Best Catching The Long Island Serial Killer Podcasts (2025)

1
What Did You HEAR About Your CHEATING WIFE After The BREAKUP? 41:09

20h ago41:09

41:09

What Did You HEAR About Your CHEATING WIFE After The BREAKUP? Support this podcast at — https://redcircle.com/true-crime-podcast-2025-real-police-interrogations-911-calls-tru/exclusive-content Advertising Inquiries: https://redcircle.com/brands Privacy & Opt-Out: https://redcircle.com/privacyBy Best True Crime Documentaries - Serial Killer Documentaries 2025 - Podcast

1
Predator Realizes He's Going To Prison For Life - The Mennonite Murder by Mark Gooch 49:05

23h ago49:05

49:05

Predator Realizes He's Going To Prison For Life - The Mennonite Murder by Mark Gooch 🚨 He drove 400 miles in cold blood… Mark Gooch abducted a stranger from church and left her body in the Arizona wilderness. 🎧 Now streaming: The chilling case of Mark Gooch. #TrueCrime #MarkGooch #MennoniteMurder #Kidnapping #Podcast In January 2020, Sasha Krause, …

1
He Hid a Head in His Closet: The Brian Cohee Jr. Case 1:42:26

2d ago1:42:26

1:42:26

He Hid a Head in His Closet: The Brian Cohee Jr. Case "He said he just wanted to know what murder felt like… then he did it." In February 2021, 19‑year‑old Brian Cohee Jr. stalked 69‑year‑old Warren Barnes—a beloved homeless man known as “The Reading Man”—and stabbed him to death under a highway overpass in Grand Junction, Colorado. After decapitat…

1
“I Still Feel Rex Is Here” — Gilgo Killers Wife, Asa Ellerup’s Grief and Denial, Analyzed by the FBI-WEEK IN REVIEW 18:15

2d ago18:15

18:15

Welcome to the "Week in Review," where we delve into the true stories behind this week's headlines. Your host, Tony Brueski, joins hands with a rotating roster of guests, sharing their insights and analysis on a collection of intriguing, perplexing, and often chilling stories that made the news. This is not your average news recap. With the sharp i…

1
The Most Chilling Story You've NEVER Heard Of 44:02

2d ago44:02

44:02

The Most Chilling Story You've NEVER Heard Of In this unsolved mystery documentary, we're covering the chilling true story behind the disappearance of Khayman Welch. Khayman "Khay" Welch completely vanished without a trace on August 12, 2020 at Weaver's Needle Vista Viewpoint, disappearing into the notorious Superstition Mountains. The Superstition…

1
Halloween Killer Realizes He's Finally Been Caught Years Later 1:41:10

2d ago1:41:10

1:41:10

Halloween Killer Realizes He's Finally Been Caught Years Later On Halloween night 2014, 22-year-old Chelsea Bruck disappeared after attending a costume party in Frenchtown Township, Michigan. She was last seen in a Poison Ivy outfit. Months later, her body was discovered in a wooded area, sparking questions that cut deeper than any costume. The pri…

1
Demons Told Her To Dismembered and Cook Her Husband's Body After Murdering Him (True Crime Documentary) 26:06

3d ago26:06

26:06

Demons Told Her To Dismembered and Cook Her Husband's Body After Murdering Him (True Crime Documentary) This chilling true crime documentary explores the horrifying case of a woman who claimed demonic voices compelled her to commit an unspeakable act. After murdering her husband, she dismembered and cooked his body, creating a case that shocked inv…

1
Inside the Mind of Asa Ellerup: FBI Profiler Breaks Down the Gilgo Beach Killer’s Home Life 59:55

3d ago59:55

59:55

Inside the Mind of Asa Ellerup: FBI Profiler Breaks Down the Gilgo Beach Killer’s Home Life In this special full-length edition of Hidden Killers, Tony Brueski is joined by Robin Dreeke—retired FBI Special Agent and former chief of the Counterintelligence Behavioral Analysis Program—for a masterclass in psychological profiling, emotional survival, …

