04

1 How to master internal board evaluations that generate real insights for Directors | Chloe Barry, Company Secretary Kingfisher 14:54

1 How to get creativity and innovation into the boardroom | Sir John Tusa 21:39

1 AI and Advanced Analytics – delivering value for directors and the board | Prof Bernardo Almada-Lobo, University of Porto & LTPlabs 19:42

1 The death of the ESG Committee | Vicky Moffatt, CEO Chapter Zero 23:08

1 Mastering the Company Secretariat | Jason Wright, Society Secretary Nationwide 20:58

1 A balancing act: where should EMEIA boards focus for long-term success? | Andrew Hobbs, Partner EY 17:16

1 Increasing productivity through inclusion | Belton Flournoy, Managing Director, Technology Consulting practice Protiviti 25:16

1 Experience of working with a board as a first-time CEO | Daphne Mavroudi-Chocholi, Managing Director RNIB Enterprises 21:21

1 How can boards convert sustainability from a wish to a winning reality? | Andrew Hobbs, Partner EY 16:03

1 U.S. and U.K. – Two countries separated by common corporate governance practices? | Susan Skeritt, Non-Executive Director 20:43

1 What do board members need to think about to avoid being sued by the climate movement? | Donald Pols, Director Friends of the Earth, Netherlands 18:29

1 Behind close doors of tech start-up Boards | Yael Banjamin, CEO Snapshot and Zack Weisfeld, Vice President & General Manager Intel Ignite 25:47

1 Can accounting save the world and your company? | Mike Mahoney, CEO E-liability Institute 17:45

1 AI - What questions do Directors need to ask? | Prof Joe Fuller, Harvard Business School 22:14

1 Leading an effective board | Andreas E.F. Utermann, Executive Chair Vontobel Holding AG 20:39

1 Why a good story is mission critical for boards | Jyoti Gupta, Story teller and award winning author 17:52

1 Executive Pay - Striking the right balance between Executives and stakeholders | Paul Norris, Senior Partner MM&K Limited 17:05

1 The inspiring life of a Director | Paul Halpin, Non-Executive Director 19:49

1 On being an effective Non-Executive Director | Marianne Loner, Non-Executive Director 19:48

1 The Board as a Team | Petri Hofste, Non-Executive Director 18:46

1 The Retention Factor: Why Boards Need to Prioritize LGBT+ Inclusion | Emma Codd, Global Chief Diversity, Equity and Inclusion Officer Deloitte 26:29

1 Governance - Are boards part of the problem or part of the solution? | Ralph Ward, Editor, The Corporate Board 22:16

1 On making it in the boardroom | Imran Saleem, Partner, Egon Zehnder 16:19

1 Building a Successful Employee Engagement Process | Louise Hardy, NED and Kevin Maguire General Counsel & Company Secretary, Crest Nicholson 17:29

1 Managing Governance Risks | Liz Lynkswiler, Company Secretary, Brightwell Pensions 18:51

1 Gender equality in the workplace starts at the top | Emma Codd, Global Chief Diversity, Equity, and Inclusion Officer, Deloitte 27:09


1 How do boards preside wisely over transactions to avoid shareholder value destruction? | Dr Dean Blomson 18:27

1 The role of the next generation in family-owned enterprises | Martin Roll 13:50

1 On being an effective Director in family-owned enterprises | Martin Roll 15:37

1 The role of boards in family-owned enterprises | Martin Roll 14:17

1 Governance challenges in Africa | Tinuade Awe, CEO of NGX Regulation, a subsidiary of Nigerian Exchange Group Plc 32:07

1 On building inclusive and equitable cultures in the boardroom and throughout the organisation | Dr Doyin Atewologun, Director Delta Alpha Psi 28:10

1 The essence of good governance | Dr Peter Crow 19:39

1 Governance - Wicked challenges in healthcare | Nabil Jamshed, Head of Corporate Governance at Guy's and St Thomas' NHS Foundation Trust for the Integrated Specialist Medicine Clinical Group 28:51

1 The power of trust – How can boards build it, lose it, and regain it | Prof Sandra Sucher, Harvard Business School 19:57

1 On increasing the quality of the dialogue in the boardroom | Prof David Clutterbuck 22:40

1 Diversity & Inclusion – The Board's role as 'agents of change' | Prof Randall Peterson, London Business School 20:44

1 Boards under pressure | Sir John Tusa, Chair 16:56

1 Boards - Geopolitical challenges & Diversity | Nassib Abou Kahlil, Top Corporate Legal Officer 20:01

1 On creating a digitally savvy board | Peter Weill, Senior Research Scientist MIT Sloan School of Management and Chair Emeritius MIT Center for Information Systems Research 19:07

1 Future-proofing your board | Didier Cossin, Professor IMD Switzerland 23:44

1 Is your board adapting to a dynamically changing risk environment? | Zahra Cassim, CEO CSIA and David Samy, Consulting Partner EY Hong Kong 21:49

1 Rethinking talent in the boardroom | Joe Fuller, Professor Harvard Business School 29:22

1 Establishing a global mindset in the boardroom | Thomas Kipp, CEO Naquel Express 19:51

1 CEO Readiness | Dr Wayne Nelson, Senior Partner at Deloitte Consulting and Strategy Consulting Leader EMEA at Monitor Deloitte. Head and Founding Dean of the Deloitte Executive Leadership Institute. 12:26

