The Lethal Library podcast

36:45

Welcome back to The Lethal Library! In this episode, Dani and Stephanie tackle the haunting case of Zacharia Street's 2003 murder in Idaho. Discover how three not-so-bright criminals—Jason Ryan McDermott, Rob Roy Wall Jr., and a teenage accomplice—botched an execution-style killing and delivered some ridiculous courtroom defenses. Expect our usual mix of sarcastic humor and jaw-dropping moments, plus a bizarre twist involving the 8th Amendment and constipation. Tune in for a wild ride! Contact The Lethal Library at TheLethalLibrary@gmail.com. Follow us on Instagram, Facebook, and TikTok!…

The Lethal Library

1
24. Teenage Trouble: Sarah Johnson's Shocking Murders 1:37:10

9 days ago1:37:10

1:37:10

Come along as Dani and Stephanie unravel the twisted tale of Sarah Johnson, a 16-year-old Idaho girl who brutally murdered her parents, Alan and Diane Johnson, in their upscale home. Known for her bratty attitude, Sarah's crime left a trail of evidence, from DNA on gloves to blood-spattered bathrobes. The podcast delves into the gripping investigation, messy courtroom drama, and bizarre defense strategies. With testimonies from neighbors, cellmates, and even her brother Matt, this episode of The Lethal Library is a deep dive into teenage rebellion turned deadly. Get ready for an episode full of dark humor and jaw-dropping moments. Contact The Lethal Library at TheLethalLibrary@gmail.com. Follow us on Instagram, Facebook, and TikTok!…

The Lethal Library

1
23. The Fedora Killer: The Notorious Crimes of Timothy Dunlap 1:03:58

16 days ago1:03:58

1:03:58

In this episode of The Lethal Library, hosts Dani and Stephanie go over a chilling and somewhat absurd case from Idaho in 1991. Timothy Dunlap, a man whose fashion sense (fedora and trench coat combo) is as questionable as his life choices, embarks on a criminal spree that leaves a young bank teller and his own girlfriend dead. We unravel how Dunlap's claimed desperation and hunger led to his heinous actions, how he bafflingly represented himself in court, and how he just won't stop talking to the press—making one ridiculous statement after another. Spoiler alert: it didn't go well for him. Dive into this roller coaster of idiocy, bad decisions, and cringe-worthy quotes. Contact The Lethal Library at TheLethalLibrary@gmail.com. Follow us on Instagram, Facebook, and TikTok!…

The Lethal Library

1
22. Old Time Misfortune: The Sensational Case of Clara O'Neill 50:48

23 days ago50:48

50:48

In this episode of The Lethal Library, hosts Stephanie and Dani dive into a true crime tale from Idaho's early 20th century archives. They explore the sensational and tragic story of Frederick Seward and Clara O'Neill. Frederick, lovesick and desperate, ends up committing a heinous crime in 1908 Moscow, Idaho. The duo brings to light all the gritty details from the time, including the shockingly direct headlines and vernacular of newspapers back then. From Frederick's tragic attempts at suicide to his ultimate fate at the gallows, this episode is packed with historical drama, yellow journalism, and a wild trip into old-timey Idaho. Tune in to learn about the twisted web of romance and murder that captivated a town and ended in a somber execution. Contact The Lethal Library at TheLethalLibrary@gmail.com. Follow us on Instagram, Facebook, and TikTok!…

The Lethal Library

1
21. Chaos in Jerome: The Charboneau Chronicles 1:48:23

28 days ago1:48:23

1:48:23

Welcome back to another wild ride with The Lethal Library! Stephanie and Dani dive into the bonkers case of JD Charboneau and Marilyn Arbaugh. This episode features everything from frying pans to crossbows. We track Charboneau's journey, Marilyn's shocking death, courtroom drama, and endless appeals. It's a whirlwind of relationships gone terribly wrong, shady lawyers, and even some spirit communication. And let's not forget Charboneau's mom's poetic outbursts! Catch up with us as we break down the absurdity and aftermath of this true crime rollercoaster. Enjoy the drama, relish the sarcasm, and bristle at the injustice—this one’s a doozy! Contact The Lethal Library at TheLethalLibrary@gmail.com. Follow us on Instagram, Facebook, and TikTok!…