1
"He's My Hero" - Gilgo Beach Killer's Wife Defends Rex Heuermann Despite DNA on Bodies | Psychologist Reacts 43:55

3d ago43:55

43:55

"He's My Hero" - Gilgo Beach Killer's Wife Defends Rex Heuermann Despite DNA on Bodies | Psychologist Reacts In this deeply disturbing analysis of the Peacock documentary, psychotherapist Shavaun Scott and I decode the most baffling true crime mystery: How did Rex Heuermann's family NOT KNOW he was allegedly the Long Island Serial Killer? We examin…

1
FULL Police Interrogation of the SCUMBAG Seth Welch The Father Who Starved His Baby to Death 47:38

3d ago47:38

47:38

FULL Police Interrogation of the SCUMBAG Seth Welch The Father Who Starved His Baby to Death Full Police Interrogation of Seth Welch, the man who neglected his newborn child by not feeding her. The presence of THC was also found in the newborn child's system. The child died of chronic malnutrition. Their house was also found with vermin, insects, a…

1
Prison Guard's Paranormal Experiences Stories 58:36

4d ago58:36

58:36

Prison Guard's Paranormal Experiences Stories Support this podcast at — https://redcircle.com/true-crime-podcast-2025-real-police-interrogations-911-calls-tru/exclusive-content Advertising Inquiries: https://redcircle.com/brands Privacy & Opt-Out: https://redcircle.com/privacyBy Best True Crime Documentaries - Serial Killer Documentaries 2025 - Podcast

1
What’s The CRAZIEST Time Karma Exposed A “Victim” As The Real Abuser — Mid-Testimony? 47:38

4d ago47:38

47:38

What’s The CRAZIEST Time Karma Exposed A “Victim” As The Real Abuser — Mid-Testimony? Support this podcast at — https://redcircle.com/true-crime-podcast-2025-real-police-interrogations-911-calls-tru/exclusive-content Advertising Inquiries: https://redcircle.com/brands Privacy & Opt-Out: https://redcircle.com/privacy…

1
“Telling Him I Love Him Hurts Him” — Gilgo Killer's Wife, Asa Ellerup’s Most Bizarre Statement Yet 19:10

4d ago19:10

19:10

“Telling Him I Love Him Hurts Him” — Gilgo Killer's Wife, Asa Ellerup’s Most Bizarre Statement Yet In this final segment, Tony Brueski and retired FBI Special Agent Robin Dreeke turn their focus toward the most emotionally revealing clips from the Peacock documentary, featuring Asa Ellerup’s reaction to her husband Rex Heuermann’s arrest—and her in…

1
Disciples of Destruction: The Mont Vernon Machete Murders 1:30:37

4d ago1:30:37

1:30:37

Disciples of Destruction: The Mont Vernon Machete Murders 36 machete blows. A little girl who played dead. This is the Mont Vernon massacre. On October 4, 2009, Steven Spader (17) and Christopher Gribble (19) led a brutal home invasion in Mont Vernon, New Hampshire. The victims—42-year-old Kimberly Cates and her 11-year-old daughter, Jaimie—were ra…

1
The Blue Moon Killer: Donald Hartung and the Ritualistic Family Massacre 52:12

4d ago52:12

52:12

The Blue Moon Killer: Donald Hartung and the Ritualistic Family Massacre 🌕 Bodies buried under blankets in a ritual scene… but it was all for money. He was the half‑brother with a grudge—and a chilling jailhouse confession. 🎧 Now streaming: The Blue Moon Killer – Inside Donald Hartung’s atrocity. #TrueCrime #BlueMoonKiller #DonaldHartung #Podcast I…

1
"I Can Love AND Hate My Dad" - Rex Heuermann's Daughter's HEARTBREAKING Journey to Accepting Truth 20:52

4d ago20:52

20:52

"I Can Love AND Hate My Dad" - Rex Heuermann's Daughter's HEARTBREAKING Journey to Accepting Truth This is the most psychologically complex footage from any true crime documentary - a daughter processing in REAL TIME that her father might be a serial killer. Psychotherapist Shavaun Scott helps us understand Victoria Heuermann's impossible journey. …