1 The role of the board in defining the purpose of the organisation | Gill Meller, Legal & Governance Director MTR Corporation 20:42

1 The environment in the boardroom: On overcoming obstacles | Susan Hooper, Chair & Non-Executive Director 20:42

1 Digital know-how in the boardroom | Hasan el Bouhali, Board Advisor, Mentor & Angel Investor 16:58

1 The board as an agent of change | Denis Woulfe, Co-Chair of Leaders as Change Agents 14:45

1 From Executive to "Professional NED" | Ian Murray, Chair or various mining companies 13:37

1 Generation Z in the boardroom | Hana Ben-Shabat, Gen Z Planet 14:44

1 Why should boards care about supply chains? | Anahita Thoms, Baker McKenzie 18:13

1 Chairing the board of a Growth Business | Peter Herbert, Chair Zopa Bank and Bank of Ireland 21:16

1 The status of ethnic diversity on FTSE boards | David Tyler, Chair The Parker Review 17:16

1 Board Evaluations - What does good really look like? Part II | Maureen Beresford, Financial Reporting Council 14:15

1 Board Evaluations - what does good really look like? Part I | Maureen Beresford, Financial Reporting Council 12:01

1 Creating A Sustainability-Savvy Board | Trista Bridges, Read the Air 20:45

1 Spreading good governance practice around the globe | Bode Ayeku, Corporate Secretaries International Association 18:50

1 Proactive Questions every board member should be asking | Dr Andrew White, SAID Business School 19:29

1 ESG - What should boards focus on | Anna-Marie Slot, Partner, Ashurst LLP 18:28

1 The changing role of CEOs and their relationship with their boards | Dr Kati Najipoor-Smith, Co-Leader Global CEO Practice, Egon Zehnder 17:24

1 The role of the board in the age of digital transformation | Lisa Harrington, Non-Executive Director Post Office UK and Digital 9 Infrastructure Plc 11:00

1 Diversity & Inclusion - See differently | David Clarke, Royal National Institute of Blind People (RNIB) 20:23

1 The digitisation of the board | Maddie Scrafton, Computershare Governance Services 17:21

1 Responding to the ESG agenda – legal insights for boards | Anna-Marie Slot, Will Chalk, Partners, Ashurst LLP 17:55

1 Integrating different perspectives in the boardroom | Sir John Tusa, Chair British Architecture Trust, Former MD BBC World Service and Barbican Arts Centre 17:12

1 Transitioning from CEO to Chair | Steve Holliday, Chair Citifibre and Zenobe, President of the Energy Institute, Former CEO at National Grid 21:00

1 Changing the racial diversity on FTSE boards | Richard DeNetto, Associate Director CBI 15:45

1 Creating a high-performance culture in the boardroom | Ralph Schubert, Senior Partner, Coverdale Team Management 16:54

1 Going beyond governance – The art of talking about what really matters | Jim Haudan, Co-founder and CEO of Root Inc now part of Accenture 12:50

1 The Alignment of Executives and Non-Executives in the Boardroom | Ken Schuetz, CEO and Founder of Aligned Influence Consulting 18:05

1 Hybrid working and controls – What should boards think about? | John Mongelard, Technical Manager - Risk & Regulation at ICAEW 17:05

1 Culture, it all starts in the boardroom | Mike Gahir, Chair of the Board of Trustee at Steps to Work 17:16

1 Putting the 'S' in ESG | Margot Slattery, Global Head of Diversity and Inclusion, ISS A/S 17:09

1 The role of the Company Secretary in major transactions | Nickesha Graham-Burrell, Head of Company Secretariat, OSB Group PLC 13:33

1 The role of the Company Secretary in increasing the effectiveness of Non-Executive Directors | John Mills, Company Secretary, Smiths Group PLC 14:12

1 Board Reporting - The indispensable part of effective boards | David Whincup, Deputy Company Secretary, Provident Financial Group 16:56

1 The role of the Company Secretary in creating future-fit boards | Loren Wulfsohn, Global Head of Policy and Stakeholder Engagement, HSBC Holdings PLC 15:03

1 Diversity & Inclusion - Insights from the U.K. and Mercedes-Benz AG | Sabine Kohleisen, Member of the Board of Management at Mercedes-Benz AG, and Denise Wilson | CEO, Hampton-Alexander Review 17:42

1 Punks in the boardroom | Christopher Pirnie, Principal at Kuberno Consulting. Former Director of Governance Operations and Policy, Fidelity International 12:07

1 The relationship between the Chair and the CEO - How can you make it work? | Sir John Tusa, Chair British Architecture Trust, Former MD BBC World Service and Barbican Arts Centre 17:31

1 Building a culture of challenge | Professor Karthik Ramanna, Professor of Business & Public Policy at Blavatnik School of Government, Oxford University 23:28
Welcome to Player FM!
Player FM is scanning the web for high-quality podcasts for you to enjoy right now. It's the best podcast app and works on Android, iPhone, and the web. Signup to sync subscriptions across devices.