The Lethal Library

1
20. Love and Lawlessness: The McKinney and Small Story 56:21

5 weeks ago56:21

56:21

In this episode, hosts Stephanie and Dani recount the disturbing true crime tale of Randy McKinney and Dovey Small. The couple's road trip from Arizona to Idaho in 1981 leads to a senseless murder fueled by drugs, desperation, and delusions of grandeur. Intended to be a quick stop in Malad, Idaho, to visit Small's sisters, the trip escalates into a plot to rob and kill their helpful friend Robert Bishop Jr. The aftermath includes chaotic decision-making, dramatic arrests, a "murder dog", and lengthy legal battles. Join us as we unravel this grim story and reflect on the lost lives and misguided choices. Contact The Lethal Library at TheLethalLibrary@gmail.com. Follow us on Instagram, Facebook, and TikTok!…

The Lethal Library

1
19. Kindness Betrayed: Two Heinous Crimes Against Two Idaho Couples 56:58

6 weeks ago56:58

56:58

In this episode of The Lethal Library, hosts Stephanie and Dani dive into two shorter but very disturbing true crime stories straight out of Idaho. First up, they unravel the tragic case of Bob and Idella Young, an elderly Nampa couple brutally murdered on Christmas Day 2003. The duo then explore another crime in a similar vein: the 1996 double homicide of another elderly couple, William Duke and Dalma Furman Bull, in Downey, Idaho. This time, there's some incredibly senseless violence over $30, a phone calling card, and a saxophone. Listen in as Stephanie and Dani navigate these grim tales with their usual blend of wit and biting commentary. Contact The Lethal Library at TheLethalLibrary@gmail.com. Follow us on Instagram, Facebook, and TikTok!…

The Lethal Library

1
18. Fiancée Frenzy: The Betrayal and Crimes of Dale Shackelford 1:34:44

7 weeks ago1:34:44

1:34:44

In this episode of The Lethal Library, hosts Stephanie and Dani dive into the convoluted case of Dale Shackelford. Beginning with a devastating fire that claimed the lives of Donna Fontaine and Fred Palahniuk, they explore how this tragic event unveiled a complex web of criminal activity. Follow along as they recount Shackelford's manipulative tactics, a press conference confession, and a trial filled with shocking testimonies and failed bomb plots. From tangled relationships and relentless legal battles to the final sentencing, this episode covers the rise and fall of a man whose criminal ambitions were far from successful. Enjoy the drama, the ridiculousness, and the ultimate downfall of a man who seriously overestimated his own craftiness. Contact The Lethal Library at TheLethalLibrary@gmail.com. Follow us on Instagram, Facebook, and TikTok!…

The Lethal Library

1
17. A Chain of Lies: The Christine Lott Case 39:23

8 weeks ago39:23

39:23

In this episode of The Lethal Library, Stephanie and Dani unpack the baffling true crime case of Christine Lott, a mother who vanished from Priest River, Idaho. The discussion spans the initial investigation, dubious actions by her husband Steve Lott, and the tragic discovery of Christine's remains over a decade later. Blending serious insights with dark humor, they highlight Steve's questionable alibis, family revelations, and the eventual courtroom drama that led to Steve's conviction. Tune in for a mix of sarcasm, heartbreak, and justice. Contact The Lethal Library at TheLethalLibrary@gmail.com. Follow us on Instagram, Facebook, and TikTok!…

The Lethal Library

1
16. From Trust to Tragedy: The Disappearance of Denise Williams 1:07:56

9 weeks ago1:07:56

1:07:56

Welcome to another wild ride in the Lethal Library with Stephanie and Dani as they unravel the tragic tale of Denise Williams. Picture this: a prison riot, heaps of drugs, and the unfortunate misuse of a young woman as an informant. Denise Williams, a 27-year-old informant for the Nampa Police Department, mysteriously vanished in September 1987, only for her body to resurface almost a year later. With details emerging about coercion by the police and a brutal murder orchestrated by drug dealers, this story brings out the gritty underbelly of a small Idaho town. Dive into the chaos, inconsistencies in police practices, and the aftermath, including a riot that ended with the murder of suspect Richard Holmes. This episode is packed with all the elements of a gritty crime saga! Contact The Lethal Library at TheLethalLibrary@gmail.com. Follow us on Instagram, Facebook, and TikTok!…