1
The Teen Who Buried a Girl: Alyssa Bustamante’s Dark Fantasy 2:03:43

5d ago2:03:43

2:03:43

The Teen Who Buried a Girl: Alyssa Bustamante’s Dark Fantasy 📝 “It was amazing… it was pretty enjoyable.” That’s what Alyssa Bustamante wrote in her diary after killing her 9-year-old neighbor—just to experience it. 🎧 Now streaming: The Chilling Case of Alyssa Bustamante. #TrueCrime #AlyssaBustamante #ThrillKiller #Podcast In October 2009, 15-year-…

1
Charles Sobhraj: The Serpent and Bikini Killer of the Hippie Trail 52:41

5d ago52:41

52:41

Charles Sobhraj: The Serpent and Bikini Killer of the Hippie Trail 🕵️‍♂️ He charmed his victims… then killed them. Charles Sobhraj, known as The Bikini Killer and The Serpent, vanished Western backpackers across Asia in the 1970s. 🎧 Now streaming: the untold story of his crimes, escapes, and shocking release. #TrueCrime #BikiniKiller #CharlesSobhra…

1
“I Still Feel Rex Is Here” — Gilgo Killer's Wife, Asa Ellerup’s Grief and Denial, Analyzed by the FBI 18:10

5d ago18:10

18:10

“I Still Feel Rex Is Here” — Gilgo Killer's Wife, Asa Ellerup’s Grief and Denial, Analyzed by the FBI In Segment 3, we enter the emotional core of the Gilgo Beach case. As Asa Ellerup walks through the remnants of her raided home, she says something haunting: “I still feel Rex is here.” It’s not just grief—it’s denial, memory, and psychological tra…

1
What is the most disturbing death bed confession you’ve ever heard? 1:00:17

5d ago1:00:17

1:00:17

What is the most disturbing death bed confession you’ve ever heard? Support this podcast at — https://redcircle.com/true-crime-podcast-2025-real-police-interrogations-911-calls-tru/exclusive-content Advertising Inquiries: https://redcircle.com/brands Privacy & Opt-Out: https://redcircle.com/privacyBy Best True Crime Documentaries - Serial Killer Documentaries 2025 - Podcast

1
Body Language Expert: Why Rex Heuermann's Wife CLOSES HER EYES When Confronted With Evidence 24:11

5d ago24:11

24:11

Body Language Expert: Why Rex Heuermann's Wife CLOSES HER EYES When Confronted With Evidence WARNING: This footage contains the actual voice of accused serial killer Rex Heuermann calling his wife from jail. What's more disturbing than his words is what ISN'T said - and what his wife reveals about their twisted dynamic. Psychotherapist Shavaun Scot…

1
Hot Car Baby-Death - Interrogation of Another Florida Super Mom (Megan Dauphin) 51:41

5d ago51:41

51:41

Hot Car Baby-Death - Interrogation of Another Florida Super Mom (Megan Dauphin) Megan Elizabeth Dauphin, the SUPERMOM in question, was 30 years old at that time in question. Megan forgot the 7-week-old baby in the car after she went to the store earlier that September 2, 2020 morning in Panama City, Florida. She had left the house earlier that morn…

1
I Shouldn’t Be Alive: Real Stories of Almost Dying 53:17

5d ago53:17

53:17

Real Life Almost Killed Experience Stories “I Shouldn’t Be Alive: Real Stories of Almost Dying” 💀 "I looked death in the face... and somehow lived." From wild animal attacks to deadly crashes, these are the stories of people who almost didn’t make it out alive. 🎧 New episode: Real Life Almost Killed Stories. #SurvivalStories #NearDeath #TrueStoryPo…

1
Zombie Apocalypse Murders: The Eldon Samuel Case 1:33:12

5d ago1:33:12

1:33:12

Zombie Apocalypse Murders: The Eldon Samuel Case 🧟 “He told me to kill them — to stop the zombie apocalypse.” A 14-year-old with a gun. A father who believed in monsters. A family gone tragic. The Zombie Apocalypse Murders: Eldon Samuel’s story 🎧 Now streaming. #TrueCrime #JuvenileMurder #EldonSamuel #ZombieMurder #Podcast At just 14 years old, Eld…

