28. Trans Women vs. Biological Women in Sports: Examining the Science of the Competitive Imbalance w/ Dr. Alexander Hutchison

The Far Side of Fitness

In this thought-provoking episode, Dr. Darian Parker speaks with Dr. Alexander Hutchison, author of An Unfair Advantage: In Sports the Body Matters, to explore one of the most contentious debates in modern athletics: the participation of trans women in women’s sports. The conversation dives deep into the biological differences between men and women, the role of hormone replacement therapy, and the science behind physical performance disparities.

Alexander shares why he begins his book with an inclusive and empathetic tone, aiming to disarm and engage readers in a meaningful dialogue. Together, they unpack why biological women face significant disadvantages when competing against trans women, and why the creation of separate competitive divisions could protect fairness while still promoting dignity and inclusion.

This episode also addresses the emotional, political, and cultural weight of the issue, highlighting the importance of open, respectful, and science-based discussions in finding common ground.

Alexander's Links:

The Unfair Advantage: https://www.amazon.com/Unfair-Advantage-Sports-Body-Matters/dp/B0F389446G

Dr. D's Links:

Website: https://doctordarianparker.com/

Affiliates:

Stick Mobility - Get your flexibility back and prevent injuries with Stick Mobility. Training Sticks improve range of motion, muscle activation, coordination, and body awareness to build a strong foundation for better movement. Go to this Link
or copy to your browser https://stickmobility.com/darian-parker and use the discount code: 1CEC828F154 to get 10% off of your purchase.

Time Stamps:

00:58 Personal Background and Cultural Experiences

02:32 Meeting Adrian Shepherd

03:05 Trans Women in Sports

04:22 Scientific Basis of Gender Differences in Sports

05:19 Case Studies and Real-World Examples

12:31 Physiological Differences: Heart and Muscle

18:26 Challenges in Fair Competition

19:56 The Debate on Inclusion and Fairness

23:26 Emotional and Societal Impacts

28:33 The Need for Compromise in Athletics

29:12 Trusting Science and Personal Experience

29:33 The Role of Emotions in Decision Making

29:44 The Importance of Truth in Advocacy

32:04 Defining Women's Sports

32:32 Challenges Faced by Trans Athletes

36:37 The Impact of Political Decisions

39:27 Empathy and Understanding in Sports

43:45 Advice for Fitness Professionals

49:27 The Importance of Open Conversations