The Lethal Library

1
15. The Nampa Nightmare: A Tale of Divorce, Desperation, and a Disastrous Getaway 42:34

10 weeks ago42:34

42:34

15. The Nampa Nightmare: A Tale of Divorce, Desperation, and a Disastrous Getaway Welcome back to the Lethal Library with Stephanie and Danny as they dive into a harrowing crime tale from Nampa, Idaho. It's the tragic story of Colleen Hubbard, who faced fatal circumstances at the hands of her estranged husband, Roger Hubbard. Amidst contentious custody battles, Colleen's encounter with Roger escalated into violence, leading to a horrific police chase through the NNU campus. Listen as they recount the events, the senseless and brutal attack, and the eventual arrest and sentencing of Roger Hubbard. Expect dark humor, shocking details, and a local twist that will leave you shaken. Contact The Lethal Library at TheLethalLibrary@gmail.com. Follow us on Instagram, Facebook, and TikTok!…

The Lethal Library

1
14. Motorcycle Mayhem: Murder, Mischief, and Matrimony (Part Two) 48:00

11 weeks ago48:00

48:00

Join Dani and Steph for part two of the motorcycle gang episode focusing on the legal journey of Paradis, Gibson, and Evans - bikers ensnared in a convoluted murder case. This episode covers key testimonies, shifting stories, and courtroom drama that spans decades. From questionable pathologist practices to Paradis's complicated love life and finding out what happened to Evans AKA Igor, we dissect the twists and turns of this true crime saga. Listen in for a detailed look at the chaos and legal battles that define this case, sprinkled with our trademark dark humor and sarcasm. Contact The Lethal Library at TheLethalLibrary@gmail.com. Follow us on Instagram, Facebook, and TikTok!…

The Lethal Library

1
13. Motorcycle Mayhem: Murder, Mischief, and Matrimony (Part One) 1:03:11

12 weeks ago1:03:11

1:03:11

Join Steph and Dani in the Lethal Library as they dive into a twisted tale involving two murderers, two motorcycle gangs, and a convoluted crime spree spanning two states. Expect soap-opera levels of drama with suspects trying to set evidence on fire, bodies found in peculiar places, and an unforgettable makeshift love story. Despite questionable cleanup attempts and frantic marriages, the saga unravels in a whirlwind of testimonies, defense stunts, and unexpected verdicts. Tune in for part one of this gripping case full of an unbelievably tangled web of crimes. Contact The Lethal Library at TheLethalLibrary@gmail.com. Follow us on Instagram, Facebook, and TikTok!…

The Lethal Library

1
12. Wilderness Wake-Up: The Pratt Brothers' Idaho Crime Spree 1:14:19

13 weeks ago1:14:19

1:14:19

Welcome back to The Lethal Library with your hosts, Stephanie and Dani, as we go into a tale of crime in Northern Idaho during the 1980s! Picture this: home invasions, shootouts, and even a run-in with a genuine drug lord. Meet the Pratt brothers, James and Joseph, bumbling their way through a robbery turned chaotic hostage situation straight out of a low-budget horror movie. From demanding non-existent safes to awkwardly imitating Cuban accents (thanks, Scarface?), these guys were definitely trying to perform above their pay grade. Don’t miss the absurdity of this story as we recount one of Idaho’s most baffling crimes. Buckle up for sarcasm, dark humor, and a tale so messed up, you'll think we made it up. Contact The Lethal Library at TheLethalLibrary@gmail.com. Follow us on Instagram, Facebook, and TikTok!…

The Lethal Library

1
11. Nature vs. Nurture: The Curious Case of Keith Eugene Wells 1:00:08

14 weeks ago1:00:08