1
“He Saved Us” — Or Did He? Gilgo Killer's Wife, Asa Ellerup’s Love Story Examined by FBI Profiler 23:54

6d ago23:54

23:54

“He Saved Us” — Or Did He? Gilgo Killer's Wife, Asa Ellerup’s Love Story Examined by FBI Profiler In Segment 2 of our deep-dive into the Gilgo Beach case, Tony Brueski and retired FBI Special Agent Robin Dreeke turn their focus to the beginning — the origin story of Asa Ellerup and Rex Heuermann’s relationship. What started as an act of kindness du…

1
Babysitter Laughs After Killing Baby & Taking Lifeless Body to McDonald's 1:16:20

6d ago1:16:20

1:16:20

Babysitter Laughs After Killing Baby & Taking Lifeless Body to McDonald's 👶 She dressed the baby, put him in a car seat…and gave him back dead. How did a babysitter with warning signs spiral into homicide? 🎧 The Marissa Tietsort Case — now streaming. #TrueCrime #MarissaTietsort #BabyMurder #WisconsinCrime #Podcast Babysitter Laughs After Killing Ba…

1
4-Year-Old Refuses to Die After Mass Killer Dad Goes on Rampage - Michael Brian Miller Police Interrogation 59:34

6d ago59:34

59:34

4-Year-Old Refuses to Die After Mass Killer Dad Goes on Rampage - Michael Brian Miller Police Interrogation In May 2009, a gruesome tragedy struck a suburban Glendale neighborhood: Michael Brian Miller fatally stabbed his wife and 10-year-old daughter, then attacked his 4-year-old son. Calling 911, he calmly reported the murders, citing delusions—s…

1
Rex Heuermann's Wife SHOWS OFF Secret Rooms She Was BANNED From Entering | "Nothing Was Off Limits" 18:48

6d ago18:48

18:48

Rex Heuermann's Wife SHOWS OFF Secret Rooms She Was BANNED From Entering | "Nothing Was Off Limits" This footage will make you question everything about denial and control. Psychotherapist Shavaun Scott analyzes the most contradictory statements ever captured as Rex Heuermann's wife gives a tour of rooms she was BANNED from entering while claiming …

1
Mom Horrified After Son Failed Polygraph - The Crimes Of Kenneth Jones 1:09:21

7d ago1:09:21

1:09:21

Mom Horrified After Son Failed Polygraph - The Crimes Of Kenneth Jones 🚨 Mom’s worst nightmare: her son fails a lie detector. What started as a routine test became a family fracture—and one of the most shocking confessions she could never unhear. 🎧 Listen now. #TrueCrime #PolygraphFail #KennethJones #Podcast Imagine discovering the truth about your…

1
Vanished in the Wilderness: The Michael Madden Mystery 1:01:29

7d ago1:01:29

1:01:29

Vanished in the Wilderness: The Michael Madden Mystery 🚨 He was experienced. He left a plan. He never came back. Michael Madden walked into Stanislaus National Forest and vanished—leaving behind zero trace. Not a shoe. Not a scent. Not a clue. 🎧 The trail went cold. But the mystery runs deep. #MissingPersons #MichaelMadden #UnsolvedMystery #TrueCri…

1
10 Signs Alleged Gilgo Beach Killer, Rex Heuermann’s Family Missed — Behavioral Analysis from the FBI 16:15

7d ago16:15

16:15

10 Signs Alleged Gilgo Beach Killer, Rex Heuermann’s Family Missed — Behavioral Analysis from the FBI In this gripping first segment, retired FBI Special Agent Robin Dreeke—former chief of the Counterintelligence Behavioral Analysis Program—joins Tony Brueski to explore the disturbing paradox at the center of the Gilgo Beach case: How did Rex Heuer…

1
"I Finally Got Him, He's Mine" - Rex Heuermann's Wife STILL Worships Accused Gilgo Beach Killer 20:13

7d ago20:13

20:13

"I Finally Got Him, He's Mine" - Rex Heuermann's Wife STILL Worships Accused Gilgo Beach Killer This might be the most disturbing analysis of denial ever captured on film. Psychotherapist Shavaun Scott joins me to decode footage from the Peacock documentary that reveals how Rex Heuermann didn't just hunt his victims - he carefully selected and groo…

1
Female Officer’s Forbidden Affair with Prisoner – Shocking Scandal Exposed 1:36:24

7d ago1:36:24

1:36:24

Female Officer’s Forbidden Affair with Prisoner – Shocking Scandal Exposed When a trusted correctional officer crosses the line, the consequences are severe. This gripping case reveals how a female officer risked everything for a forbidden romance with an inmate—a scandal that led to her downfall. What started as harmless conversations quickly esca…

1
When Killers Realize It's Over: Raw Police Interrogation Murderer Reaction Compilation 1:22:28

8d ago1:22:28

1:22:28

When Killers Realize It's Over: Raw Police Interrogation Murderer Reaction Compilation Some moments in true crime are unforgettable—none more so than the second a killer realizes it’s over. This episode dives into a chilling compilation of real police interrogations, capturing the exact moment suspects break. From calculated silence to sudden emoti…

1
She Murdered and Dismembered a Disabled Man — Then Lived With the Body 1:30:21

8d ago1:30:21

1:30:21

She Murdered and Dismembered a Disabled Man — Then Lived With the Body 🚨 She killed him. Cut him to pieces... and kept him with her for months. This is the shocking story of Penny Pospisil and the trailer-of-terror that hid a dead man. 🎧 Listen now. #TrueCrime #PennyPospisil #RVHorror #Podcast In the summer of 2018, Penny Pospisil was living with h…

1
Living With a Serial Killer FBI Expert Explains How Rex Heuermann Hid Seven Murders From Family-WEEK IN REVIEW 16:45

8d ago16:45

16:45

Welcome to the "Week in Review," where we delve into the true stories behind this week's headlines. Your host, Tony Brueski, joins hands with a rotating roster of guests, sharing their insights and analysis on a collection of intriguing, perplexing, and often chilling stories that made the news. This is not your average news recap. With the sharp i…

1
FBI Profiler Why Gilgo Beach Killer Kept Murder Trophies and a Kill Manual for 20 Years-WEEK IN REVIEW 12:53

8d ago12:53

12:53

Welcome to the "Week in Review," where we delve into the true stories behind this week's headlines. Your host, Tony Brueski, joins hands with a rotating roster of guests, sharing their insights and analysis on a collection of intriguing, perplexing, and often chilling stories that made the news. This is not your average news recap. With the sharp i…

1
She Called Him 'Hero' While He Allegedly Killed 7 Women: FBI Expert Analyzes Asa Ellerup's Denial 29:09

12d ago29:09

29:09

She Called Him 'Hero' While He Allegedly Killed 7 Women: FBI Expert Analyzes Asa Ellerup's Denial Description: In one of the most psychologically complex aspects of the Gilgo Beach murders case, Asa Ellerup continues to stand by her husband Rex Heuermann, calling him her "hero" despite charges he murdered seven women. She describes visiting him in …

1
Living With a Serial Killer: FBI Expert Explains How Rex Heuermann Hid 7 Murders From Family 16:40

13d ago16:40

16:40

Living With a Serial Killer: FBI Expert Explains How Rex Heuermann Hid 7 Murders From Family Description: How does a man accused of brutally murdering seven women over three decades hide such horrific crimes from the family sleeping under the same roof? In this eye-opening interview, former FBI Special Agent Robin Dreeke, who led the Bureau's Behav…

1
Profiler: Why Gilgo Beach Killer Kept Murder Trophies and a 'Kill Manual' for 20 Years 12:47

14d ago12:47

12:47

Profiler: Why Gilgo Beach Killer Kept Murder Trophies and a 'Kill Manual' for 20 Years Description: In this chilling episode, retired FBI Special Agent and former head of the Behavioral Analysis Program Robin Dreeke reveals the dark psychology behind Rex Heuermann's most damning evidence - the murder planning document discovered on his computer and…

1
Rex Heuermanns Wife Calls Serial Killer Husband Her Hero - 5 Most Disturbing Quotes From New Documentary-WEEK IN REVIEW 25:41

15d ago25:41

25:41

Welcome to the "Week in Review," where we delve into the true stories behind this week's headlines. Your host, Tony Brueski, joins hands with a rotating roster of guests, sharing their insights and analysis on a collection of intriguing, perplexing, and often chilling stories that made the news. This is not your average news recap. With the sharp i…

1
Gilgo Beach Killers Wife Claims He's INNOCENT: 5 Psychological Red Flags-WEEK IN REVIEW 15:11

16d ago15:11

15:11

Welcome to the "Week in Review," where we delve into the true stories behind this week's headlines. Your host, Tony Brueski, joins hands with a rotating roster of guests, sharing their insights and analysis on a collection of intriguing, perplexing, and often chilling stories that made the news. This is not your average news recap. With the sharp i…

1
Big Breakdown - Alleged Gilgo Beach Killer's Wife Calls Her Husband Rex Heuermann, A 'Hero' 40:27

17d ago40:27

40:27

Big Breakdown - Alleged Gilgo Beach Killer's Wife Calls Her Husband Rex Heuermann, A 'Hero' This explosive episode examines the shocking public statements made by Asa Ellerup, wife of accused Gilgo Beach serial killer Rex Heuermann, in which she refers to her husband as a "hero" despite the mounting evidence against him. Our expert panel analyzes t…

1
Gilgo Beach Killer's Wife Claims He's INNOCENT - Five Psychological Red Flags She IGNORED 15:06

19d ago15:06

15:06

Gilgo Beach Killer's Wife Claims He's INNOCENT - Five Psychological Red Flags She IGNORED Rex Heuermann's wife Asa Ellerup finally breaks her silence in the explosive Peacock documentary "The Gilgo Beach Killer: House of Secrets," revealing disturbing details about the secret basement room that prosecutors say held the key to understanding the alle…

1
Rex Heuermann's Wife Calls Serial Killer Husband Her 'Hero' - 5 Most Disturbing Quotes From New Documentary 25:36

20d ago25:36

25:36

Rex Heuermann's Wife Calls Serial Killer Husband Her 'Hero' - 5 Most Disturbing Quotes From New Documentary The Gilgo Beach serial killer case has taken a shocking turn with the release of Peacock's documentary "The Gilgo Beach Killer: House of Secrets," featuring the first-ever interviews with Rex Heuermann's family. In this deep dive analysis, we…

1
Son Realizes He Killed His Father 50:49

1M ago50:49

50:49

Son Realizes He Killed His Father In Lexington Township on January 24, 2021, Hardy Robert Wills-Traxler confessed to killing his father, Bruce Traxler, and burning the shed where his body was found. Hardy, who struggled with mental illness, believed his father was a threat, though no evidence supported this. During questioning, his confused answers…

1
How a Predator Finally Met Karma 36:47

2M ago36:47

36:47

How a Predator Finally Met Karma A man from Airway Heights, described as extraordinarily foolish, fled when police arrived to confront him about a domestic violence incident. He tried to hide behind a tree, a tactic that failed thanks to a neighbor tipping off authorities. His troubles only escalated after arrest—he attempted to remove his restrain…

1
The Moment She Realized She Killed Her Newborn 23:16

2M ago23:16

23:16

The Moment She Realized She Killed Her Newborn Mothers are often seen as protective angels who will do anything to protect their children, but in this case, she became her child's worst enemy. Officers were immediately dispatched to the location after receiving a 911 call about a mother contemplating murder. Viewer discretion is advised, as what yo…

Podcasts Worth a Listen

Catching The Long Island Serial Killer Podcasts

Podcasts Worth a Listen

Quick Reference Guide